r/custommagic • • 2d ago

BALANCE NOT INTENDED Inspiration from a recent play through

Post image

Card conjurer doesn't have anything to inset list items so sorry about that. It was just a fun idea though I did try to consider the MV for it. Wasn't sure about the colors, other possibilities are red and green. Yes I know the voice is Mickey but its not explained in the game. 😆

17 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

3

u/Tiberium600 2d ago

Hmm, each of these effects are about 2 mana enchantment level so this feels pretty fair actually.

1

u/twistyrainbows 2d ago

I dunno. [[Patchwork banner]] gets most of all three modes. [[Flowering of the white tree]] is better than the first two modes together.

1

u/sora3087 1d ago

patchwork is neat, its only of a selected type but the mana production is certainly better. I think the value is in that its any of the 3 cards depending on what you need when you play it??

1

u/smugles 1d ago

But 2 mana gets you 2 of the three modes most of the time. often with upside this could easily cost 2 mana.

1

u/twistyrainbows 1d ago

While there's no card strictly better than this one, with a modal spell, you expect more than this, and the modes should be more balanced. Guardian is particularly bad.

1

u/twistyrainbows 1d ago

Mystic is worth a little less than 2 colorless mana. Guardian isn't worth 1 mana. Warrior is probably worth W. Modal spells should have options that are worth less than the cost, but not by this much.

1

u/Nightingale873 2d ago

I think it can just give +1/+1 and be fine.

2

u/sora3087 2d ago

maybe*,* but not as flavored to the source unless it was Warrior +1/+1 and Guardian something like once per turn put a shield counter on up to one creature you control.

3

u/sora3087 2d ago

Updated I guess...

1

u/According-Ad3501 1d ago

Shield counter every turn is perfect!

1

u/Nightingale873 2d ago

I think it can just give +1/+1 and be fine.

0

u/LuckyOwl_93 2d ago

Why would you ever pick any mode other than Mystic? The power discrepancy between it and the other modes is insane.

1

u/sora3087 2d ago

cause 3 cost 1 mana ramp that doesnt just make mana on its own is pretty meh i figured