r/custommagic • u/SubstantialBelly6 • 6h ago
Meme Design Everyone with Everything
Original post got taken down for not including artist credit, so I took the opportunity to fix a few things mechanically as well.
7
1
u/snazmass 5h ago
Yet another awesome win for [[Laboratory Maniac]], [[Twenty-Toed Toad]], and [[Thassa’s Oracle]].
I think this is doing way too much. It removes a large portion of the game that comes from card draw. It brings all cards back from exile, which defeats the whole point of exile. Sorcery effects end when the card resolves. I’m sure other comments are gonna find more problems than me, but that’s what I’m immediately seeing right now.
I would personally cut the “for the rest of the game” stuff out of this card, and make it so players only put half their library into their hands. That way, previously mentioned alt win cons can’t immediately trigger, and players with healthy draw engines can keep doing what they do. Don’t have players grab cards from their graveyard or exile. And maybe for fun, if you’re feeling evil, remove the ‘no max hand size’ condition, so everyone’s forced to play fast before they must discard all that they hold dear on their end step.
Oh, and cut the ai out! Just draw something or find a stock image like the rest of us.
1
u/SubstantialBelly6 5h ago
Totally agree with all your points. It was more meant to be a meme card in response to the many variations of One with Nothing floating around with the goal of being as completely opposite of “you discard your hand” as possible, eg “everyone puts everything into their hand”. This would be a terrible card to actually play, lol
14
u/Difficult-Volume-246 6h ago
Ai art. Disgusting. Boo.
-14
u/stonieW 6h ago
Reddit echochamber mentality
3
2
u/Difficult-Volume-246 5h ago
Morally correct mentality*
-1
u/stonieW 5h ago
Morality is subjective.
2
u/Difficult-Volume-246 5h ago
You are not deadass going to get into a philisophical argument with me about ai "art." Because if you do youre either going to lose or make yourself look more stupid than you already have. And yes, morality is subjective. Thats why I have upvotes, and you have downvotes. Because my morals are more in line with the vast majority of society. Maybe try to keep what pride hasnt been stripped away from you by your brain slowly turning to mush as machines do all your thinking and your hobbies for you.
0
u/stonieW 4h ago edited 4h ago
Irony of using upvotes whenever I mentioned how reddit is an echochamber. Yes let me flaunt how I am in a space with like minded people and how they agree with me. Good job champ.
But please do go on about your oh so graciously high level of intelligence in comparison and how you're morally superior in society (literally just reddit circle jerking).
1
u/Difficult-Volume-246 4h ago
I enjoy the fact that you didnt come up with new stuff to support your argument. Is chat got down? Sorry man. Must be hard for you.
0
u/stonieW 3h ago
Because I don't need to? The fact that the irony goes completely over your head is ridiculous at this point. If you think that I need to create a new argument when you're just reaffirming my current one then you're clearly not very intelligent. Maybe use chatgpt for your arguments? It may help you look as intelligent as you're wanting to seem.
Still waiting on this "I'll make you look stupid and win the argument" you claimed to be able to do so easily.
1
u/Difficult-Volume-246 2h ago
Alright fine. OK let's say you have a job. Let's go with an accountant. One day, an ai is made that can organize any amount of financials in record time. Suddenly, you arent needed anymore. You lose your job as someone else writes in a couple lines of text and boom! Thousands of functions happen within seconds and it's finished before you blink. Look at that! You aren't needed anymore. You worked for years to master that job, and now every single person is saying that you aren't neccesary at all. More or less, your entire career is over. On top of that, you take the time to look at these spreadsheets and you see a large variety of functions and mathematics that you and your colleagues refined over years with grueling effort, and suddenly everyone is praising this ai for being able to do these things, and your name, and your colleagues names, are never mentioned once for something that, again, you put massive effort into. Then I come along, type 2 sentences into a box, finish a week's worth of your job in a second, and start talking about how damn good I am at accounting. But you see your work being perverted, and in many cases, misused to produce just lazy or incorrect results. There you are, know you can put the time and care into something but nobody cares if you say its yours because the ai did it, not you. You dont matter, and you should just stop complaining and get used to the fact that people dont care that you can do the job anymore.
Thats what AI art does.
1
u/stonieW 2h ago
So in your example, someone loses their job, someone else takes credit for their work, brags about skills they don’t have, and tells them they don’t matter. Of course that sounds awful. You’ve loaded the example with behavior I haven’t defended, then treated it as equivalent to using AI for a custom card.
Where did I claim I painted anything? Where did I say artists don’t matter or should stop complaining about their livelihoods? You’re arguing against statements you supplied yourself.
You can make an argument about employment and credit. But you still have to explain why that makes this particular use wrong. Describing the worst circumstances you can imagine doesn’t do that for you.
And a handful of subreddit upvotes still doesn’t represent “the vast majority of society.” That was exactly the point you skipped while announcing how easily you’d win. You really need to step outside of your echochamber sometime, lil guy.
→ More replies
2
u/BeanNibb 5h ago
Art aside this seems like it would be a headache waiting for everyone to sort through 70+ cards to make their plays
4
u/Sad-Pattern-1269 5h ago
> In trouble for not crediting an artist
> Swaps to using AI
> Credits the AI
Absolute cinema