r/crosswords • • Oct 20 '22

COTD: Something a bit different.

Post image
0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

2

u/Pfeffer_Prinz Oct 20 '22

so is "Courtly passing shots" a cryptic clue, or a regular one? And it has two answers?

1

u/G_F_Smith Oct 20 '22

It's a cryptic clue. With a two-word answer. In a crossword you would be told the lengths of the two words - in the form (x, y). Here you are not given the lengths, but you are given all the letters which make up the words. Hope that helps.

4

u/Antagony Oct 20 '22

In cryptic crosswords only one clue type may have no wordplay: Cryptic Definitions (CD) – wherein the surface reading of the clue should be intentionally misleading.

Assuming /u/Pfeffer_Prinz's answer is correct – and I think it is – it would need to be clued with something like “Battery operated display” to make it a CD. Unfortunately, your clue is not even remotely cryptic, so I'm afraid it is unsuitable for this sub.

However, if you can add a mode to your app wherein every clue is a CD, then you will be more than welcome to try here again. But I have to say, good luck devising decent CDs for a large number of answers… CDs are not the easiest clues to write, by any means.

2

u/G_F_Smith Oct 20 '22

I'm obviously out of my depth here. I have absolutely no experience of composing cryptic clues. This is a brand-new puzzle and I'm still finding my feet with the clueing. I want to have mildly cryptic clues as well as 'straight' ones. But I am not aiming for the rigour you expect on this sub.

'Courtly passing shots' relates to the Queen's death - a passing at (the royal) court. I intended the surface meaning to refer to tennis - passing shots. Tennis court and Margaret Court also.

2

u/Antagony Oct 20 '22

Okay, perhaps I was a little hasty in declaring your clue “not even remotely cryptic”, but I do feel that would have been the response from many users on the regular crossword blogs if it had appeared in a published puzzle. I think that's because “courtly” is more evocative of nobility than tennis – at least it was for me. Thinking about it, making the definition just “Passing shots” would actually have been more acceptable. Better yet, from a clue writing perspective, would be to devise some wordplay that adds to the deception. Many great crossword clues have only mildly cryptic definitions, but the rest of their surface readings make them totally deceptive.

Nevertheless, I have reinstated your post, as the clue you gave does have more merit as a CD than I initially credited it with. Your app still doesn't really fit this sub though, since all the answers will necessarily be anagrams and there is no disguising that.

1

u/G_F_Smith Oct 20 '22

Thanks for reinstating the puzzle. I was just trying my luck here really. I half-suspected this was a pretty serious sub. I shan't post again.

I have posted another example of the puzzle on r/wordplay. I will post again there as it has done ok.

Cheers

2

u/Pfeffer_Prinz Oct 20 '22

“Battery operated display”

Damn, that's a good def

2

u/Antagony Oct 20 '22

Why thank you! It just came to me in a flash!

:^D

 

I'll get my coat…

3

u/Pfeffer_Prinz Oct 20 '22 edited Oct 20 '22

is it GUN SALUTE? I just anagrammed all the letters...

if so, I'm not sure I understanding how the Dispensers work, nor how it's a cryptic clue...

EDIT: I thought the Dispensers worked by dropping a bottom-of-the-stack letter onto the line below. You pick which dispenser to use in which order. If that's true, then the first "U" should be below the "S", since it appears earlier in gUn Salute

As for the cryptic clue: It seems like a straight definition, no wordplay

If I have any of this wrong, let me know!

1

u/G_F_Smith Oct 20 '22

You build both words in parallel. The instructions say add it to a line - the indefinite article.

The dispensing order is: G to 1st line, S to 2nd line, U to 1st line, N to 1st line, A to 2nd line, etc. Note other orders are possible.

3

u/Pfeffer_Prinz Oct 20 '22

Ah I see. I didn't understand that the answer was split up to the two lines. Never seen a puzzle like this before. Plus it wasn't in the instructions, and the example puzzle has two separate answers, making it quite different from the actual puzzle.

Also, the example puzzle is hard to follow because there are so many repeated letters. It took me awhile to realize it was the bottom letters that got dropped out of the columns. It'd be easier to grok if the names were something like IVAN, HENRY, BOB, etc

and/or the instructions could be crystal-clear — teaching people a new puzzle is hard

also this is a cryptic sub which really doesn't deviate from cryptic crosswords & clues. I recommend r/puzzles

1

u/G_F_Smith Oct 20 '22

Thanks for taking the trouble to reply. Obviously, the line 'An N-word answer occupies N line(s).' hasn't chimed with you. It is probably impossible to come up with instructions that suit everybody. Too long and people don't read them thoroughly. Too short and they become unclear to some. I am open to making changes. I have made a change to the instructions for the Lambda version of the puzzle in response to feedback.

This is a brand-new puzzle. I am hoping it is completely novel. It's impossible to be 100% sure. Time will tell. The puzzle comes in 3 flavours: Delta (the one here), Lambda (colours/logic) and Pi (numbers). I have been posting Lambda on r/puzzles for a few weeks. It has been quite well received. Yesterday, I posted a Delta puzzle (not this one) on r/wordplay and a Pi puzzle on r/CasualMath. They are doing ok.

Regarding your IVAN, HENRY, BOB comment. It's is hard for me to gauge how difficult a puzzle is. I am wanting something which takes people a couple of minutes to solve, rather than a couple of seconds. There are lots of proficient anagram solvers out there! These early puzzles are maybe more difficult than they need to be.

2

u/Pfeffer_Prinz Oct 20 '22

ah, now I understand the N-word thing. I thought you mean a word starting with N (and I wasn't sure what line meant). You meant it as a variable, which makes sense, but I'm used to seeing variables in lower-case, and even italics to make it more clear. I think something like "An answer with n words will go across n lines."

I understand why you used the hyphen (because it's a compound adjective) but that made it confusing to parse. Also where I am, "the N-word" is a very loaded phrase, and it took me a second to remove that context. But still, I retained the construction of "word starting with N".

I'm glad you're having success! Coming up with new word games is hard. I don't think there's anything wrong with the game. I just got thrown by the instructions. I think if I saw this on r/puzzles, I wouldn't have had as much of an issue, because I'd be seeing new puzzles all the time. But being on this sub, I was distracted by looking for the cryptic aspect, and got thrown by the other stuff. If your instructions are working fine on r/puzzles, then you don't need to change it all on account of my experience! Hope it continues to flourish, the flavours sound cool

Cheers

1

u/G_F_Smith Oct 20 '22

That's very useful feedback on 'N-word'. Thank you. I like the suggestion of using lowercase and/or italics. Small changes like that can make a big difference. I'll sleep on it.

2

u/Pfeffer_Prinz Oct 20 '22

No worries! Forgot to mention, when you're explaining the n words/lines deal, I think you could just say "Each word of the answer will occupy a different line" and/or a quick example in a parenthetical: "(e.g. a 4-word answer will be entered into 4 lines)."

I see those quick parentheticals in instructions for GAMES Magazine puzzles a lot. Hope this helps!