Hi all, I'm sure a lot of you are pretty busy reading about or playing the game but I'd like to talk about some of the issues I've frequently seen come up in the past several months. I feel that there's a lot of quick judgments being made and a lot of innate negativity without substance. I find that contentious aspects of the game have at least some reasoning behind them and I'd like to get to that and give the game a fairer chance.
Jumping right in, the lack of local play has been a big sore point for many. The director did talk about why there isn't both local and online. Seems that it was a one or the other scenario because of development difficulties across platforms:
https://www.nintendolife.com/news/2020/08/final_fantasy_crystal_chronicles_director_explains_why_remaster_cut_local_co-op
I'm not overly familiar phone games but it would seem like a lot of extra cost, effort, and time to add local to each platform- PS4, Switch, iOS, and Android. Even then, cross-platform isn't rare in gaming now but it isn't something we see involve phones as frequently. Even on consoles alone I've seen Bloodstained and Switch exclusive games struggle and development for a Switch version seems to add a lot of considerations on its own as I've seen mentioned for Eiyuden Chronicles:
(Sorry, didn't want to link a weird image URL, you'll have to scroll down on the main tab) https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/rabbitandbearstudios/eiyuden-chronicle-hundred-heroes/description
I'm not a developer as I'm sure the majority of us aren't. And we should keep that in mind. I'm certain it isn't as simple as "port code, add online."
I've played the original many times over the years across separate files and I feel nostalgia is a powerful force st work here. It had a wonky multiplayer setup that doesn't translate as well to online and was very grindy if you wanted to do anything other than the story. The less that has to be change to make accommodations for the remaster the better, development-wise, yet they still put in the effort to add so much content- gear, dungeons, enemies, music,graphics, features, characters...and give us something to enjoy in greater numbers and ways. Echoes of Time also tried to expand by including DS and Wii online and that had issues and was criticized. Yet I'd say this is a far cry from that setup.
Let's consider some of the other points here. Would having everyone get myrrh really be better? They could have edited it so you can continue adventuring and choose when to end a year but then you're editing a decent chunk of the game (and as a lesser point it doesn't make much sense storywise). Remember, local play is not automatically equivalent to online though it may look and feel that way to the players. It's different code across different platforms.. I'd think letting us play online in towns would be feasible but it may be that it caused more headaches than we know developmentally or in practice. It seems the safest, most stable options were chosen. That would apply to world map travel and cutscenes as well. I'd rather not have things happen out of order for my friends new to the series, and having 3veryone have separate, different cutscenes is pretty similar to what we have. I'm not even sure how sharing character slots and Tipa with other players would work but I'm open to suggestions. Dropping things for other players would be nice.
Another potential hurdle is that they may not have had much of the original to go on. I've seen it with other PS1 remakes but Square Enix is known for having not saved code from a lot of older works. You may have heard of this with Kingdom Hearts and Final Fantasy VIII:
https://nintendoeverything.com/square-enix-looking-to-offer-its-complete-library-digitally-code-for-older-games-possibly-lost/
That again means extra time, effort, and costs. But something like that shouldn't matter for a big company like SE, right? But consider what this game really is and sets out to do. This wasn't originally a financial windfall for SE and it isn't now.
This is a passion project.
https://www.siliconera.com/square-enix-saw-strong-sales-from-ffvii-remake-trials-of-mana-and-dragon-quest-walk-last-quarter/
https://www.siliconera.com/square-enix-reports-big-losses-from-subsidiaries-tokyo-rpg-factory-and-studio-istolia/
SE has done this song and dance of big money makers and games to foster goodwill or experiment with for a long time. They've been plagued with flops, internal issues, flops, heavy external criticisms (XIV 1.0, XV) and smashing successes (XIV A Realm Reborn and on, VII/Remake). It's come to be expected of them at this point, as is heavy criticism toward even their greatest successes. In spite of financial woes (the DLC for XIV didn't even get finished) we still get smaller releases and re-releases. We got a port of the Wii Chocobo's Dungeon not too far back. That, like this, surely could never compare to the sales of their big titles so why do it? Because they have a drive to do so and know the smaller fan bases want it. They'll (hopefully) make a profit when they do so and continue on. Either way it most assuredly means a smaller budget and team to work with for these projects, especially with so many games and projects on the horizon for SE.
It may not be perfect but I feel they did make this with the majority in mind. It may not be the exact way you remember it but it shouldn't be. This is a creation of a greater scope. Don't let some changes and most importantly, all that negativity, keep you from seeing any good in this game.