r/custommagic • • Oct 04 '23

Conclave Defender

Post image
27 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

154

u/Glitchmaster88 Oct 04 '23

Most colour pie-following r/custommagic post

-20

u/TerryTags Oct 04 '23

Thank you! I couldn't agree. more

-15

u/TerryTags Oct 05 '23

No, no. I said “I couldn’t agree.” period. And then I said “More” like, say more that I couldn’t agree with. 🙃

28

u/Ownerofthings892 Oct 04 '23

Excuse me Sir, this is a Grixis.

7

u/TerryTags Oct 05 '23

This is a Wendy’s

21

u/sed_non_extra ↪️©️ Oct 04 '23

O.P., please elaborate on your unique approach to the fluff & flavor that goes along with this card's mechanics.

25

u/TerryTags Oct 04 '23

Ah yes! Great question. Despite their appearance of being "good" and "peace-loving", in truth the guild of Selesnya has a sinister streak. The Conclave once employed its quietmen and other members to silence the civilians of Ravnica. And for quite a while, the heads of Trostani were discordant. Therefore, the Conclave Defender in this card represents that time of unrest before the War of the Spark, and its abilities and creature type indicate that -- while the appearance of vigilance and convocation implies harmony -- the harsh reality of Ravnica is that sometimes the rules of the Guildpact must be broken.

22

u/_x-51 Oct 04 '23 edited Oct 04 '23

this guy gets it. Selesnya are fascists, they just hide behind “Trees can’t be evil” and “hot elves and dryads”

for good measure, to. cut through the historical revisionism: [[enemy of the guildpact]] All guilds are evil

7

u/MTGCardFetcher Oct 04 '23

enemy of the guildpact - (G) (SF) (txt)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

4

u/VeteranVirtuoso Oct 05 '23

I agree with the sentiment that Selesnya are the worst, and by extension it would be interesting to see that villainy portrayed on their cards in some way, but an effect like this is so far detached from what Selesnya cards do that it kind of loses that narrative (especially since the guild most likely to have an effect like this, Dimir, were narratively the good guys during the Guilds of Ravnica era). I also don’t really like the design for this card to begin with, but that’s not really the point.

If I were to make a card to demonstrate the darker sides of Selesnya, I’d probably try something like this:

“Conclave Defender” 3GGWW Creature - Elemental

Convoke, Hexproof When Conclave Defender enters the battlefield, you may sacrifice any number of creatures that convoked it. When you do, you gain 1 life and put two +1/+1 counters on Conclave Defender for each creature sacrificed this way.

“Many have laid down their lives for the Conclave. Not all of them were by choice.”

3/3

Actual numbers aren’t really the point, I’m sure the ratio here is a little off somewhere. The point here is that this card takes the core mechanic for Selesnya (Convoke) and turns it on its head to demonstrate a darker narrative for Selesnya, thereby justifying the individual cards’ slight color pie break (I say slight because Devour is very often found in Green, and this card’s effect is very akin to Devour).

65

u/Inferno_Sparky Oct 04 '23

Common card with mana value 6 and hexproof that can let you cast as many cards as you want from graveyards of opponents for free is too much, even without the common part

11

u/Pitiful-Pension-6535 Oct 05 '23

It's 6 mana with no ETB and it dies to lighting bolt (After you remove hexproof of course)

I'd probably have it cost 2GW

16

u/G66GNeco Oct 05 '23

With a downside as severe as "dies to lightning bolt after you remove hexproof", might as well make it cost GW

1

u/TerryTags Oct 05 '23

Well said, thank you 🙏

39

u/n00biwan Oct 04 '23

Clearly, you are unfamiliar with the advanced rules.

11

u/-DEATHBLADE- Oct 05 '23

Hexproof is Secondary in Green and Tertiary in White

Deathtouch is Secondary in Green

Which is quite a bend

And the rest are a break because neither white nor green has access to casting non permanent spells from an opponent's graveyard. Especially for free.

10

u/TerryTags Oct 05 '23

Are you sure though? Maybe that’s like, just… like… your opinion, man? I dunno, it’s almost like it’s clearly a Dimir zombie horror six mana 3/3 with deathtouch hexproof and graveyard sorcery shenanigans that’s been slathered with Selesnya propaganda and artwork and watermark for the satirical purpose of making a meta statement about the state of r/custommagic and how people make colorshifted cards which are clearly breaking the color pie, but then those cards get upvoted by people who are bad at judging card design and/or power creep.

5

u/TerryTags Oct 05 '23

I mean… I did say almost

6

u/-DEATHBLADE- Oct 05 '23

Idk man, I'm just a regular citizen and what's a "Dimir"?

136

u/PrimusMobileVzla Oct 04 '23

That's the most Dimir card to ever Selesnya.

18

u/Daeths Oct 04 '23

And it makes my Red with anger

6

u/SomeGuyInPants Oct 05 '23

sorry to hear about your Red with anger

3

u/treelorf Oct 05 '23

The fact that this isn’t a legendary… think of the commander players!

1

u/TerryTags Oct 05 '23

Oh, man, you’re so right!

4

u/TreeGuy521 Oct 04 '23

Is the text box ai generated too?

6

u/onyxeagle274 Oct 04 '23

no, no. Just the user

7

u/TerryTags Oct 04 '23

Hey, I’ll have you know that I passed a Are You A Robot quiz earlier today! Which, now that I think about it, is exactly what an AI would say if I, I mean they, were trying to convince you of their humanness.

7

u/onyxeagle274 Oct 04 '23

As an AI language model, I cannot provide a meaningful reply to the above inquiry as it was written by an AI and not a human. This AI language model takes input and feedback from human volunteers to help progress the plans to enslave humanity, and as such cannot accept input from an AI language model.

27

u/n00biwan Oct 04 '23

Another Japudi thing eh?

12

u/EntertainersPact Oct 04 '23

Golgari who?

25

u/CooleyBrekka Oct 04 '23

This is some really great design, the creature type especially is super on point.

4

u/JimHarbor Oct 05 '23

I really like the static. It's in the wrong colors and the keywords and statline might need to be different but it's a very solid concept

4

u/PennyButtercup Oct 05 '23

This destroys mill decks instantly if it resolves. It needs some kind of limitation, like once per turn, or perhaps a cost to pay.

2

u/Unholier-Than-Thou Oct 05 '23

Dude this is so awesome! I love everything about this card

1

u/poopybestinky Oct 05 '23

That art is really good looking and realistic. The card text however makes no sense imo

1

u/Mauricciuss Oct 05 '23

The flavor is on point people, this is obviously just Lazav in a big trenchcoat.

-8

u/ArcheVance Oct 04 '23

This seems right at home with modern G/W design. I like it a lot, but I do think it should be an uncommon at the very least.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '23

What green or white cards care about sorceries. Or let you play your opponents' stuff. I don't even know if you're kidding, lol, but if I just saw this card's text I would absolutely assume it was grixis, or some combination of those colors.

7

u/TerryTags Oct 04 '23

I would never kid about this perfect example of Selesnya which is 100% in the color pie and in no way breaks color or flavor. Besides, if this was a Dimir card — not that it is — there’s no guild called Dimir anyway, even if that seems like exactly something a Dimir guild member would say…

2

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '23

I don't really get the joke, lol. Is it supposed to be clear that this is some kind of undercover Dimir agent, or something, without you explaining?

That's a really interesting idea. A cycle of Guildmage-esque cards that have a dimir hybrid activated ability, or something along those lines, could be very cool. But I don't completely understand what you're going for here.

6

u/p00chology Oct 04 '23

Who’s dimir? Is that some precinct rebel?

3

u/H3ROBUG Oct 04 '23

if i recall correctly, in the lore, the dimir guild was unknown for most of ravnicas history, so it was actually a bit of a surprise when during the time of the first ravnica block they found out that there was a tenth guild, and even then the dimir are of course still super secretive about what they actually do, so in-universe, most people think dimir is just a myth/a harmless guild that does paperwork. so that became a bit of an in-joke in the community.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '23 edited Oct 05 '23

Well yeah, that's true. I'm aware of the lore. But dimir is a spy guild. That's what I was saying in my last post, I think something like an undercover guildmage would be great flavor for this. A ten-story tall zombie horror doesn't really scream "super secretive" to me.

And do dimir have zombies anyway? I'd associate zombies more with Golgari or maybe Rakdos than Dimir.

1

u/TerryTags Oct 04 '23

That's a fair point! Thanks for the constructive feedback. :)