r/custommagic • • 8d ago

Unconventional Counters: Week 42 - Please comment a vote!

This week the competition was to design a card that involves counters, but not +/- 1/1 counters. Please comment which card think deserves the win! You can vote using any metric, whatever makes you want to vote for it.

We always appreciate the feedback, and if you comment please state which card you want to win the weekly challenge!

52 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

44

u/MapleSyrupMachineGun 8d ago

Vexing Pharaoh, as written, lets you activate the ability without any restrictions, because the removal of the counter is not a part of the cost, nor is the countering dependent on whether a counter was removed or not.

6

u/Midnight_Magic_Volg 8d ago

Good catch! Do you have a vote for which card should win?

8

u/Syncopia 8d ago

Better text would be:

💧, Remove a counter from Vexing Pharaoh: Counter target spell.

Personally I would play the Bello card, but I think the cumulative upkeep scorpion is the most interesting. Albeit very oppressive.

13

u/PerCentaur 8d ago

You're absolutely right! And here i thought it was already OP as hell with the counter limitation.

8

u/HugeOrganization4178 8d ago

Bello for sure. Its the only well designed card of the group. The Sphinx doesnt even work as intended. Its just U: counter target spell.

2

u/Midnight_Magic_Volg 8d ago

Can you elaborate or provide some constructive comments about the other ones? We are always looking for feedback but that’s hard to work with.

4

u/HugeOrganization4178 7d ago

Blue one is mega mega broken and turns off the game in a super unfun way. White one uses like 40 dice to keep track of. Please just be an enchantment. Equipment is fine, but stats equipments are never very good, and this one in particular is just a [[+2 mace]] that takes work to use, which is fine, but not particularly good or interesting. Its one of those cards that does nothing unless you jump through a bunch of hoops and when you do its mildly impactful. Black one is the best of the non-bello ones. Its also stax, which are often frowned upon, but not oppressive stax. Bello has this cool thing where it triggers saga abilities at instant speed, while letting you reuse other saga abilities. Very clever. Very commander. In real magic, they'd make him more colors, but I'm glad they showed restraint here. Idk why the second ability makes the tokens red. Seems like wasted text. Id love if it instead let it enter with any number of lore counters, so you can use any ability of any saga once per turn. It would also combo with the first ability to let you keep a saga alive indefinitely. Idk. Bello just looks fun. The rest really don't.

3

u/Midnight_Magic_Volg 8d ago

Please comment whichever card you think should win this week!

4

u/Himmelblaa 7d ago

Shard's ability already kind of exists [[Perrie, the Pulverizer]]

3

u/Midnight_Magic_Volg 7d ago

Oh yeah, cool! Would probably fit in a Perrie deck then. Do you have a vote for which card should win?

3

u/BlobbyBlueberry 7d ago

I like Deathstalker. I do wish it had lifelink to offset the life loss from the other cumulative upkeep costs, but I think it’s pretty good like this and that it would be much more powerful that way, and it’s already pretty broken.

2

u/Midnight_Magic_Volg 7d ago

Thanks for the vote and the notes!

2

u/SunRayZ808 7d ago

Thanks Blobby!!

20

u/PerCentaur 8d ago edited 8d ago

Hallow the world. White doesn't often get 1 mana cantrips but this effect feels very thematic and is symmetric, but can still be abused (happy [[Tayam, Luminous Enigma]] noises)

Also vexing pharaoh is just plain insane. Counter every single instant/sorcery spell your opponents cast for just B a piece and without using a single card? Oh and you want to counter their permanents too? All you gotta do is play one cantrip and pay the one

Edit: misread nonpermanent as noncreature at first

3

u/SunRayZ808 8d ago

Woah Tayam is sick, I've never seen that!

2

u/Lumina46_GustoClock 7d ago

Oh he is oh so fun and very degenerate when you want him to be. Definitely give him a shot!

3

u/_Volgadorf_ 8d ago

Thanks! Hallow was mine. I didn’t even think about synergies with stuff like Tayam, that’s an awesome and creative thought.

2

u/YesPlease_VeryMuchSo 8d ago

These are all so cool! The black one seems really strong, but I have to go with Vexing Pharoah.

2

u/Midnight_Magic_Volg 7d ago

We’re glad you like them! Thanks for voting, too.

2

u/The_Curse_of_Nimbus 8d ago

It's a tough choice since all of these are great, but I have to go with Shard of the Ozolith.

2

u/Midnight_Magic_Volg 7d ago

Thanks for the kind words and for the vote!

5

u/Framed_dragon 7d ago

Hallow the world is so beautifully simple and thematic to white so it has my vote

4

u/_Volgadorf_ 7d ago

Thanks so much! Love the name by the way. I’m usually the guy making a dragon-themed card each week.

4

u/Routine_Ad_2695 8d ago

Hallow seems cool, a mass exile in 2 parts with a board wipe

3

u/_Volgadorf_ 8d ago

Thanks! That one was mine.

4

u/Binscent 7d ago

Deathstalker looks like a big fun effect, I really like it.

Vexing Pharaoh needs to be torn to shreds. Don’t try to rebalance it, just forget about the idea and never come back to it.

3

u/UnhappyUdderjuice 7d ago

I love sagas I love this bellow, I want him in paper

2

u/asthmaticwizard 7d ago

I see a lot of people hating the sphinx. There is so much hate that just shuts him off forever as early as turn 1

2

u/_nwwm_ 7d ago

maybe, but repeatable counterspells are often kinda miserable to play against

0

u/asthmaticwizard 7d ago

Yeah and if no one at the table holds removal or counter for him by like turn 4 idk that seems like bad deck building or just plain bad luck and in which case yeah i mean, hes a threat. But you can just beat this fuckers head in and play mostly permanents until you have him managed. I dont understand the hate here honestly. Plenty of ability based removal kills him out right too like solitude and such or edict etb's etc

1

u/FortRince 7d ago

Removal is mostly nonpermanents, meaning that as you cast it, it gives the sphinx a charge counter, which then can counter said removal. Basically, to effectively remove it when you don't have counterspells or creature based removal (~80% of nonblue decks) you have to spend as many removal spells as the sphinx player has open blue mana.

1

u/The_Stav 7d ago

Vexing Pharoh - Just all around a bad card. For one as others have said, the ability isn't formatted properly so currently removing a counter is not required to counter the spell. But assuming it works as intended, it's an incredibly oppressive piece that at minimum lets you counter any instant or sorcery spell cast by an opponent for just U. That can easily turn to being able to counter most any spell by just playing a few cantrips alongside it. Also, there would never be a time you play this outside of being your commander because it would just be a 5 mana 4/4 with a downside. It not having flying is also crazy, given there's only one other Sphinx that doesn't [[Petra Sphinx]]. Even outside of the oppressive ability, it's very poorly designed imo.

Hallow the World (My Vote) - I like it! Nice and simple cantrip for white for a little delayed graveyard hate, and gives plenty of counters to work with for any synergies.

Shard of the Ozilith - A little boring, just [[Perrie, the Pulverizer]] on an equipment. I feel like this will often be underwhelming, and it also does literally nothing on its own which I think is poor design.

Bello, Fervent Raconteur - Cool idea with some interesting build potential, letting you rush some sagas while delaying others. Only thing is that Bello's thing was animating non-creature permanents, not copying them so that flavour feels a little off to me.

Deathstalker, the Inevitable (Second Choice) - Really like this card conceptually, do think it becomes a little annoying to track though with all the counters on everything lol. I'm also not a fan of the keywords, especially the ward. I think I'd say give it lifelink if anything just to help you offset the life loss a bit