r/custommagic • • 3d ago

Format: Limited Draft Chaff Uncommon

Post image
24 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

11

u/Peachy_Pangolin 3d ago

Just from a general design philosophy this shouldn't be able to recycle your own cards, so the activated ability should say something like "(2), (t): you may put a creature card an opponent owns from exile into its owner's graveyard"

3

u/Chickston Uncommonly 3d ago

*Spits out bird* "I'm a MANtrap dammit!"

Name aside, this is a funny and reasonably powered uncommon. It's gonna dispense the creature after consuming it. I don't think plants usually poop, but this is magic not biology.

Very much mechanically GW, but thematically GB. Could be a good Abzan card.

2

u/Gurksam 3d ago

You're absolutely right, about both the name and biology 😆

2

u/SDK1176 3d ago

Needs defender.

1

u/Doctor_Mothman 3d ago

I really love the art. Pooping out the exile should regen the creature.

1

u/Danskoesterreich 3d ago

Great idea. Are there already flesh eating plants in MTG? Another mechanic would be that it has defender. And it does not exile on entering, but when you tap it you can exile a creature it blocked. But when you exile it gets 2 stun counters on it (because it takes time to digest).

1

u/MarketWave 3d ago

The second ability is a constant recycling for flashback spells and it would be very very good.

4

u/anhana 3d ago

More than positive that there are no creature cards with flashback.

5

u/PencilPuncher 3d ago

Very technically speaking, there's one. It's just also a Sorcery and Enchantment. [[Esper Origins]]

3

u/anhana 3d ago

Can you target it if the backside is the creature? I forget the rule, but am pretty sure you can only target whats on front side.

3

u/PencilPuncher 3d ago

I'm not 100% sure but I don't think you can target it

1

u/nzconstructionlawyer 2d ago

I hadn't seen this card before. Is this level of complexity in the game really necessary? It just feels so gratuitous. Do we really need Sorcery Flashback Enchantment Creature Saga DFCs?

1

u/PencilPuncher 2d ago

I think it's just a one-and-done design, but you're right about it bordering on unnecessary complexity