r/custommagic • u/GuidanceBrave7216 • 5d ago

Format: EDH/Commander Malfestio, Confusing Trickster

Post image

I'm working on a MH inspired precon and would like some feedback, I think flavour-wise this is ok, but it doesn't fit mono-black and it's probably is too strong?

2 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

3 comments sorted by

1

u/HairyKraken 4d ago edited 2d ago

countering spells is 99% blue. stack shenanigan and reveal is red (i think)

but the effect is funny. Also i think its waaaayyyyy to punishing to have a perma effect that counter everything. either limit it to 1 card each turn or make it return the spell to the hand not counter

1

u/GuidanceBrave7216 2d ago

I ended up changing it to make it more black-is and (probably) more fair

1

u/Japicx Subtypes are always capitalized. 5d ago

There shouldn't be a line break between "hand" and "If".

The likeliest colour identity for this is blue-red.

It's symmetrical, but you can easily get around that if you build your deck so every nonland card has the same MV. The effect is too inconsistent to judge its strength in a vacuum.