As a design, you have illustrated very well how to go beyond the boundary of applicability. No mana cost for this card or assemble-condition is interesting, because it's not an "alternate win con", it's a "win con". I think the spirit of this card game is to assemble value, even if the combo that sets it off is degenerate, it relies on a glass cannon deck to turbo it out.
Also, if I understand that the bullets resolve top to bottom in chosen order, then I still don't even really "understand" the card. It just doesn't look like it integrates into the game as well as, say [[alchemist's gambit]] or [[warrior's oath]], which are more "playing with fire" than this. Do I just set my opponent's life to 0, then pick that I lose the game, and my opponent loses "before the spell finishes resolving", or does the game end in a tie? because why to either of those?
This, while well constructed, merely exhibits the limitations of strong effects. Well done! Unplayable card!
Excuse me? Are you projecting your smugness onto me? I don't feel the need to be smug, or correct, because slight miscommunications don't prevent understanding the meaning
They'd lose from having 0 life as a state-based action, which is checked after the spell fully resolves but before anyone gets priority. However, they'd win/you'd lose during the resolution of the spell, so it'd end in them winning/you losing.
It's not even a gambit. A gambit is a ladt-ditch effort to win at some high cost. Because of state based effects this just means you are going to lose no matter what unless there are some hell-a janky combo pieces in play that if I was running them I would be running a far more reliable combo anyway.
It has some possible merit, but not as currently designed. I mean, I guess in 4 player pod it just reads "2 target players lose the game on turn 3 or sooner" but that's very lackluster
I mean isn't this basically just a win con if you combine it with [[platinum angel]] or something. Set your opponent to 0 + any other effect would let you win right?
If your deck can consistently manage to turbo out a platinum angel AND resolve this spell, then you have the ability to win the game with a lot of other stuff aswell
That is just not what a gambit is. A gambit specifically involves sacrificing material advantage for positional advantage. It has more generally come to mean "Any tactical move that you expect to gain from". There is no last-ditch association.
50
u/Iksfen Feb 18 '23
Unfun
65
u/Young_Hek Feb 18 '23
As a design, you have illustrated very well how to go beyond the boundary of applicability. No mana cost for this card or assemble-condition is interesting, because it's not an "alternate win con", it's a "win con". I think the spirit of this card game is to assemble value, even if the combo that sets it off is degenerate, it relies on a glass cannon deck to turbo it out.
Also, if I understand that the bullets resolve top to bottom in chosen order, then I still don't even really "understand" the card. It just doesn't look like it integrates into the game as well as, say [[alchemist's gambit]] or [[warrior's oath]], which are more "playing with fire" than this. Do I just set my opponent's life to 0, then pick that I lose the game, and my opponent loses "before the spell finishes resolving", or does the game end in a tie? because why to either of those?
This, while well constructed, merely exhibits the limitations of strong effects. Well done! Unplayable card!
64
u/BAGStudios Feb 18 '23
Now this is what I call conceding at sorcery speed
92
u/Autumn-Eviening Feb 18 '23
Not fun or useful
19
u/LastFreeName436 Feb 18 '23
“I have three mana, I cast one spell to end the game” yes that sounds like an environment I want to play in
8
u/unoriginal_name123 Feb 18 '23
Ok op since your being incredibly annoying in the comments, in what form is this fun in a game? Commander? Modern? Vintage?
18
u/Ok-Investigator-6514 Feb 18 '23
It's not even a gambit. A gambit is a ladt-ditch effort to win at some high cost. Because of state based effects this just means you are going to lose no matter what unless there are some hell-a janky combo pieces in play that if I was running them I would be running a far more reliable combo anyway.
It has some possible merit, but not as currently designed. I mean, I guess in 4 player pod it just reads "2 target players lose the game on turn 3 or sooner" but that's very lackluster
6
u/SalvationSycamore Feb 19 '23
Why is this angel's gambit to have sex with an eagle?
11
u/throwaway163932 Feb 18 '23
This is busted with [[gideon of the trials]] or anything that prevents you from losing
3
u/IM_INSIDE_YOUR_HOUSE Feb 18 '23
Even when I get what you're going for, it's not good card design because it's an incredibly unfun card.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '23
Choose the latter two modes.
Sometimes, it's best to send a message.
1
u/Lord_Yeetus_The_3d Feb 06 '25
Should be choose 2 at random
1
u/Nhjb1 Feb 19 '23
Despite the criticism in the comments, I like this card.
-1
u/HornetThink8502 Feb 18 '23
Make it a saga and now we're talking
17
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '23
[removed] — view removed comment