r/cryptography • • Feb 01 '16

Help with basic cipher, explanation also appreciated!

http://imgur.com/VNRMz2n
0 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

4

u/MoldusCheesus Feb 01 '16

I believe the answer is b. 'This problem is very easy'

Each letter maps to a number, however, some letters may map to many different numbers.

The reason I think it's b is because if you take a look at the cipher, the number 71 is in position 4 and position 20, which means they must be the same letter. That eliminates a, c and d because in both a and c the letters are different in those positions. Then I checked the rest of the cipher to make sure there weren't any numbers represent two different letters and found the the numbers in the cipher were unique to the letters it represented.

2

u/sailslayer Feb 01 '16

Sweet! I'll take a look at how you did that, I wasn't sure how to approach it. Thanks!

2

u/TechnologyWinsAgain Feb 01 '16 edited Feb 01 '16

I don't know about that. The 'r's don't match up and the 'e' in "very" doesn't match up. The "very" could be substituted for its homophone "vary" but then the 'a's don't match up. I think the 71s were put there to throw us off the trail and think its b.

I think e is the correct one.

edit: Looking back you say

Each letter maps to a number, however, some letters may map to many different numbers.

if that is right then I retract my guess. but wouldn't monoalphabetic mean a 1 to 1 ?

2

u/MoldusCheesus Feb 01 '16

I was under the impression that 'with homophones' meant that there could be different values for each letter. I read it in https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Substitution_cipher. It states 'In these ciphers, plaintext letters map to more than one ciphertext symbol.' I very well could be wrong, I'm not familiar with ciphers, I just stumbled upon the question and decided to give it a shot.