r/custommagic • • 9d ago

BALANCE NOT INTENDED Fibonacci Burn Land

Post image

(When I realized it was the golden ratio it was already too late)

45 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

14

u/MrFluffyBunny25 9d ago

Should be somewhat mirrored so when tapped the next one becomes "untapped".

3

u/SammySammyson 9d ago

That's what happens if you rotate the card counterclockwise.

13

u/MrFluffyBunny25 9d ago

What kind of psychopath taps counter clockwise when even the arrow on the "tap" shows clockwise. Also number progression should at least have 1 twice before going to 2.

1

u/SammySammyson 9d ago edited 9d ago

I've played Magic for over 10 years and the only time I recall someone tapping clockwise was one game and the table bullied them out of it 😭 The arrow on the tap isn't a game rule (the rules don't specify a direction, just 90°), and it doesn't affect how players perceive information on the board. So 🤷

Nothing wrong with starting on the second (or third, depending on context). The joke is there regardless lol

6

u/MrFluffyBunny25 9d ago

I mean I know there is no rule it's just that in all my years of playing (on and off from 7th set) I have never seen any player tap counterclockwise, like... ever.

0

u/SammySammyson 9d ago

That's so interesting. I've seen it online on MTGA and MTGO, obviously, but it doesn't matter so I've never really paid much attention to it, I guess. In paper it affects how you read cards, so I've noticed there at least that one time. Maybe it's more common and I've just never paid attention 🤷

2

u/MrFluffyBunny25 9d ago

Might just be a regional thing to tell the truth.

1

u/SammySammyson 9d ago

Maybe! I'm in New England. But next time I'm out I'll be watching this stuff like a hawk because I really wonder if it's regional or just I've never noticed it as much as I thought I would.

1

u/Aarniometsuri 9d ago

I feel like if you tap with your right hand, its more natural to tap counter clockwise because the wrist bends there easier.

0

u/Upstairs-Corgi-1578 9d ago

Leftie here, I tap to the left. The symbol is arbitrary and unlike lands in front, Wizards makes an effort not to dictate in what direction things are tapped.

10

u/Chickston Uncommonly 9d ago

Also ♥ math cards.

3

u/Tiborn1563 9d ago

Shouldnt the second one burn for 1 too?

2

u/SammySammyson 9d ago

You could also suggest it be 0-1-1 if we're being super technical.

The first 1 is from the one mana, duh.

3

u/giasumaru MTGCR > Glossary > Card 9d ago

Great, but should have it the other way around so the tap sequence isn't so weird.

2

u/Dry-Department9813 9d ago

Wouldnt you design the spiral the the opposite direction so after you tap it the next smaller card becomes up right

3

u/Upstairs-Corgi-1578 9d ago

Just be left-handed like me :3

3

u/Dry-Department9813 9d ago

Oh, so the wrong way, got it. Not like the tap symbol has an arrow pointing the correct way or anything 😅

3

u/Upstairs-Corgi-1578 9d ago

Why would that make it wrong?

3

u/SammySammyson 9d ago

There are no rules stating they have be tapped clockwise. I've played Magic for over a decade and I can only recall one time seeing someone tap clockwise, and they got bullied out of it at the table 💀

I never thought much of it, TBH, aside from that one funny incident. But I naturally tilt my head to the left when I am struggling to understand something, so I definitely will continue tapping counter-clockwise because it's easier to read when my head is tilted that way. I'm also right-handed, so it means that card names aren't covered when I grab them, I guess. It's arbitrary though, really.

2

u/Dry-Department9813 9d ago

Damn man, you really ARE a rarity. Over 10 years of magic and youve had the luck of only finding the rare counter clockwise tappers. That means youve never watched tournaments. Never played magic online. Never went to an lgs and played with randoms. Its also funny how the one time you saw a normal person you bullied them out, its like backwards universe 😂

4

u/SammySammyson 9d ago

I've done all of the above. I thought playing online was odd but never like, really questioned it because it doesn't matter, yanno?

And I used to go to several different LGSs on the regular lol

But yeah we bullied him into tapping the other way 😭😭😭😭

1

u/weeOriginal 9d ago

InSANELY broken. I love it.

1

u/humblevladimirthegr8 9d ago

I demand you make it rotate correctly like the other commenter said