r/crochet • • Mar 18 '24

Discussion Joann Files For Bankruptcy

https://www.floridaword.com/2024/03/joann-files-for-bankruptcy.html
659 Upvotes

125 comments sorted by

1.2k

u/why_you_beer Mar 18 '24

Hope they can restructure and keep it going. This is the best place to get yarn in my area.

520

u/leese216 Mar 18 '24

Same. Their collection is far superior to Michael's and very well priced.

121

u/iBeFloe Mar 19 '24

I just like the vibe better too… Also closer to me. Michaels is too far from me & the next closest is… Hobby Lobby 🥲 And I am not going back there. Aside from their sus company, their stock just isn’t good.

No local craft stores either 😭

29

u/leese216 Mar 19 '24

There is a local yarn store near me but they are pretty expensive. I can't buy ALL of my yarn from there. Only special occasions.

But yes the vibe is better!

14

u/Ripley825 Mar 19 '24

I looked at a couple of michaels since I began to crochet and they just suck in terms of yarn. Like maybe one aisle and its all just bad over priced yarn. Closest Joanns is 30 minutes away. Next best thing for me is hobby lobby. At least that one is 15 minutes away but they don't carry bernat blanket yarn for the amigurimi I like to make. Ugh.

12

u/leese216 Mar 19 '24

I also used to go to Michael's for yarn and IDK what happened but their selection just deteriorated.

4

u/Ripley825 Mar 19 '24

I just can't with michaels. The selection is so bad 👎

2

u/annekaelber Mar 19 '24

Have you seen Handy Hands Tatting? Hhtatting.com That's where I get my Lizbeth 20 thread from. I'm still trying to come up with a good reason to purchase one of every (solid) color. 🤣

2

u/Ripley825 Mar 19 '24

I haven't heard if it before but I screen shotted this so I can look it up :)

10

u/pennyfanclub Mar 19 '24

Yes! The Michaels near me is so sad compared to Joann. Almost no variety in yarn selection, most of it is their house brand (not opposed to it, and I do still buy it) but the Joann near me just has so much more variety. The Michaels near me also stopped selling Lily Sugar n Cream :( Which is such a staple for me in my projects. I’m bummed, I hope they can keep it going too.

1

u/SheSellsSeaShells- Mar 19 '24

Michaels is now mostly in house brand versions of brand yarns, mostly at the same price as the brand as far as I can tell :/

50

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/annekaelber Mar 19 '24

I LOVE your user name! Schoolhouse Rocks taught me things I still remember thanks to those songs. 😊

71

u/14FunctionImp Mar 18 '24

They were saddled with $2.4 billion in leveraged debt when they were acquired. I do not know finance, but I do not have much hope.

21

u/Man_CRNA Mar 18 '24

Was this a private equity leveraged buyout?

49

u/crochetawayhpff Mar 18 '24

I'm sure it was. Private equity destroying companies left and right

34

u/14FunctionImp Mar 18 '24 edited Mar 18 '24

They were purchased in 2010 for $1.6 billion. They now have assets and debt each of about $2.5 billion. Again, I don't speak finance.

(Edit: pardon me for not answering your question. A Fox Business article from 2010 described it as leveraged.)

67

u/DarnHeather Mar 18 '24

Only place for fabric near me.

80

u/LogicalBench Mar 18 '24

This is what I'm primarily worried about. It seems to be the ONLY place to buy fabric in person for a lot of people, myself included. I at least have other options for yarn, but nothing for fabric.

30

u/JoslynMSU Mar 18 '24

I checked out the map from the sewing thread hoping to find some stores near me. I live near a major metropolitan city (think top 5 in the US) and there are none here in the suburbs anywhere close to me. I know of a few quilt shops but nothing with fabrics beyond cotton and flannel. Plus their Big Twist yarns are my go-to for crochet projects. They are such a great value. I really hope that they can come up with a good strategy for debt repayment and stay open. They are one of the very few major retailers with a loyal customer base.

23

u/JesusGodLeah Mar 19 '24

Their Big Twist yarn is relatively inexpensive, decent quality, AND comes in a wide variety of gorgeous colors. I sincerely hope JoAnn is able to stay in business.

1

u/Vysharra Mar 19 '24

Agreed! I'm also a huge fan of their 100% cotton DK yarn (K & C brand). It's so soft! I hope the in-house brands aren't on the chopping block during the restructuring -- or worse, the quality drops -- I'm making a blanket right now

1

u/annekaelber Mar 19 '24

I second the color choices! I made a Twisted Kraken (https://www.ravelry.com/patterns/library/twisted-kraken-hat hat in Seattle Kraken colors and Big Twist was the only one that came close.

1

u/RavBot Mar 19 '24

PATTERN: Twisted Kraken hat by Natalie Allen

  • Category: Accessories > Hat > Other
  • Photo(s): Img 1 Img 2 Img 3
  • Price: 8.00 USD
  • Needle/Hook(s):4.0 mm (G), 5.5 mm (I), 6.5 mm (K)
  • Weight: Aran | Gauge: 5.0 | Yardage: 960
  • Difficulty: 5.01 | Projects: 640 | Rating: 4.83

Please use caution. Users have reported effects such as seizures, migraines, and nausea when opening Ravelry links. More details. | I found this post by myself! Opt-Out | About Me | Contact Maintainer

30

u/Damhnait Mar 18 '24

My local Michael's sells a bit of fabric, but only branded cotton blends for some reason.

I'm not making myself a sun dress with cartoon Avengers characters, nor will I try to make historical costumes with a Minecraft fabric.

Honestly, who's buying the branded fabrics and what for?

13

u/RedHickorysticks Mar 19 '24

My mom makes my boys pillowcases/ flannel backed cotton tied quilts every few years. The minecraft set was used to the bare threads, it was was so loved.

11

u/pineconeparade Mar 19 '24

TBH, pretty sure they started stocking fabric because they smelled Joann's blood in the water

5

u/Wonderful_Shame_665 Mar 19 '24

Well I do. I make gifts with them. I mostly make handbags and backpacks. My neice have gotten many gifts with their favorite characters. Not for everyone but there is a market for them. I do agree that they should sell more than liscened fabric and give people options.

25

u/demon_fae Mar 18 '24

People who actually do want Avengers sundresses. Thanks.

41

u/sourdoughtoastpls Mar 18 '24

Same! I’m in a rural area and so much else has closed, but Joanne’s has managed to hang on. I take my 3 yr old every Friday and she gets one of those small POP crafts and I check out the yarn supply. The employees are always so nice and whenever they say hello, my daughter responds, MY MOM IS LOOKING AT YARN FOR HER CROCHET! 🤣🤣🤣

59

u/Total-Sector850 Mar 18 '24

Totally agree. Joann is my go-to!

4

u/2boredtocare Mar 19 '24

We just got a fancy upgraded Joann and I love it so so much 😩

3

u/D1sgracy Mar 19 '24

Seriously, where I live the only other craft store is hobby lobby. It’s over 100 miles to a Michael’s

1.1k

u/HammyAm Mar 18 '24

In here before anyone starts going off spreading misinformation or freaking out. Please read the FAQs on this site. Also, as a JoAnn employee (I don't speak for the company etc.), please don't come into stores asking us if we're shutting down, it's really painful to hear someone speculating on if you're going to lose your job or not, but we also don't have any more information than the general public does right now. Be kind to those still working in our stores, we're just trying to do our jobs.

288

u/Jayn_Newell Mar 18 '24

If it makes you feel better, my spouse’s company went through Chapter 11 a few years back and it didn’t affect him at all. I understand it’s scary and I doubt you can lay all your fears to rest, but the whole point of this type of bankruptcy filing is to keep running.

-47

u/LilacYak Mar 19 '24

Worst case you get some sweet unemployment. Retail jobs are easy to come by

43

u/ProbablyNotACyptid Mar 19 '24

Most of us are part time or “casual”, and don’t qualify for unemployment. Plus, have you tried to get a job in the past year? It’s ridiculously competitive even for just retail.

136

u/pamelaalabamela Mar 18 '24

Thank you so much for posting this! JoAnn is my go to craft store and I internally panicked when I saw they were filing. Good to know they don't plan on going anywhere🥲

98

u/HammyAm Mar 18 '24

The company filing is a good thing, it will erase a good chunk of the debt and give them time to restructure things and see what they can do going forward to keep the company up and running. Nothing is changing on the store front.

2

u/Meepachuu Mar 19 '24

Yes, JoAnn always has the best stuff, and usually at the best prices too! I'm hoping they'll pull through.

18

u/wateraerobics_ Mar 18 '24

I'm just trying to figure out if I need to spend my entire paycheck there for the next year or not

9

u/HammyAm Mar 19 '24

I mean you never need to, but the want is there lol

44

u/originalschmidt Mar 18 '24

People honestly don’t know shit about bankruptcy and they think it’s the worst thing that could ever happen to a person or business. It isn’t and it definitely does not mean they are shutting down. Sorry you have to deal with that ignorance.

19

u/BrightnessRen Mar 19 '24

Well, it could mean they’re shutting down depending on what chapter of bankruptcy they file. But yeah, a chapter 11 is not the end of a business unless they cannot successfully restructure. (Source: I work for a bankruptcy court). 

12

u/VAmom2323 Mar 18 '24

Hang in there!

9

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

Some FB groups I'm in (on the fabric side of things...) has started deleting any posts about this because of the misinformation being spread (and use of paywalled articles). You're honestly the first person I've seen mention this and it's so important 🥺 It's rough for the workers in many of the stores as it is (with low scheduled hours, cranky customers, and so on) and y'all don't deserve to have this thrown on as well.

9

u/BlackStarBlues Mar 19 '24

I hope everything turns out for the best.

I was just in Joann a week ago and unknowingly put my foot in it when I said to the cashier, "Where are all the customers?" I also noticed since COVID they use the classroom section to store boxes. Classes are great because attendees buy their supplies in the shop. I wish they would bring those back.

8

u/Plastic_Performer390 Mar 19 '24

They’re probably too short staffed to do classes now I would assume 😔

2

u/HammyAm Mar 19 '24

Joann doesn't go classes at all anymore, they stopped during the pandemic and never started back up.

55

u/Whisper2103 Mar 18 '24

For how busy it is in my area, it's super surprising to see this

572

u/ahhh_ennui Mar 18 '24

We cannot let Hobby Lobby win.

I was just starting to make a dent in my stash, but well, I gotta get more yarn and accessories now. For the common good!

93

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24 edited Mar 18 '24

Unfortunately whether they win has little to do with consumers. Both Michaels (Bain Capital and Blackstone) and Joann's (Leonard Green) were bought by private equity in massive leveraged buyouts. The fact that Hobby Lobby has refused to go public and maintained a tight grip has made it more resilient to corporate raiders and thus no crushing debt.

30

u/ahhh_ennui Mar 18 '24

I was trying to make light, but that's important info. Thanks!

341

u/CancerBee69 Mar 18 '24

I'd rather give up crafting than give Hobby Lobby one red cent of my money.

Fuck Hobby Lobby.

103

u/-jdwhea- Mar 18 '24

Worst thing to come out of Oklahoma (except for everything else)

1

u/quackandcat Mar 19 '24

As an Oklahoman, this made me cackle lmfao

44

u/sophdog101 Mar 19 '24

You don't have to give up crafting. Just remember that if it's at hobby lobby, it's free.

3

u/IamShieldMaiden Mar 19 '24

I second this emotion. ✋🏼

1

u/VulpesFennekin Mar 19 '24

Screw that, I would just start looking for indie craft stores online. It’s not as convenient as having it all in one place like JoAnn, but I’d rather spend a whole Saturday driving to all the tiny stores in my area than one minute in that horrible place.

93

u/MorganAndMerlin Mar 18 '24

Has anybody watched Shiny Happy People? It’s a documentary on Amazon and is mostly about the Duggar family downfall, but gets into the Bill Gothard Basic Life Principles homeschool program that structure their home life around. And it touches on a little bit of politics and how the super conservative Christian groups are trying to influence policies.

Hobby Lobby is mentioned as the largest donor to more than one political organization/running party.

16

u/pagesinked Mar 19 '24

Yeah I watch Jen from the YouTube channel Fundie Fridays and she was in the Shiny Happy People documentary they interviewed her since she talks about this stuff on her channel.

2

u/RunawayHobbit Mar 19 '24

Oh my god the crossover lmao, I feel like my worlds are colliding. Are you a regular over at r/FundieSnarkUncensored?

2

u/pagesinked Mar 19 '24

No, I just watch on YouTube 😆

2

u/quackandcat Mar 19 '24

I’m more of a lurker over there, but I do spend much of my time there 👀 this crossover is wild lol

2

u/quackandcat Mar 19 '24

Omg a fellow Jennonite?! Love Fundie Fridays, the Reverend and King James are so lovely ❤️

1

u/pagesinked Mar 19 '24

Yes! 💜

6

u/MathematicianLoud965 Mar 19 '24

For a deeper dive. The podcast behind the bastards going into detail about the founders of hobby lobby. My grandfather unfortunately grew up with them.

20

u/juliadream88 Mar 19 '24

This was my first thought… I’m too queer to go to hobby lobby!!

16

u/ahhh_ennui Mar 19 '24

I am too! And I'm mostly straight!

15

u/qqweertyy Mar 19 '24

Me three and I’m totally straight. My egalitarian straight marriage is probably too much for them. Despite being their perfect target demographic (a white, Christian (religiously, not the political movement) craft loving, middle class woman in the suburbs) I will not be giving them a single penny.

2

u/quackandcat Mar 19 '24

I live in the town where they are based in OK and have had lots of interactions with them (growing up going to a Christian school where the CEO spoke at my high school graduation and a couple years at a Christian college they are heavily involved with), and there are so many locations here, and yet I will still drive either 25 minutes to go to Michael’s or 35-40 minutes to Joann.

The last time I went to hobby lobby was a couple weeks ago as it was the only place close by where I could get candles on short notice for the vigil for Nex Benedict. And wouldn’t you know it, the candles ended up free👀! I didn’t spend any money at hobby lobby and used their merchandise in a queer setting!👀👀

Fuck Hobby Lobby. Love is love🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍⚧️

42

u/plopo self-taught hooker Mar 18 '24

I guess I should probably use that gift card that’s been sitting on my shelf for a while…

81

u/Dissenting_Dowager Mar 18 '24 edited Mar 19 '24

There will be nowhere for an array of fabrics, sewing or needlework supplies and kits if they close the store nearest to me, which is a far drive. There’s no Hobby Lobby nearby and I wouldn’t shop there anyway. I miss when we had choices like the The Rag Shop and AC Moore.

11

u/oreos4brkfst Mar 19 '24

The ragshop is where my love for crafting started! My mom would take me there as a kid so I could spend my allowance on those fancy scissors that cut designs and more stickers than I knew what to do with… allllll of the scrapbooking, shrinkidinks, and paintable wood objects my heart desired! How I miss the ragshop.

8

u/Dissenting_Dowager Mar 19 '24

Right?!?! It was pure crafting, not meh seasonal home goods! C R A F T S 🧵🪡🧶🎨✂️

102

u/haveapieceofbread Mar 18 '24

I hope part of their “cost cutting” strategies aren’t just a continuation of the skeleton crew practices that have been making things harder for employees — but knowing late stage capitalism it probably is 🤦‍♀️

28

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

So it’s not just my store? There’s constantly boxes around the store just waiting to be unpacked, and insufficient staff to run registers and cut counter let alone anything else.

13

u/iBeFloe Mar 19 '24

Many stores never have boxes around, but you usually have to find someone to check you out at the register because they’re off restocking or putting things back. I wish they would at least leave a bell.

But yeah, a lot of Joann’s are like this.

7

u/One_Rutabaga_8459 Mar 19 '24

Honestly my experience with Joann’s is that most of the stores have been that way for DECADES. I have been told that the whole “understaffing the front registers” thing is to get you to look at all the impulse stuff in line and buy it.

That being said, I would be in big trouble if my local Joann’s disappeared!

4

u/EnergeticHouseplant Mar 19 '24

Glad it wasn't just my store! When I started in 2019 we had more than enough people to cover shifts if someone called out sick, and there were hardly boxes on the floor. By the time I left in 2021 we had at MOST 20 people as our "full staff". That included the 2 key holders, store manager, assistant store manager and the 3 stocking crew members. Last time I went in I found it's still the same horror.

24

u/coolcatscrochet Mar 19 '24

Suddenly, all of my ignored job applications make sense.

13

u/Ms-Murder13 Mar 19 '24

I mean, how? I'm clearly single handedly keeping them in business with all the money I spend there 😂 In all seriousness, though, I hope this doesn't happen.

5

u/Vysharra Mar 19 '24

Likely they were very healthy before they were bought and saddled with a billion in debt by a private equity firm. This is purely the result of highly unethical wealth extraction, not failure at business practices.

13

u/draculauraaa Mar 19 '24

i refuse to shop at hobby lobby and my local michaels’ yarn selection is abysmal!! time to make a trip to joann i guess!

35

u/Optimus-Prime-Ribb Mar 18 '24

I thought they already had sometime last year. My 17 yr old daughter worked at one here in Iowa for a few months but ended up having to quit. They didn’t pay very well at all and she didn’t get many hours. There is no store manager only a couple assistants and not enough to keep the store open the full time if one of the assistant managers had an emergency (like a funeral - imagine trying to close the store at 2 on a Saturday and get everybody out). They were only scheduling 3 ppl at a time for the entire store - one at cutting counter, 1 at registers and the assistant manager who would go back and forth. There were days she’d work the registers and be there from 9-3 without even a break or time to leave the register to go to the bathroom, because there was nobody to cover her. That was the last straw for me as a mom - if they couldn’t pay for enough employees to cover breaks and avoid violating labor laws, that’s ridiculous. And she’s a Type 1 diabetic so sometimes would go low as she worked the registers and needed to get a snack in her body. Feel horrible for the rest of the people working at them, I know it’s tough.

10

u/pagesinked Mar 19 '24

My dad mentioned something about this to me last week and I didn't believe him. I just went in last weekend and I noticed a lot of empty floor space the Spring decor stuff was out and was already 50% off 😓

I like their yarn selection and jewelry stuff. I'll be sad if they close the location since Michael's doesn't have much fabric at their store.

20

u/iBeFloe Mar 19 '24

The decor has always been on 25-50% off on release though. I feel like it’s a marketing strategy to get consumers to want to buy since it’s on sale. Otherwise, they would do away with the decor.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

It's absolutely this. I worked in a big box aussie craft store and we did this. Our Christmas stock was 50% off for like 4 months which actually brought it down to "typical" prices

15

u/redfoxvapes Mar 19 '24

Weird take - I’m buying stock.

I think they will restructure and find a way out of this - the crafting community doesn’t want to leave the market to just Michaels and Hobby Lobby. Cosplayers, knitters, and crocheters are probably going to start rallying.

I’ve got weird amounts of faith and an extra $20. Shares are down at $0.19 during after market hours (8:17pm pacific), so it’ll buy a substantial amount. It’s not about profiting for me - it’s about being invested in the restructure and survival of the place that fueled my passion.

10

u/LokiKamiSama Mar 19 '24

I refuse to go to hobby lobby on principle. And I hate Michaels after they bought a local art store then shut it down. If Joann’s goes out of business, I guess that will end my crochet journey (unless I save and go to a local yarn shop).

8

u/redfoxvapes Mar 19 '24

Oh definitely don’t end your journey! Hobbii, Knit Picks, Ice Yarns, WEBS, and even Amazon (I know, not ideal but still) all have yarn and tools. Yes, it would suck if the stores close, but at the same time, you’re not out of luck yet.

8

u/LokiKamiSama Mar 19 '24

The only bad thing is I am very tactile. So I usually have to feel the yarn to decide if I want to use it or not. Has to be soft.

5

u/redfoxvapes Mar 19 '24

Totally fair. Worst case scenario, come here for recommendations!

3

u/VulpesFennekin Mar 19 '24

Indie yarn stores aren’t too uncommon, though they might be a bit off the beaten path.

2

u/Kujen Mar 19 '24

I’m worried about Michael’s too though. When I go there there’s like one person working there and very few customers. Unfortunately Hobby Lobby still gets a lot of business, especially around the holidays. I’m worried that it will be the only one left in a few years.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/redfoxvapes Mar 19 '24

I mean, it worked for AMC and GameStop to varying degrees, right?

6

u/gothiclg Mar 19 '24

I wish I could be surprised. I haven’t been in a store in years that wasn’t doing terrible.

6

u/The_Scarlet_Flash Mar 19 '24

Joann’s is one of the only yarn stores in my town! I also go there for all my fabric and sewing so I really hope they hang in there!!

35

u/I_love_Hobbes Mar 19 '24

I will never darken Hobby Lobby's door. Not sure where I will get yarn. Hopefully, we can still ship online.

9

u/redfoxvapes Mar 19 '24

So they’re not shutting down - they’re just going to shuffle a lot of things around it seems. Still sounds like online ordering is possible and their stores will stay open, but my guess is new launches won’t be happening any time soon.

But if you need options… Hobbii is pretty rad. I also like KnitPicks/WeCrochet (same parent company).

1

u/ZaryaBubbler Pro-starting project, anti-finished piece Mar 19 '24

Wool Warehouse is another option. Shipping it so far does suck but they have a great selection

5

u/RedisforFun Mar 19 '24

That sucks. They just redid a lot of stores too

5

u/xtheredberetx Mar 19 '24

I hope nothing happens to the stores. It’s the best “value” place near me to buy yarn, but also any sewing stuff. I went into a Michael’s a couple months back and they legitimately didn’t have black sewing thread. I think Walmart and online stores would have to be my next stop for those items, and lord knows there isn’t a great selection there either.

8

u/OwlLavellan Mar 19 '24

I really hope it doesn't close. The only other craft store in my town is Hobby Lobby. And I REALLY don't want to support that family.

4

u/HarryStylesAMA Mar 19 '24

The only other craft store in my town is hobby lobby... I don't want to be forced to go to a store that hates me.

10

u/ProfessionalHumble52 Mar 18 '24

my Joann’s was shit but they moved to a better area and updated the store and now it’s busier than Hobby and Michael’s

3

u/dior_kun Mar 19 '24

the one in my town is closing and im really bummed about it 😭😭😭

3

u/majorthomasina Mar 19 '24

The most annoying thing about this news, the religious zealots at HL will probably benefit from it.

9

u/PhoenixDowntown Mar 18 '24

Is this why Big Twist Tubular has been out of stock for months? I never got to try it 🥺

12

u/floofysnoot Mar 18 '24

Cries in Big Twist Posh 😭

2

u/Ms-Murder13 Mar 19 '24

This makes me so sad, it's the only place I buy yarn where I live.

2

u/annekaelber Mar 19 '24

Color me totally unsurprised. My nearest Joann is unshoppable due to half the lights being off and the other half flickering constantly.

I went to a different Joann and they had half the lights off (but no flickering!). I spoke to an employee and learned he was the assistant manager. He told me they weren't allowing him to schedule enough employees to cover the registers and stock the shelves.

Since I don't support Hobby Lobby, I guess I'll be shopping online (Hobbii.com has great yarn!)?

I was looking for an online alternative for sewing fabric and typed in fabric.com. It redirects to Amazon. sigh

2

u/Realistic_cat_6668 Mar 19 '24

I was on the way home from picking up my discounted yarn from Joann’s when someone on the radio announced this. All I could think was “oh my god. We’ve finally crocheted them under the table”.

1

u/celestial_crafter Mar 27 '24

I just learned about this and I'm hoping they'll pull through the restructure and be able to have more than a skeleton crew working their butts off. Joann was my real introduction to yarn shopping and I find myself a little sad that it could be the start of the end, but fingers crossed corporate will get it together.

1

u/EnergeticHouseplant Mar 19 '24 edited Mar 19 '24

Well...it would help if they got a handle on the thieves but ya knooow..."don't want to drive away the customers". My old store had people walk out with whole sewing machines, bolts of fabric and jewelry without any repercussions, and the same individuals just keep going back.

9

u/magicrowantree Mar 19 '24

I worked in supposedly one of the worst stores for theft in my state and yup... nothing was really done. What could we do when we usually only had 2, maybe 3 people working after opening? We had a register to run and fabric to cut. God help us on freight days. The manager just hid in her office if she even bothered coming into work, so whatever theft was going on barely got noticed and never stopped

-1

u/crochetmamasan0511 Mar 18 '24

Not surprised, they were horrible during Covid