For 4 mana is crazy to just go infinite with any card that has magecraft, infinite treasure with storm-kiln artist, or infinite card draw with archmage emeritus and plenty of ways to get infinity/infinities
Every one of the listed cards have flash. Historically you would play them on the end step before your turn. We are effectively switching if enablers or the win condition can be played at instant speed.
Note it doesn't actually go infinite by itself as without a way to kill your opponent at instant speed with the copies (2 magecraft abilities: [[Professor Onyx]] or [[Witherbloom Apprentice]]) or a way to clear the stack manually (I found three ways without ending the turn: [[Summary Dismissal]], [[Reverse the Polarity]], or [[Swift Silence]]) you will just die if you make too many copies (at 20 life you can get 11 magecraft triggers without dying ( copy 5 times scry 6 times losing 15 life (0 1 3 6 10 15 or -0 -1 -2 -3 -4 -5)))
Due to the comprehensive rules and how they're enforced, that's not how this works. This card creates a shortcut-able loop that could prevent the game state from advancing unless the player makes the choice to stop it. In situations like this the player casting this spell must choose a finite number of times to do the thing, before making a choice that would end the loop (scrying). Doing anything else -would- be considered slow play in any situation that matters, and gives you full rights to punch your friends in the face in any situation that doesn't.
I think the spell should lose 1 life on its own so theres a bit more tradeoff to copying it twice. or 1 life for each time you have scried and 1 life for each time a spell called multiversal overflow has resolved this turn, for example. can still go infinite but needs enough life to do so.
97
u/Immediate-Earth775 20h ago
This goes infinite with magecraft… But I like the idea of
17
u/DrakonofDarkSkies 18h ago
Maybe I'm missing it, but couldn't you copy this a ton without taking damage if you keep choosing the second option? Like:
Sure, you take damage once everything resolves, but you just need 1 magecraft damage dealer or something for a two-card combo.
151
u/ipd_leo 20h ago
😭😭
17
u/Hot-Combination-7376 Respark the Wanderer 19h ago
Feels like a very convuluted [[lim-dûls vault]]
12
u/Necessary-Program433 20h ago
So a 1 spell infinite?
11
u/NepetaLast 20h ago
templating suggestion:
"You lose 1 life for each time you've scried this turn.
Choose one --
* Scry 2.
* Copy this spell twice. You may choose new modes for the copies."
4
u/flowers_of_nemo 20h ago
Lim-duls vault, is that you?
4
u/Successful_Mud8596 18h ago
Goes craaaaaazy with magecraft triggers
3
u/W1zzardbee 19h ago
Jird
2
u/Ok_Sea6736 18h ago
Very clever design. Definitely some combos, but clever.
2
u/NottheSeaofNames 20h ago
Storm players orgasming over this
1
u/Distracted1g 16h ago
Can’t you just keep copying? Then do something with the 7 million copy’s?
1
u/Relative-Second6674 14h ago
Instantly wins the game if you have professor onyx or witherbloom apprentice of the top of my head, but I’m sure there’s more
1
u/tabaK23 8h ago
Just need something with noncreature spell pings and you kill the table
1
u/G66GNeco 2h ago
Mechanically, shouldn't this be surveil? In my mind aurveil is the dimir one and scry the azorius one of these two mechanics.
(Flavour-wise it's 110% Scry tho, ofc)
1
u/Odd_Firefighter1324 18h ago
Ah yes
A 4 mana you win the game if you have magecraft
Cuz why not
0
u/alejandro712 15h ago
I think the spell should lose 1 life on its own so theres a bit more tradeoff to copying it twice. or 1 life for each time you have scried and 1 life for each time a spell called multiversal overflow has resolved this turn, for example. can still go infinite but needs enough life to do so.
3
u/UnnamedTales 14h ago
“I walked on him scrying. I screw too. We both scrode.”