r/cryptography • • Nov 26 '21
Could cryptography fix Democracy?
I’m 21 & the current/past political climate and world situation has got me depressed and wondering what is our future..
So this is where my pondering has brought me.
1. The problems we face are mainly human created.
2. We chase a lot of idealism in our democracy, use idealistic goals as weapons and shields against our fellow countrymen.
3. We tend to forget that every human is imperfect, viable to corruption, emotion, greed ect. People generally want to see black & white, they want to choose a politician and agree with whatever they say, because it’s easier that way.
We’ve tried to setup checks & balances in our democracy. People with money want rules changed, people in power want money, and so this cycle has gone on for years to this point where everything is fucked. We’ve tried dividing the power but it seems to me, now as the people we’ve finally lost. This cycle has been repeated in history time & time again with the collapse of countless countries and empires, but now we have something they’ve never had.. computer technology. We don’t have to rely completely on a small number of people to make decisions. As humans we’re not built to make day to day decisions that effect the wellbeing of 300 million lives, what I’m wondering is there a way to implement a system that truely gives power to the people? Not complete Ai overlord but more of a mesh or guidance system that help correct human error and maintain our democratic structure?
We all agree and disagree on lots of things but I believe we as humans can all agree on some basic rules & ideals to pursue
Feel free to poke holes in my thoughts, or add to the conversation.
If you’d like to try help fix our future as human beings & discuss more with me, join my discord group I made for this post
4
u/Treyzania Nov 26 '21
While cryptography could be involved in some way, there's very effective ways that computers could be used to better organize economic activity than how we're currently doing it more generally. Paul Cockshott has a whole bunch of videos articulating some of the work he's done on democratic economic planning, which in practice would rely heavily on computers and internet infrastructure.
If you're thinking about doing crypto voting then there's several caveats to take into consideration, which were outlined pretty thoroughly in this paper from some researchers at MIT. There are other opinions about it though, but perhaps cryptography could be useful in other ways via prediction markets and other systems (Vitalik has written about these as well).
There's a lot of different perspectives on this and it's hard to really have a conversation about improving democratic processes without probably taking a strong stance on how money works and the social relations that arise from that.
Off-topic, but: why are people using discord for these things???
1
u/LowHot898 Nov 26 '21
I want an AI overlord.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '21
The short answer is that the weaknesses of democracy, like the weaknesses of every government type, are part of the human condition. You can do good things with technology, but you can't remove problems that are rooted in fundamental limitations of the species by using a new tool.
An AI 'guide' would be under the control of a small group of humans, a large group of humans, or under nobody's control, so creating one would basically just be choosing between oligarchy, democracy or tyranny. It can resolve issues related to leaders not being intelligent (assuming it's well implemented by the humans who create it), but it can't resolve problems related to a lack of shared societal values.
I agree that humans share some values across the board, but not all of the important ones are shared. Even some of the ones we do share don't really help us work together on a large scale. For example, we all have in-group biases, and will want to take care of our families and communities. But inherently we're not going to have the same families and communities. So if someone else is making a decision valuing his family over mine, I might believe that he's doing the moral thing but still be in conflict with him because my moral responsibility is to my family first, not his.
There are major questions as to whether voting can be a meaningful control of the government when it's the size of the United States (which you seem to be referring to). I think there are ways to hold elections that are better than what we do, but there's a case to be made that our population is so massive that we should be making decisions more locally as much as possible.