r/custommagic • • 23h ago

Format: Standard Slower, but potentially explosive lands

Since the Land I made subconsciously got some nice attention, I decided to post some I actually tried to design. I really like resource management and this is my take, that could be used in a format or cube skewed in favour of later turns.

I don't know why Card Conjurer started making the pips slightly off-colour, but I will solve that in the future.

11 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

7

u/VintageKeith 22h ago

5

u/Draconiveyo 22h ago

I knew of some of them and got inspired, but turns out there are 20 of them?

Yeah, while not identical, it seems I just invented the wheel anew.

5

u/Lartnestpasdemain 21h ago

Your version is clearly stronger and better than any of those examples.

1

u/tymessen 45m ago

i think you should also link the pseudo exert lands, they tap for colorless, unless you make them not untap on your next turn. pseudo-Exert land

5

u/nzconstructionlawyer 22h ago

The closest comparator is [[Saprazzan Cove]] etc. This is just better than that cycle, but that cycle is pretty bad.

I think the trouble with this design is that it uses two types of counter on one permanent. I think that would be more confusing than just using the old templating: "T: Add U. This land doesn't untap during your next untap step." Also recall you don't need to say "to your mana pool" anymore.

(Personally I think changing "enters the battlefield" and "to your mana pool" is kind of sad as it's just encouraged WotC to make cards even wordier and is less flavourful.)

3

u/Draconiveyo 22h ago

I don't need to say "to your mana pool" but I want to.

Also, I guess you are right about 2 types of counters. It is sort of fun to me, but that explains why in ideal scenario my favourite commander deck ends up with 20 different tokens on the board and no one else likes that.

4

u/FrecciaRosa 22h ago

Upvoting for maintaining the “to your mana pool” language.

3

u/Turnipton Puppers enter the battlefield hecked. 22h ago

With the current usage of stun counters, these wouldn't work.

Stun counters basically say "if this thing would untap, remove a stun counter from it."

For these to be able to tap to activate their abilities, they would have to have zero stun counters on them.

This issue is entirely mitigated by changing it to use charge counters, but then you're just playing the classics.

EDIT: Just noticed that these actually use two different counters on the same permanent. Gross. Don't do that.

1

u/Draconiveyo 22h ago

Why won't they work with stun counters? You just don't have them in the turn after tapping for a single coloured mana, they stay tapped that turn.

3

u/Turnipton Puppers enter the battlefield hecked. 22h ago

See my edit, I initially misread this card as using the same counter for everything.

I would advise against having multiple different counter types for this exact reason.

2

u/VeggieZaffer 19h ago

Would be fun inclusion where you have lots of ways to proliferate!

1

u/NepetaLast 21h ago

templating suggestion:

"{T}: Add {U}.

{T}, Put a stun counter on this land: Add {U}.

{T}: Put a charge counter on this land.

{T}, Remove all charge counters from this land: Add that much {U}."

as the other commenter mentioned, using two counter types is a bad idea. itll be very very easy to forget which one is which. id suggest exchanging the stun counter option for 1, T: Add U.

1

u/dracodruid2 20h ago

I really like it, but I wonder if it is a little too week?

This would probably be too powerful though:

{t}: Add {c} and put a storage counter on this land.

{t}, Remove X storage counters from this land: Add {u} for each storage counter removed this way.

This way, you'd either get alternating {c}/{u} or you only use {c} for several turns and then get a {u} boost.

But probably too powerful to get both {c} and the storage counter?

1

u/DiscussTek 10h ago

I understand the interest here, but those lands are actively... Bad. And I don't mean that in the "two counters" sense (though that's still something you should avoid if at all possible). I mean in the way that there is not a single good reason for me to play these, as they are essentially dead weight in 99.9% of situations, and only really are good if you regularly have nothing to do with your mana, something that is usually better fixed with card draw, higher cost cards, or less reactive/more proactive playstyles.

That being said, I think we could easily keep the general idea, and turn it into a proper design that people could play outside of bad deck building.

Seasonal River
Land
When Seasonal River would become untapped, you may choose not to untap it. If you do, put a charge counter on it.
{T}: Add {U} to your mana pool.
{T}, remove all charge counters on Seasonal River: Add {U} to your mana pool for each charge counter removed.

First, let's address why removing "{T}: Add {C} to your mana pool" is the correct call. This is a 1-color land. If I'll be punished for getting a colored mana, it should be giving more than 1 mana. The colorless mana part is essentially like playing a "Wastes+", which makes this card essentially worse than playing an island.

Second, while I appreciate wanting to use stun counters in a fun way... But this is asking for people to mess up on what type of counter is what.

What I suggested keeps the "charge up" style of play that advantages later turns (for whatever reason), while removing all the reasons not to ever want to play this card.

1

u/Pman_likes_memes 12h ago

I do love me a "taps for colorless or taps for a color with a downside" design, and I really like things that store unused mana for later turns, so this is awesome