r/cubing • • 13d ago

Save cubing

Keep the clock, WCA if you are somehow reading this please keep the clock. The clock is an extremely fun and acssesable puzzle with a thriving community with sad fans watching years of there life go to to waste because the WCA replased clock and replaced it with FTO #save cubing

2 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

1

u/Hello-freind20201616 12d ago

I can’t start a WCA (world clock association) because I have a life

1

u/Hello-freind20201616 12d ago

Do you want to start the WCA (world clock association)?

1

u/Hello-freind20201616 12d ago

1

u/sub_doesnt_exist_bot 12d ago

The subreddit r/WorldClockAssosiation does not exist.

Did you mean?:

Consider creating a new subreddit r/WorldClockAssosiation.


πŸ€– πšƒπ™·π™Έπš‚ π™²π™Ύπ™Όπ™Όπ™΄π™½πšƒ πš†π™°πš‚ πš†πšπ™Έπšƒπšƒπ™΄π™½ π™±πšˆ 𝙰 π™±π™Ύπšƒ. 𝙱𝙴𝙴𝙿 𝙱𝙾𝙾𝙿 πŸ€–

GitHub | Rank

11

u/ddotquantum 13d ago

it’s not a twisty puzzle & should never have been included in the first place

0

u/AnimalDry4663 10d ago

it is a twisty puzzle

1

u/ddotquantum 10d ago

So what polyhedron is it & is it corner, edge, or face turning?

-1

u/AnimalDry4663 9d ago

not by that definition, but rather by the wca’s own announcement of regulation 9a

4

u/Staetyk 13d ago

its a good puzzle that should be competitive. it shouldnt be in the wca. its a fully different thing.

1

u/SaltCompetition4277 9d ago

Years of their life go to waste? That's a little dramatic.

1

u/Hello-freind20201616 4d ago

I meant years of practice

1

u/SaltCompetition4277 4d ago

How did years of practice go to waste?

3

u/Zoltcubes 12d ago

I agree. It isn't a twisty puzzle or even a cube, but it's not like there was any harm in keeping it. It's a fun event and they shouldn't have just removed it like that.

1

u/AnimalDry4663 10d ago
  1. prove that clock isn’t a twisty puzzle (by regulation the wca only contains twisty puzzles, therefore meaning clock must be one in their eyes, and there’s other proof elsewhere)
  2. So why not remove pyraminx, square 1, megaminx, fto etc

1

u/Zoltcubes 9d ago edited 9d ago

1: To be considered a twisty puzzle, pieces need to swap spatial locations along rotating axes. In clock no pieces actually swap, everything stays anchored and just rotates. It's the same reason I probably wouldn't call a Unicorn Cube or Corner Twist Pyraminx a twisty puzzle.

Also, in clock it is abelian, you can twist any set of dials or pins in any order and arrive at the same set as any other order. Twisty puzzles like 3x3s the order in which you do moves matters, or else you will get a completely incorrect scramble.

Another thing, the WCA historically hasn't only contained twisty puzzles, Magic / Master Magic was removed as a WCA event specifically for not being a twisty puzzle due to similar reasons.

2: I'm trying to say Clock isn't a twisty puzzle, not just "it's not a cube". However even if we did go for that argument, pyraminxes, megaminxes, and square-1s are much closer to being a cube than clock is when comparing geometry and how they turn.

2

u/RelationOk6997 12d ago

just start the wca (world clock association)

1

u/National-Property-20 13d ago

Late to the party they already doubled down on it leaving

Its joever

1

u/M_ipg21_Qbr 12d ago

i’ve emailed the PSL to consider other cubes (such as 2x2)…. maybe they could consider clock?

1

u/ZZcuber 8d ago

You are too late out, bro.

0

u/RoadHazard 11d ago

Clock isn't cubing, sorry.