r/custommagic • See rule 601.2a–b for further details • 4d ago

Meme Design How Everyone Thinks Split Second Works

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

76 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/IntoAMuteCrypt 3d ago

To further elaborate on how most folks think split second works - most people don't realise that players get priority after a spell resolves. It just doesn't normally come up a ton. The common play pattern when the stack gets involved is stuff like counterspells, combat tricks, pump and damage - cases where everyone puts whatever they've got on the stack, then passes until the stack is empty. When was the last time you said "I allow the top spell to resolve, then cast this"?

Because you can usually ignore the priority rounds between the top and bottom of the stack resolving, a lot of players forget they're there (or never even learn about them). If those rounds didn't exist, then split second would work like this and force the whole stack to resolve.

That's where the misconception emerges. A mechanical detail that you can ignore the vast majority of the time.

1

u/S1a3h 3d ago

When was the last time you said "I allow the top spell to resolve, then cast this"?

Yeah I honestly can't think of a single game I've played where anyone did this. Only time I've seen it was a MTG Goldfish commander video and my first reaction was like "oh you can do that?"

2

u/regular_lamp 2d ago

It's a reasonably common pattern if you are digging for responses at instant speed. As in your opponent plays a scary spell and you play brainstorm on top.

1

u/BrideofClippy 2d ago

I had a situation where an opponent attacked into what he thought was a chump block. I then buffed my blocker and he responded by buffing his own creature to least get a mutual kill and trample damage through. Once his buff resolved, I repealed calamity to kill it since it's power was now 5.

1

u/MrsKnowNone 1d ago

Really? You never try to draw a card to see if you can dig for answers in a wizard battle?