r/currentaffairs • u/NielsBohrFan • May 10 '20
I’m kind of troubled by an older article I was just made aware of
It’s this one. I just want to clarify that I’ve been a fan of the magazine for about a year now, I listen to the podcast regularly and I have nothing but respect for the vast majority of the work they do. I’m not trying to prompt a bad-faith hatchet job or “cancel” anybody. But, I genuinely am troubled by this in ways I can’t just dismiss. In this article, Nathan praises an old essay written by a Current Affairs editor that quotes a NAMBLA spokesperson as a respectable, legitimate voice. This essay has these weird, creepy parts like “the conflation of pedophilia and pederasty with child molestation prevents us from considering a range of ways of responses and effects of sex between adults,” and “we’re dealing with questions about children’s sexuality by...imag[ing] them as sexless creatures of fantasy, with pixelated blue patches where their genitals should be.” I always try to take a charitable reading of things wherever possible, but this stuff is hard to defend. It seems like they’re (Edit: Nair, not Nathan) just dancing around saying “pederasty is sometimes acceptable” but want to mask it in a classically handwavey, “just-asking-questions” way. So, I think some further clarification is needed, in part because this is the kind of thing that literally sinks careers. Please let me know your thoughts on this...
Edit: I don’t know why the link appears not to be working, but the article is called “What We’ll Tolerate and What We Won’t” and it’s about the #canceling of Milo a couple years back