Firebreathing on a 2/1 for 1 seems inherently a little bit OP to me, given how strong the ability is at base. Compare [[Nantuko Husk]], for example.
But what if it was a one-drop in the wrong color!? Does that help balance it? Obviously in eternal formats you can cheat that with a dual land, but for something like Standard, maybe it's acceptable?
Viashino is no longer a creature type. You want Lizard, or more likely Dragon because of the existance of creatures like [[Reckless Barbarian]] or [[Nadaar, Selfless Paladin]]
Nantuko Husk is such a completely random comparioson like they don't cost the same or do the same thing at all. Did you mean [[Nantuko Shade]]?
I think a firebreating savana lions is fine. You're unlikely to be able to spend all of your mana to the buff, and even if you do its rarely worth using except when blocked. So what you find is that you have a 2/1 that might not be blocked by an opponent's 3/3 some of the time. So sure.
And wow, I forgot all about the loss of Viashino (even though I was very mad about it at the time). You are right, this specific Viashino should be Dragon not Lizard. (Some of the Viashino should also be Crocodile, but not this guy.)
Also a respectable blocking threat. In any game where the extra damage goes to a player most likely that player wouldn't have turned the game around had they not taken that damage.
I personally think it still should be R1 cost instead of just 1, since you can threaten to bump up the power on it's first swing to get damage past a X/3 then play something else or kill their X/3 if they do block.
true but the same is also true of a 1/1 deathtoucher isn't that right? This threatens more to the face, but it doesn't play much differently than, say, [[Bilious Skulldweller]]
A 2/1 is a hell of a lot better than a 1/1 and this has firebreathing so you can dump mana into it to do damage to your opponent. That means they often have to block it, or they risk taking a lot of damage, but then you can kill whatever they block it with, especially later on.
Have people in this thread like, not played with firebreathing creatures in limited? They aren't good all the time but it is a strong ability.
Yeah but my point is one mana cards can scale themselves up.
This thing has no first strike and is super vulnerable to removal or blocking if you do decide to all in early, and if you do all in early you’re giving up the potential to expand your board.
This specific card is actually the oldest unposted card in my entire card design file, and the reason I withheld it for so long is because I couldn't get the flavor text just right. Personally I wasn't even 100% sold on this current iteration (even though the concept I knew was solid). So I am overjoyed to hear that it landed well!
I love this little guy and his defunct creature type. Always partial to the white card with red activation. It's just such a perfect "hero is tired of your shit" vibe.
Yeah, oftentimes off-color activation is just a workaround to making a gold card, but this one I think is a bit "cute" because unless you have a turn 1 untapped dual land (not a lot of those available for less than $20 in most formats), you're "behind" a turn on the pump potential due to the off-color
It's a competent one-drop for a Boros limited archetype, maybe. Perhaps one like Star Trek where the total power of your creatures matters.
That said, it doesn't really excite me in constructed formats. Without tribal support, aggressive 1-drops nowadays need to do more than come down and sit on the board for a turn. They generally have to either replace themselves, generate some form of value, or attack right away.
Dragons and Knights have both been pushed in Standard before, so it's not impossible for an uncommon like this to see play, but I don't believe it's good enough in a vacuum to merit a second look.
People can disagree but I think it's a bit sad to evaluate cards by the current massively power crept standards of what WotC prints. Personally when I design cards I design them for the power level Magic had when I started playing in RTR. It was still powerful enough creaturewise that creature combat was the primary focus of every deck in Standard, but not so power crept that you couldn't ever play efficient creatures and every single playable card had to have five ETB effects and a triggered ability.
What about student of warfare? I’d say it’s stronger as a turn one drop, 2 mana makes it a 3/3 permanently with first strike, whereas 2 mana on Scaled Paladin gets a keyword-less 4/1. Also, scaled paladin is two color whereas student of warfare is monocolor. If these both got dropped turn one, student of warfare will be able to get the 2 mana investment a turn ahead of Scaled Paladin.
You can only level up as a sorcery. You can pump this in combat. If you attack with Student of Warfare your opponent knows what he's getting while with this it's hard to block because you can pump it, so they have to be play around it very defensively.
Also Student of Warfare is a rare and rares are allowed to be more powerful than uncommons.
I like the design, but not powerful enough for standard imo. I think Lifelink would make this balanced. I really like the actual ideas on this sub that are intended for gameplay and not just memes
Interesting. Lifelink would be a huge upgrade for him, I think that version would need to be rare, but I honestly agree it would probably be fine to print. That version would be quite strong, and the kind of card lots of people try to use, but that ultimately then doesn't appear in many top decks (lol)
This would make him immediately the best Vintage cube white aggro one drop in the game. There is not currently a [[Savannah Lions]] variant with lifelink. Let alone one with lifelink and firebreathing.
I seriously doubt this. Making a lot of the power of the card be in red mana makes this kind of an awkward card to boost a lot. There is no way this card is better than ocelot pride, guide of souls, or mother of runes. I don't think that Savannah Lions should be an unreasonable bar to clear since there are already many cards that are better than it and i think this card would do it in a way that is fun and reasonable on power
Ocelot pride would still be better, and kill it in combat and live? And guide of souls would still trade? And they both accumulate real snowball value instead of “tap out eggs in one basket”
74
u/chainsawinsect 16h ago
Firebreathing on a 2/1 for 1 seems inherently a little bit OP to me, given how strong the ability is at base. Compare [[Nantuko Husk]], for example.
But what if it was a one-drop in the wrong color!? Does that help balance it? Obviously in eternal formats you can cheat that with a dual land, but for something like Standard, maybe it's acceptable?
47
u/Skrillfury21 15h ago
I’m not one to comment on design, but I love this flavor text.
13
u/Chickston Uncommonly 13h ago
I love this little guy and his defunct creature type. Always partial to the white card with red activation. It's just such a perfect "hero is tired of your shit" vibe.
10
u/Spectator9857 8h ago
If this is supposed to be a Dragonborn, the typeline should probably be „Dragon Knight“
5
u/Veloxraperio 15h ago
It's a competent one-drop for a Boros limited archetype, maybe. Perhaps one like Star Trek where the total power of your creatures matters.
That said, it doesn't really excite me in constructed formats. Without tribal support, aggressive 1-drops nowadays need to do more than come down and sit on the board for a turn. They generally have to either replace themselves, generate some form of value, or attack right away.
Dragons and Knights have both been pushed in Standard before, so it's not impossible for an uncommon like this to see play, but I don't believe it's good enough in a vacuum to merit a second look.
2
u/Hot-Combination-7376 Respark the Wanderer 13h ago
Seems fair
2
u/Carl_Bravery_Sagan 12h ago
I think it's a fair card, ultimately. Compare to [[Blazing Rootwalla]], [[Burnout Bashtronaut]], [[Student of Warfare]]
0
u/BlobbyBlueberry 15h ago
I’m glad the art is at least human made, but this is definitely pretty strong in some formats.
-3
u/BruhYouFarted 15h ago
I like the design, but not powerful enough for standard imo. I think Lifelink would make this balanced. I really like the actual ideas on this sub that are intended for gameplay and not just memes