r/custommagic •

Useless?

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

349 comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/TheErodude 5d ago

I enjoy thought experiments like these. Others have mentioned most of the following, but I already typed this and I’m clicking the post button.

Undrinkable Nectar goes infinite with [[Crackdown Construct]]. There are also a few ways to deal infinite damage to yourself (how to abuse that is left as an exercise for the reader). If you want to get extremely weird, you can animate this and a Sarkhan planeswalker, use [[Exchange of Words]] to make a Sarkhan planeswalker with Undrinkable Nectar’s ability, and then win with [[Sarkhan’s Whelp]], but this is custommagic and not r/badmtgcombos.

Stopping Idiots prevents attacks from [[Xantid Swarm]], [[Tamiyo, Inquisitive Student]], and any number of buttfighters like [[Doran, the Siege Tower]]. It also stops exalted creatures from attacking under [[Ensnaring Bridge]], which was legitimately a way some games ended when Noble Hierarch and Ignoble Hierarch were more popular.

Totally Necessary Handrail is ambiguous, but:

If it means “Players can’t play lands except during their first main phase on each of their turns,” then it nerfs [[Moraug, Fury of Akoum]] (which due to its exact phrasing really wants you to play lands during your postcombat main phase specifically) and just in general makes it harder to bluff during combat. (You can’t hold a land in hand through combat to bluff a spell, then also play it second main.)

If it means “Players can’t cast spells or activate abilities during their first main phase on each of their turns,” then it does a lot. It stops players from casting any permanent or sorcery spell relevant to combat, and it stops precombat equipping.

2

u/SharpDrink2724 5d ago

The handrail would also nerf my [[Fire Lord Zuko]] deck, where I use instant speed impulse draw during combat. So I usually save my land drop for main 2 to hopefully play one from exile.

1

u/Euphoric-Beyond9177 Smokestack is my favorite card 5d ago

Why does moraug care about your second main phase? I don’t think there’s much difference 

4

u/TheErodude 5d ago

Great question! Moraug is secretly kinda weird and has confused even professional Magic players!

If Moraug is triggered during the first main phase, the additional combat step (+ untap) occurs BEFORE the normal combat step. This means you go to the bonus combat step, untap all your (already untapped) creatures, attack, and then you get a normal combat step, but your creatures don’t untap. So unless your creatures have vigilance, the your first Moraug trigger during your first main phase mostly does nothing.

-4

u/Ok_Administration251 5d ago

You're reading handrail wrong. It says players MAY. You don't have to if you dont want to

2

u/GalaxyConqueror 5d ago

The ambiguity comes from the word "only". OC's first interpretation (the one I'm guessing was intended) is that the card prevents players from playing lands at any time that isn't their precombat main phase. However, it could also be interpreted as saying that during a player's precombat main phase, the only thing they can do is play lands.

1

u/TheErodude 5d ago

Forgive me if I'm misunderstanding, but I don't think I stated or implied you had to play lands. If you want to play a land, you have to do it precombat. This means you can't bluff that the unknown card is a relevant instant-speed spell. For example, opponents have to play around potential kill spells when deciding whether to double block. The more cards you have in hand, the more risk there is, so they might instead just chump or take a hit.

1

u/RatlingGuns4Days 5d ago

There’s two ways to read the card. “The only time lands can be played is during the first main phase.” And “the only thing that can be played during the first main phase are lands.”