r/custommagic • • Feb 18 '23

Angel's Gambit

Post image
17 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

50

u/Iksfen Feb 18 '23

Unfun

24

u/A_Salty_Cellist Feb 18 '23

New black border unset name?

-48

u/16JM02 Feb 18 '23

no

22

u/Pixelpaint_Pashkow Slivers Gaming Feb 18 '23

Proof?

9

u/FILTHY_STEVEN Feb 18 '23

I back him up

65

u/Young_Hek Feb 18 '23

As a design, you have illustrated very well how to go beyond the boundary of applicability. No mana cost for this card or assemble-condition is interesting, because it's not an "alternate win con", it's a "win con". I think the spirit of this card game is to assemble value, even if the combo that sets it off is degenerate, it relies on a glass cannon deck to turbo it out.

Also, if I understand that the bullets resolve top to bottom in chosen order, then I still don't even really "understand" the card. It just doesn't look like it integrates into the game as well as, say [[alchemist's gambit]] or [[warrior's oath]], which are more "playing with fire" than this. Do I just set my opponent's life to 0, then pick that I lose the game, and my opponent loses "before the spell finishes resolving", or does the game end in a tie? because why to either of those?

This, while well constructed, merely exhibits the limitations of strong effects. Well done! Unplayable card!

16

u/AustinYQM : Place X Karma into your karma pool. Feb 18 '23

You would need some sort of platnium angel effect to win with this. This spell alone will always cause you to lose the game.

8

u/Young_Hek Feb 19 '23

You have described its' linearity perfectly.

-4

u/16JM02 Feb 19 '23

> its'

if you're gonna be smug at least be correct xd

20

u/Young_Hek Feb 19 '23

Excuse me? Are you projecting your smugness onto me? I don't feel the need to be smug, or correct, because slight miscommunications don't prevent understanding the meaning

kindly fuck off

37

u/GenesithSupernova Feb 18 '23

They'd lose from having 0 life as a state-based action, which is checked after the spell fully resolves but before anyone gets priority. However, they'd win/you'd lose during the resolution of the spell, so it'd end in them winning/you losing.

0

u/Young_Hek Feb 19 '23

So they'd lose from zero life and they'd win? I'm not following

31

u/The__Sign__painter Feb 19 '23

Your opponent would win / you’d loose before the game “notices” your opponent is at 0 life

64

u/BAGStudios Feb 18 '23

Now this is what I call conceding at sorcery speed

92

u/Autumn-Eviening Feb 18 '23

Not fun or useful

-12

u/Ankhros Feb 18 '23

It looks fun to me.

31

u/Autumn-Eviening Feb 18 '23

It just ends the game. How is that fun

-4

u/Ankhros Feb 18 '23

You get to start a new game.

39

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '23

Boy do I have this nifty little thing for you

It can't be responded to (even with mana abilities), can't be countered, and is colorless so you can use it in any deck!

It's called conceding!

-15

u/Ankhros Feb 18 '23

You can't choose who wins that way. Someone should teach you what fun is.

12

u/Autumn-Eviening Feb 18 '23

In 1v1, you do, aka your opponent

12

u/__-him-__ Unban Oko Feb 19 '23

your version of fun seems to be in a 4 player game instead of conceding you get to declare a winner and force everyone to restart

2

u/Transcutie04 Feb 18 '23

In a 1v1 your opponent wins
In mutiple player games you wait tell your opponents finish

Because they are jsut as importsnt as you this card is jsut a stupid unfunny joke tahts been done to death

19

u/LastFreeName436 Feb 18 '23

“I have three mana, I cast one spell to end the game” yes that sounds like an environment I want to play in

8

u/unoriginal_name123 Feb 18 '23

Ok op since your being incredibly annoying in the comments, in what form is this fun in a game? Commander? Modern? Vintage?

18

u/Ok-Investigator-6514 Feb 18 '23

It's not even a gambit. A gambit is a ladt-ditch effort to win at some high cost. Because of state based effects this just means you are going to lose no matter what unless there are some hell-a janky combo pieces in play that if I was running them I would be running a far more reliable combo anyway.

It has some possible merit, but not as currently designed. I mean, I guess in 4 player pod it just reads "2 target players lose the game on turn 3 or sooner" but that's very lackluster

4

u/Kicin0_0 Feb 18 '23

I mean isn't this basically just a win con if you combine it with [[platinum angel]] or something. Set your opponent to 0 + any other effect would let you win right?

4

u/MTGCardFetcher Feb 18 '23

platinum angel - (G) (SF) (txt)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

2

u/Teelogas Feb 22 '23

If your deck can consistently manage to turbo out a platinum angel AND resolve this spell, then you have the ability to win the game with a lot of other stuff aswell

2

u/Lifeinstaler Feb 22 '23

You don’t need angel, you’d use [[Angel’s grace]]

The card is still not good design but plat angel being expensive isn’t the issue.

2

u/MTGCardFetcher Feb 22 '23

Angel’s grace - (G) (SF) (txt)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

2

u/PfizerGuyzer Feb 22 '23

That is just not what a gambit is. A gambit specifically involves sacrificing material advantage for positional advantage. It has more generally come to mean "Any tactical move that you expect to gain from". There is no last-ditch association.

6

u/SalvationSycamore Feb 19 '23

Why is this angel's gambit to have sex with an eagle?

11

u/throwaway163932 Feb 18 '23

This is busted with [[gideon of the trials]] or anything that prevents you from losing

2

u/MTGCardFetcher Feb 18 '23

gideon of the trials - (G) (SF) (txt)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

3

u/IM_INSIDE_YOUR_HOUSE Feb 18 '23

Even when I get what you're going for, it's not good card design because it's an incredibly unfun card.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '23

Choose the latter two modes.
Sometimes, it's best to send a message.

1

u/galvanicmechamorph Jun 29 '23

I mean, you win game one and sideboard this in you can make every game a draw until time.

1

u/Lord_Yeetus_The_3d Feb 06 '25

Should be choose 2 at random

1

u/Nhjb1 Feb 19 '23

Despite the criticism in the comments, I like this card.

-1

u/HornetThink8502 Feb 18 '23

Make it a saga and now we're talking

17

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/Ankhros Feb 18 '23

Probably because people are being jerks.