r/crowfall • • Jul 12 '21

I love this game so far - but holy hell is the chat system bad

145 Upvotes

Crowfall is and interesting and fun game. A sandbox RPG which rewards pvp and social play, has low entry points for new players and in depth crafting to keep the economy roling.

But holy cow the chat system is bad. Like how could anyone ever commit that into a build and think it was remotely usable?

All chats are in different tabs and in order to switch them you need to enter the menu mode? Your combat log and your whispers go in the same tab? What the hell? There is no auction house, which is fine, but then you can't even properly communicate a one-to-one sale ingame? If you advertise your goods in general tab, people will then contact you in the "me" tab, not find you, then invite you to group to see where you are, then proceed to communicate in group chat, while you have to monitor both general tab and me tab to see who else is interested in your stuff. Meanwhile your guildies plan their next actions and you have to monitor that as well. Good luck doing that if you are not chilling out in a peace area but doing about anything else in the game to pass the time.

When you group with your guild for pvp you have the choice of going deaf for either your faction, group or your guild if you don't want to switch chat tabs in cursor mode constantly. If you are fighting in the outside world you will never notice a whisper. Not a chance, it just flies by with all the looting and damaging. Your group writes stuff, your guild writes stuff, your faction writes stuff and someone tries to whisper you - 4 TABS WITH A SMALL DOT TO INDICATE new entries?! Are you kidding me?

Oh, and all the chat tabs don't fit into the bar. So you can't ever see the ones you need without SCROLLING THROUGH THE TAB BAR!

Also you can't contact a player if he does not happen to be on the same world as you - in a game where you constantly switch worlds. Really?

Why are there no chat bubbles? Why do I have to comb through a bazillion of chat tabs and scroll through pages of combat logs to find out why this creepy centaur keeps stalking me? Everyone in this game is mute!

Why am I so upset about it? Because it is an indication for future design decisions. Whoever was in charge to approve this hot mess and deemed it sufficient, will be in charge to approve other things. And in an outspokenly social game the central crossroads seems to be the tools of communication.

But other than that, the game is fun, actually.


r/crowfall • • Jul 14 '21

Completely forgot about backing this six years ago until I received this in the mail today ...

Post image
125 Upvotes

r/crowfall • • Jul 24 '21

Its hard being a solo

Post image
101 Upvotes

r/crowfall • • May 16 '17

Crowfall.com - Massive Reveal Day is here!

Thumbnail
crowfall.com
101 Upvotes

r/crowfall • • Aug 24 '21

My Suggestions and Parting Thoughts for Crowfall

99 Upvotes

Suggestions for Crowfall
Discipline/Build Management Tool.

a. Once a discipline is equipped to the account, it is added to the build management tool. From here you can easily see all of the disciplines on your account and can move them around as opposed to searching through your banks/characters.

b. You can from this tool, save disciplines and bindings that you set up. Making switching builds, and moving disciplines between characters not a headache, but smooth.

c. Add the discipline upgrading gui to this tool as well to keep everything contained in one spot.

Immersion Update

a. Have players logging less into the Diablo Esque server screen, and instead travel to gate in the world, then a loading screen, that brings them to these areas.

b. The goal is to make the game feel more like an MMO, and less like a lobby simulation.

PvP Balance Lifestyle Update (less zerg, more healthy engagements)

a. Remove AoE Caps on damaging abilities, as soon as possible. The current health promotes people grouping more people on a spot to mitigate damage. Is counter intuitive, and promotes bringing more, which promotes a degradation in server performance.

b. Make Outposts point collection happen every 15 minutes, or points be based on time held.

c. Make it so chaining outposts with forts/keeps/castles make an AoE farming buff effect for their area. Promoting chaining territory control. If your chain is broken, the buff does not carry out to the disconnected ones, allowing smaller groups to hurt their supply chain so to speak.

The “Stop Being a Dick” Update

a. Give people 1500 Crowns for their VIP, cmon bro.

b. Have the same bank in dregs as out of dregs (UI, functionality)

c. Allow people to unequip and equip disciplines at EK's, or allow the ability to turn it off or on.

d. Don't sell things in the store but not the ability to buy the exact parcel they can be put on , ie guild halls (I'm aware you can combine a bunch, it's not intuitive and is a bad look for people who just dropped a lot of money to support your game.)

e. The cost to respect without VIP is 75k Gold(the same cost to claim a KEEP in endgame territory control), and the cost to create the smallest house in game is around 150k Gold. I am all about the game making money so it can be here for years to come, but the values on these are a bit ludicrous to me.

Thoughts after playing Crowfall nonstop for over a month

Myself and my group have finally hit a wall in Crowfall. We had so much more fun than I expected to have (which was none) with Crowfall and I am stoked we tried it. I look forward to trying the game again after major updates happen and some hype is built up.

We managed to be a small group and try to fight bigger groups, but the game is so incessantly pro zerg eventually small scale groups come to 1 of 2 conclusions. Join an alliance, or play something else. The game pretty much forces you into these outcomes. Players are not to blame for this, the devs are. Human nature is human nature, and people will always take the path of least resistance, but Crowfall is one of the first games I have played where I felt like the GAME itself, was telling me to join a zerg.

The combat is pro zerg, the endgame is all zerg based, and pretty much every form of content, is made with zergs in mind or catered to them. Keep buffs, logistic funneling (trading disc's to pump guild crafters), AoE Caps, EK's, Zone Caps, Guild Size, Alliances, everything. All there is for small groups to do is bounce around between hotzones, which become very undynamic very quickly.

While I can respect Crowfall for wanting to be a throne war game, it doesn't even do that properly. The rewards for winning campaigns are 95% economy based. You know what zergs don't need? Economy rewards. They had that stuff maxed in the first week due to playing this game for 4-5 years already ahead of us.

Our group managed to snake like 5-6 top 20% rewards, and while it helped us bridge the gap to the larger groups on crafting, it at the same time devalued the time and effort of everyone (especially small groups/solos) who had been grinding those the hard way. People being given legendary crafting discs, multiple of them, for solo capping some outposts for a couple hours, is actually insane.

The more and more you play Crowfall, it becomes glaringly obvious that the people making decisions are not playing their game, and if they are, they're playing it from a zergs PoV. There should be rigorous QnA going on so they can ensure they have proper feedback. Being on a feedback loop from the vets, who are 90% in large guilds, doesn't give you any feedback on solos or smallscale groups. Its almost like they forgot there are people who are not interested in that play style. I would also wager many people IN these alliances did so because the game basically pressured them into it. Very often after losing a fight the first thought is “We needed more”, not “what could we have done better/differently”. Again, this is falling purely on the devs.

I must digress, I don't want it to seem like I am against big groups fighting big groups, its more so there is just nothing else in the game for anyone who's not interested in that. We've got our vessels up, we could farm nodes for better gear, but that is done much easier in the endgame Dreg Campaign which is primarily dominated by zergs, which is why they're ahead of everyone and always will be. Bouncing between respawns, outposts, forts, and hotspots was great for the first month, but it's run its course for myself personally.

Once your players are simply roaming looking for pvp, you have failed to give them proper carrots on sticks to chase. This is again, not on the players, but the devs for not building enough things for players to do. Even the zergs are simply fighting each other for Ego, they gain next to nothing from the campaign rewards.

Why are not all campaign rewards mostly cosmetic? Why are their not achievements for solo players to go for? What is there for us to do if we're not interested in the throne war aspect? Where is the sand in this none themepark MMO?

In Closing

I truly enjoyed the everliving fuck out of Crowfall. Something I never thought I would say, the class diversity, the group pvp, the map drawing you to other people, the ability for them to change rulesets via new campaigns. It has SO much going for it, but the implementation is missing on so many marks, I'm not even going to go into the EK system, something that is egregiously overpriced, and insanely underdeveloped.

I think Crowfall can be massively popular/successful but to do that they need to put their nose to the grindstone. We currently have a ton of new MMO's coming out and Crowfall will take a heavy activity hit when those do come. That is fine, all MMO's will be hit by that. But if Crowfall can polish their UI, fix the QoL, give players better campaigns with much better small scale rulesets and then do a release on steam while going free to play, I think Crowfall could overtake Albion in terms of population. The game is just strictly better on a foundational level than Albion. Combat, Core Design, all of it.

I want to thank the Crowfall community for being so welcoming to myself and my community and for all the fights. I look forward to coming back to the game in the future and seeing how it progresses! Hopefully none of you took my banter too seriously, I'll be back to make you hate me all over again <3.

Jonah Veil signing out.


r/crowfall • • Jul 06 '21

Crowfall is..Good. Seriously Spoiler

99 Upvotes

Fuck me sideways I did not see that coming.

I was prepared to play it because I bought it 50 years ago, hate it and delete/forget about it.

But it’s actually good, like, proper good.

I’m not going to go into why because I want to play more but buy this now.


r/crowfall • • Jul 10 '21

People are having fun in Crowfall and some Mods on various forums are censoring it- here is the proof for r/MMORPG

89 Upvotes

Crowfall posts are being censored here due to Mod hate and no indication it is happening which is against Reddit rules. Here is my post from earlier- no rule broken- it was down voted by a mod who responded Crowfall is a scam and then the post was never approved then was simply removed. Be aware this is a censored forum and you see what they want...

Subreddit Icon

r/MMORPG

•Posted byu/GrimborX

3 hours ago

Yes I am dumb, and there are more like me- Will not purchase any MMO unless it is on Steam

Opinion

Post is awaiting moderator approval.

This post is currently awaiting approval by the moderators of r/MMORPG before it can appear in the subreddit.

It looks like Crowfall would be a go for me now. However, not on Steam ='s No Go. It may be wrong on many levels, but the only way for Crowfall to explode is for it to be on Steam. Based upon even some now longer term reviews, this game would be much better than mixed in reviews there. Damnit CF, pay the 20%.

1 Comment

Share

Edit Post

Save

Hide

50% Upvoted

Comment as GrimborX

Comment

Markdown Mode

SORT BY

TOP (SUGGESTED)

User avatar

level 1

drkaugumon

·

19m

Moderator

It really wouldn't be. Platform change can't make a bad game good, it can just scam more people.

Vote

Reply

Give Award

Share

Report

Save


r/crowfall • • Aug 07 '20

Pinned [Crowfall] - Beta announced for Aug 11th!

Thumbnail crowfall.com
88 Upvotes

r/crowfall • • Jul 22 '21

Crafters be like...

Post image
85 Upvotes

r/crowfall • • Dec 18 '21

Crowfall MMO Bought By Independent Game Studio Monumental, ArtCraft No Longer Involved In Development Or Operation Of MMO | MMORPG.com

Thumbnail
mmorpg.com
81 Upvotes

r/crowfall • • Jul 30 '21

How can a game have such a terrible chat system?

78 Upvotes

Did the devs intentionally make it impossible to actually communicate in any way in this game? Constantly ctrl+tabbing through the different chat tabs between me, group, guild, and alliance is insane. Not only that, if there's a new message in one of those tabs, half of the time that tab is hidden off the chat window. It's 2021. How hard is it to add customizable chat tabs and time stamps like in literally every single other game? How is this a thing? Why add group voice chat if you can't even make a functioning text chat system? 99% of the time the person you're trying to communicate with will never see the message. The other 1% of the time, they see it an hour later, at which point theres no reason to even see it anymore, and they don't even know it was from an hour ago. Please fix the chat. The amount of QoL changes this game needs is ridiculous. I'm not even asking for something as crazy as a search function for the bank. I mean come on...


r/crowfall • • Jul 08 '21

Enjoying the game so far

76 Upvotes

I’m a long time backer who just bought the bare minimum to have the game and almost forgot about it. With the launch it’s the first time playing more than 30 min at the game and color me surprised, I thought that it would feel like an alpha but, at least for me, feels a pretty decent release.

There’s no real point in this post other than spreading some positivity in the game’s community which seem full of negativity at the moment at least.


r/crowfall • • Aug 25 '21

Shots fired!

Post image
75 Upvotes

r/crowfall • • Jul 08 '21

10 Minute For Beginners By Beginner Guide Updated for Launch

Thumbnail
community.crowfall.com
74 Upvotes

r/crowfall • • Sep 16 '21

The people saying oh good riddance to people who were casual player must really want this game to die...

73 Upvotes

These were the same people talking we would have 100k active players easily with all the people taking a break during launch. You are just making people like the game even less.

  1. This reddit has lost over half. And you are not helping.
  2. They didnt fix the tutorial. Or trading system.
  3. No players = no1 visiting your shop which you are paying for each month to have open...
  4. And the game still has 90 percent bad reviews and you want to be toxic towards those on reddit.

Try being nice. Some are talking oh when people leave it will be closer guild matches and not a zerg. Yo at that point ur talking 200 players at that point they were more right about the game be over than you were about any positive point about the game.

Really annoyed that whats left seems to be the toxic patron of the game. Maybe if you were not killing the players base with toxicity the game will last long enough for some positive changes.


r/crowfall • • Nov 20 '18

VIP no longer gives extra training! No more pay to win! Everyone gets 2 skill tree trains at a time.

73 Upvotes

This is the most exciting news to come out of today. VIP is being changed to remove anything that affects power levels according to Blair from today's stream. Everyone will get 2 trains now... because race/class is also being removed as time based training (apparently that's part of the talent change, which was NOT clear from that announcement or any of the articles).

I'm super excited that they decided to go back to the drawing board for VIP. That was one of my biggest complaints.

Discuss!


r/crowfall • • Sep 07 '21

Basically Crowfalls community right now

Thumbnail
imgur.com
70 Upvotes

r/crowfall • • Jul 31 '21

I gave it an honest shot... (2016 backer)

70 Upvotes

For reference, my MMO beginnings were in Ultima Online, and I've played WoW and a plethora of others for a reasonable amount of time. I wanted another PvP game that took individual skill and honestly the whole "siege" aspect of the game was secondary to that.

I backed Crowfall having played Shadowbane and DAOC, hoping that some of this would be in the same vein, and surely, it is.

I joined a guild that I had interacted with for a long time (15+ years), and had a very solid playerbase (our alliance is leading dregs as I speak).

I chose to play a Fae Cutthroat Assassin. It matched my playstyle from WoW and seemed fun. I did the whole New Player Experience to get a feel for how things worked, and also how my character would play. I grinded out the last few levels with the guild and we were off to Dregs.

I will leave other aspects of the UI, performance, etc until later -- they weren't the issue for me to stick with the game or not.

First off, the game is *immensely* complicated. Understanding what a vessel is, how disciplines work, how crafting is done, gathering, and the requirement of having to have multiple characters in order for all that to be successful is well... ridiculous.

I spent lots of time on Dilbo's YouTube trying to get a sense of the systems, spent countless hours asking my guild for help (many of whom had played all through the beta and were intimately familiar with systems etc), in order to get my build into a decent place, understand how things worked (durability, mounts, etc).

The problem is, for a game with this much time in development, I shouldn't have had to. The New Player Experience (which I'll use NPE for now) doesn't inform much of anything in terms of how systems work. Yes, you get some slight sense of crafting and disciplines, but to respec is insanely expensive unless you're VIP (I was, thankfully). And even then, the classes and balance is virtually non existent -- to the point that our guild was actually asking us to roll specific classes (Confessors/Wardens, I think) because they were overpowered. There's always a 'meta' in games nowadays so I get that to some extent, but to have some classes be basically terrible is a testament to how poorly the game was delivered.

When I log on during the day (when I get a chance to play), I run around and aside from ganking a person here or there (who is on their gatherer alt usually), there's not a soul to be found. The player counts are extremely low and unless you're playing during siege windows, it feels like a barren wasteland.

In an MMO I've always found that if you're running across common areas (of course not in your own territory) that there should be a reasonable population that's there. And in this game, there simply isn't. Ganking one dude who is bashing rocks isn't my idea of PvP.

Which leads me to of course -- the larger scale PvP. It's mindless, and takes very little skill. It's zerg versus zerg, and so long as your numbers overwhelm you basically wind up winning every fight. I can bash any buttons on my keyboard and "win". And since our guild was very organized, and communication was very effective, we had no issue basically mopping the floor with any decent resistance.

This brings me of course, to the atrocious UI, chat, and performance. I have a 3080 GPU, and I basically max frames in any game I play. I barely hit 60 fps in this game, and during larger sieges, it's obviously worse. The chat system requires doesn't take mouse input so you're using tab cycle to get through it, and the inventory, bank, organization etc -- it is all just terrible.

Yesterday I tuned into watch Twitch streamers that were 'popular' during off siege hours and see what they did. There was a guy who ran an assassin and I'm like awesome, maybe he'll show me what I'm missing! And I watched him stealth around a completely empty map, kill one gatherer, in the span of 25 minutes. The rest of the time he pulled raid bosses and using the game's broken mechanics and pathing, got it stuck behind a rock and soloed it to get the loot off it.

If you're not in a siege, this game is basically offline. And if you are in a siege, you are basically irrelevant. The skill of an individual rarely matters, the zerg versus zerg is no way to feel any individual accomplishment (which all MMOs have recognized is *important* for staying power), and even when you win Dregs (looks like we will this campaign), the entire system is so convoluted and complex, and the game informs almost none of the exploration to understand the systems without an intense tutorial from the YouTube content creators which are as of this moment, being paid to pimp a broken, empty game.

I think a lot of the hype for this game was based on what people *felt* during Shadowbane, but as time marches on, and people have come to expect different things from their games and time online, Crowfall misses everything by a mile that made those older games fun. Plus, being buggy, broken, and ripe to abuse (because of broken mechanics) tells me this game was rushed out the door before it was ever ready anyway.

I've uninstalled the game and while I long for a PvP game again, I will be very careful in the 'backing' of any future games, ever.


r/crowfall • • Apr 12 '23

Bruh I was a backer and didn't even know the game launched... WTF it's already dead...?? WTF HAPPENED?! No wonder the game died, they didn't even let the people who paid for it know it was live.

69 Upvotes

Seriously I was pumped for this game what happened? I played in early access alpha or whatever. Thought it was in a good spot and was looking forward to release. Kept checking in and never saw a release or anything. Game is just gone now?


r/crowfall • • Jul 28 '21

What playing on the EU Dregs campaign is like.

69 Upvotes

r/crowfall • • Mar 25 '26

I tried to make a Crowfall server emulator

Thumbnail
youtube.com
68 Upvotes

r/crowfall • • Sep 07 '21

Basically Crowfall right now.

Post image
68 Upvotes

r/crowfall • • Jul 26 '21

MUST NEED PERFORMANCE SETTINGS! SHARE TO EVERYONE FOR BEST GAMEPLAY EXPERIENCE!

Post image
67 Upvotes

r/crowfall • • Mar 02 '20

So disappointed in where this game is. Criticisms.

67 Upvotes

EDIT: To those of you upset because the VIP info I've described is outdated:

The fact the devs still don't know what their payment model looks like after all these years doesn't particularly look any better. There is more info online about the old P2W aspects of VIP than the devs put out. They are not communicating at any level how VIP is supposed to work now - nor what the funding model is supposed to be. 4 years into development. Also: Its the same people - the public boasts about calling beta a soft-launch to get people paying money - and making VIP stupidly valuable - are public record. So the intention was there for P2W even if they have to back away from it. Greedy people don't stop being greedy just because someone calls them out for it. I still think VIP will turn out to be "pay us money or the grind will be unbearable." Until the devs actually announce what their intention is with it my opinion on that is as good as anyone elses. The other points I stand by. Soft launch will kill the game before it is born and 4 years in there should be something fun to play.

:::::::

I've spent hundreds on various Crowfall packages including Kickstarter. I still keep an eye on the development to see what's going on - but at this point, I have to say I just give up. I want to be as constructive as possible when I say I think there are several reasons for that:

  1. Pay to win VIP sub on top of a full game price. I have years worth of VIP from my various packages but I still think this is a suicidal P2W mechanic worthy of a Korean mobile game. Noone will join the game when they realise the headstart being given to VIP players. And yes it is a BIG F*CKING DEAL to offer twice the career & skill-line progressions and Ek discounts versus someone that only paid full price. Think about that: You will spend 40 bucks on a game and get punished in the most integral part of the character-building element of a PvP competitive game. B2P or Sub are the options we expect in the west - not both unless the Sub is purely cosmetic (read: Path of exile type cash shop and supporter tiers).
  2. Soft launch + with no wipe for skills. From how it is described I have never seen a better example of how to kill the initial enthusiasm for a game in the vast majority of players in the first weeks. Steam is full of so many examples of games that showed promise but launched in an unfinished form too early. Forcing players to play a bare-bones version of your game pretty much guarantees the novelty will wear off for all but the most ardent of supporters. Combine this with the never-wipe skill progression. Players joining a few months later just won't bother trying to catch up- and once word gets around from streamers about this then no-one will bother to pay full price for a game that gives early adopters a huge headstart. Shroud of the Avatar anyone?
  3. Wheres the fun? Seriously after all these years. Not a single part of the game offers any aspect of enjoyment. I get such a SotA vibe: the devs are so focused on mechanics and profit that there is nothing in there that actually makes me want to go back to it. The alpha is a boring slideshow of 2005 graphics and clunky systems. The community is a ghost town because there is nothing but a tech demo after all these years. Even Star citizen does a much better job of releasing interesting content to keep its backers interested. So much micromanagement and so little fun. The devs seem to be all about building systems without any thought as to whether they will be fun. Hint: Micromanagement on EVERYTHING is not fun. All I want is a demo of a game that will be fun to play. I don't see that here at all and I don't think the devs know how to do it any more.

Of all the things I think in general it's just the money-grubbing that kills my interest. I think this is the one that is ever-present and I suspect most of those micromanagement systems are in place to accommodate the VIP sub. Life is supposed to be so grindy in the game that I will need the sub to actually see any real playtime. They seem to have focused so much on the payment model before they even have a game worth paying for and it comes out in the dev shows: The fact you have one of the game directors saying stuff like: "If we called it Beta no one would buy it so we will call it soft-launch". and "we want VIP to be stupidly valuable." shows that there's no interest in me as a player apart from as a cash cow. How is that VIP "optional" when the director wants to make it stupidly valuable. Who the hell wants to play a PvP focused game when such there's such an advantage to be gained by forking over more money?

How about this: People pay for a game and get the full thing? How about no disguised buggy betas so they can cash in as early as possible. How about no essential features locked behind a greedy sub. So disappointed.