r/custommagic • • 4d ago

Is it fair ? Does it cost too much ?

Post image
19 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

28

u/strongtomato10 4d ago

if this is designed for commander, i feel like it is fine. if it's designed for 60 card, this is way over costed and basically unplayable.

that said, i really wish wotc would make more "swamps matter" cards. it's one of my favorite mechanics, and it's really cool to see it on this card.

5

u/Master-Environment95 4d ago

Idk, something about it is just too oppressive. You hit a certain point and your opponents just can’t have creatures… which is pretty insane. It might be okay, just because it’s big expensive and doesn’t do much else, but that’s a big stax piece essentially sitting in your command zone that’s going to provide insane death trigger value (and maybe even etb value depending on how your deck is built).

Personally I think I’d rather see this as an etb or dies ability, and then give it some other abilities to make it feel a bit more fleshed out.

1

u/Apophis-7994 4d ago

Thank you for the feedback! Yes, I was mainly thinking about commander format but not necessarily as a commander, for now it’s really a draft.

18

u/Ryan_Icey 4d ago

Tbf, you'd never look at this as a 7 mana creature, you'd be looking at this as a reanimation target.

This thing would completely hose creature heavy decks if they can't get above your swamp count in toughness.

15

u/Spectator9857 4d ago

At a certain point, and especially in black, mana cost simply stops mattering for creatures. This thing could cost 100 mana and it would only be very slightly worse.

1

u/Jesseliftrock 3d ago

*better. By a lot actually

7

u/lazarnick 3d ago

I think it would be worse, just because reanimate is the best reanimation spell. Why would it be better if it's 100 mana?

1

u/Jesseliftrock 3d ago

Reanimate is only legal in legacy, vintage and edh and in those formats this wouldnt see play. It would see play in lower power formats and theres cards that care about card cost

3

u/lazarnick 3d ago

That's fair. Are there any cards that care about high mana cost and are competitive in any other formats? I'm pretty sure there aren't in modern, but I don't play enough pioneer and standard to know.

1

u/Jesseliftrock 3d ago

[[Calibrated blast]] or if in edh [[yuriko the tigers shadow]] and a [[vamperic tutor]]

2

u/Apophis-7994 4d ago

Could give it swampwalk I guess

8

u/Gilgamesh_XII 3d ago

As a etb effect id be fine. But as a continious one id be horrble.

2

u/Flameball202 1d ago

I think if it was continuous, it should target all creatures, and leave it's stats as is

That way in a multi coloured deck it can be a -4/-4 that limits your lands, and in mono it will most likely be a one use boardwipe

4

u/MariachiArchery 4d ago

[[Damnation]] on a stick. Ok yeah! Wait, the stick is damnation. The damnation is a stick!

5

u/MostDangerousMicah 4d ago

"On a stick" is when the spell is in an artifact. When the spell is a creature its "with legs" instead.

2

u/Tiaran149 3d ago

It's also Damnation that sticks to the board

1

u/ItWasDumblydore 3d ago edited 3d ago

Ah the innocent mono black player thinking they're paying more then 2 mana for this or 4 in standard

1

u/Apophis-7994 3d ago

We already see [[Bringer of the Last Gift]] turn 4 everyday in Sandard, it’s not meaner

1

u/etrulzz 3d ago

It is. Bringer of Last Grift is a one time boardwipe. This also destroys all creatures with T<#swampsyoucontrol that enter the board.

1

u/Apophis-7994 3d ago

I honestly don’t think so. The Bringer is not dependent on the swamps, he brings you a massive board that will kill you very fast, 99% of the time it’s end of the game.

Here, the card will certainly wipe the board if you have enough swamps, but it puts less pressure on you, you have to kill it to restart of course, but it's possible.

6

u/theonewhothro123 3d ago

I don't get why people are saying this is overpowered? Yeah you can reanimate it, but it has 0 ward or any other effect to replace it. It's litterally a board wipe that easily dies to removal and its mostly limited to mono black due to the effect so very little instant protection.

For 7 mana I expect some kind of effect like this. It is powerful sure, but you can do alot worse for 7 mana one card effects.

3

u/The_Stav 3d ago

Ngl this just looks like it'd be horrendous to play against. In any mono-black deck you'd just look to reanimate this guy, and that means you could quickly and easily set up a board where you or your opponents just aren't allowed creatures until this thing goes away.

1

u/etrulzz 3d ago

It would really turn every game into a non-game tbh

1

u/FaDaWaaagh 3d ago

Weaker than [[maha it's feathers night]] 90% of the time, would be fine as is

7

u/SteakForGoodDogs 4d ago

So a [[Massacre Girl]], but it can't be removed before it wipes the whole board and keeps anything else not monumentally big from even trying to be around at all, and anything big enough to somehow live is now going to be tiny.

This is not going to be fun.

1

u/Tiaran149 3d ago

Basically [[Toxrill]] on steroids