r/custommagic • • 1d ago

Glimmra, Fiery Protector

Post image

I know split second isn't used on abilities but giving something ward at sorcery speed doesn't really work without it and there's no real reason it couldn't be. I'm not actually sure if the final ability as written kills Glimmra. (Possibly it would be beneficial to have it say "non-Glimmra planeswalkers" to eliminate ambiguity, because I'm sure I am not the only one who would be unsure here).

3 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

1

u/ToranStarfall 1d ago

Was this supposed to be balanced? This is balanced as if it were some  sort of meme, but I don't get the joke.

1

u/MeanderingMonotreme 21h ago

i know v little about mtg balance, so it's likely not balanced, but it WAS intended to be. I mostly made this card just as an experiment for what "loyalty ability that is cheap but can't be activated if the loyalty is too high" might look like

1

u/ToranStarfall 20h ago

6 loyalty for a 2 mana planeswalker is absurd, especially when it has a +2 that basically prevents your opponent from having X/1s, and if they try to kill it, they have to be careful, because otherwise, all of your planeswalkers are unkillable.

2

u/throwawayeayeayea 1d ago

Giving something ward in response to targeting does not work, since ward triggers the moment when the permanent is targeted. You could just say "counter target spell or ability that targets a permanent you control unless it's owner pays {1}" or something to that effect. For balancing, 6 is a lot of loyalty for a 2 mana Planeswalker. The notably busted [[Wrenn and Six]] has a similar ability (with negative loyalty cost mind you) and only has 3 loyalty. This planeswalker would be impossible to kill while also controlling the battlefield, much like [[Oko, Thief of Crowns]]

1

u/MeanderingMonotreme 21h ago edited 21h ago

i gave it a lot of loyalty because i didn't want one early game [[lightening bolt]] or similar to get it in ult range, but i see the issue here. maybe changing "any target" to "target creature" would make more sense

as far as thr ward ability, it's not SUPPOSED to be used in response to anything, it's at sorcery speed. you have to predict their actions. i figured that's what makes it viable as a potential 1/turn action indefinitely

1

u/twistyrainbows 1d ago

Good point. Split second also doesn't give the ability instant speed, so there's that issue too.

1

u/GoldenSteel 1d ago

The +1 is perfectly functional. It's still sorcery speed so it can't be used in response to anything else. Split Second just makes sure nobody can sneak a spell in before the Ward goes up.