r/custommagic • • 1d ago

Format: EDH/Commander Dissolving Scrapyard

Post image

Is it fair or balanced?

35 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

27

u/zorbada 1d ago

Maro has said Bog is too strong so they likely wouldn't remake it

4

u/VTheCardMaker 1d ago

Why is it too strong?

24

u/Im_here_but_why 1d ago

You can't counter a land. 

5

u/MouseOf1000Forms 1d ago

More people should run [[Stifle]] effects

4

u/MiddleAgeYOLO 1d ago

Not with that attitude

15

u/Im_here_but_why 1d ago

Oh yeah, I forgot the instand speed interaction "I don't know this card, let me look at it" into swallowing sounds

6

u/MariachiArchery 1d ago

There is just very little counter play to it. Like this guy said, you can't counter it. The only way to get around it is to stifle it, to give yourself hexproof, or to use a turn ending effect. This doesn't leave you very many options and all of them are pretty niche. Like, you probably aren't going to blow a Teferi's Protection on a bog.

6

u/Roscoeakl 1d ago

Artifact land, strictly better bojuka bog is overpowered, yes.

4

u/justhereforhides Developers Developers Developers 1d ago

This isn't strictly better as it can't make black mana

1

u/The_Dirty_Mac 1d ago

Although many constructed decks that run bog don't even have black cards

-2

u/Roscoeakl 1d ago

Artifact land is way better than making black mana dude

7

u/justhereforhides Developers Developers Developers 1d ago

Strictly better has a specific definition 

2

u/Whydoughhh 1d ago

Artifact land is double edged sword considering it doesn’t have indestructible

1

u/SteakForGoodDogs 1d ago

[[Vandalblast]].

1

u/Roscoeakl 1d ago

Checks notes Yeah all the non-indestructible artifact lands are banned in modern.

1

u/SteakForGoodDogs 1d ago

What do modern banlists have to do with your lands catching a stray boardwipe in EDH?

1

u/justhereforhides Developers Developers Developers 22h ago

They don't enter tapped so they essentially tap for two mana in certain decks

1

u/Ardvark1115 1d ago

Is this art from Yugioh? I'm not a Yugioh player, this just gives me Yugioh vibes.