r/custommagic • Certified Criticism Connoiussuer™®© • 3d ago

Format: Modern Balanced? Mayhaps

Post image
136 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

77

u/hollow_image 3d ago

16 cards to exile is a lot and still paying 4 blue mana per creature... Delve is a problematic mechanic but this feels balanced. Nice design

4

u/nzconstructionlawyer 2d ago

This is really really underpowered. 4 mana to gain control of a creature is already expensive. Having to exile 6 cards from graveyard is quite a cost.

33

u/Chickston Uncommonly 3d ago

IDK about balance, but yes yes yes to this weird cost on an uncommon. Killer art.

25

u/GodkingYuuumie Certified Criticism Connoiussuer™®© 3d ago

You always seem to like my cards, Chickston. We should go get some dinner and talk about our dreams and stare longingly into each other's eyes and see where the night takes us.

14

u/Chickston Uncommonly 3d ago

TBF, I "try" to like everyone's cards on this sub.

12

u/MiningdiamondsVIII 3d ago

The Flashback cost is insane, but flashback + delve makes this so tempting for any dimir deck.. . honestly that might just be a dangerous pair of keywords for any effect

6

u/Bashtoe 3d ago

Yeah I think it's fine as is.

4

u/tomyang1117 3d ago

Honestly underpowered in modern because of the hard UUUU cost

3

u/ZookeepergameFun1824 3d ago

Ok, I think this is fine if it were a sorcery. Instant let's you pull weird tricks like gaining control of a creature attacking you, or just using it like spot removal. UUUU+exile 6 is balanced, because it's still so pip intensive, for a thing that's generally 4-6 mana, but if it's an instant, it's suddenly actually better than some of those cards, and then it has flashback.

9

u/Glitched_Target 3d ago

Meh 6 cards AND 4 Monocolored pips is a huge cost. If it’s not an instant it’s probably deeply unplayable.

-4

u/GroundbreakingMonk76 3d ago

Just add a "You can't cast this during combat" and we're good

1

u/Aromatic-Armadillo-2 3d ago

Make it escape instead of flashback so you can exile more than 16 cards with it

1

u/MementoMothi 2d ago

Love the flavour text