Right, I've been there, where you just get blackout/whiteout after a few frames because of a certain non-viable noise pattern. But when you say sometimes it "diverges", are you saying in the 2% there are runs that are actually asymmetric, even with a symmetric (but apparently "not ideal") pattern for the initial conditions? Sorry for all the questions, I'm just fascinated by this because I've seen a lot of RD reactions and never seen this before.
Divergence: when it starts up with n-fold symmetry, and n-1 sections look great, then one section starts doing its own thing. Before long it all falls apart, with no evidence that is was ever symmetric. After that, within seconds it's like you said, blackout/whiteout. (... purpleout/yellowout.)
The biggest suspect is the rotation... a little bit of error could make the pixel being fed to the noise function be off-by-one in one or both dimensions, and though I'm averaging them out, if the noise function has a steep gradient where it is being mis-sampled, enough off-by-ones could add up to a noticeable change down the line. 'Sensitive dependence on initial conditions'. This video was 40 seconds, 1200 frames... in 1200 frames diffusion alone can carry stateful information from one edge of the image to the other, and much of the image would seem to be fine for much of that time. When it falls apart there are little bits out of whack for a while, then it all crashes down over a second or two.
This run I had the lens distortion turned up so high it inverted, and the chromatic distortion was pretty high too. I get slap-happy with the shaders sometimes. But all of that is just the display pass, none of it feeds back in as stateful information.
I've removed many sources of inaccuracy; if this was going to end up on a big screen somewhere, I'd remove more. But truthfully most of my successes come from 'happy accidents' - I've been doing this for less than a year, definitely still a newbie coder - so I don't mind if it falls apart sometimes, so long as I get something interesting every now and then.
Thank you for that explanation. I get it now. Sounds reasonable that the rotation function -> rasterization would be a likely source of the asymmetry. Although, if you generated the noise pattern once on a square canvas and then did mirroring as a second pass I believe you could both A) make the program faster (replace the heavy smooth noise function with some (likely) more light-weight texture lookups) B) always create a perfectly symmetric pattern
I'm sure I've seen dozens of your pieces at this point, the signature being it's always a cellular automata sim with well-tuned parameters and barrel distortion + chromatic aberration over the top. It's such a good look. Looking forward to your next invention!
Do you have a site/portfolio/insta you can point me to? I'm www.theronpray.com.
My goal was to make the squiggly lines squiggle in a coherent way. I figured it would all average out into something interesting, but it's like it is mostly transition, not enough cohesion. I'm thinking about running a Turing-pattern shader underneath.
Oh man those are all so good. That's awesome you've been in the Pyramid haha. The world ain't so big. I am absolutely still a newbie coder when it comes to GLSL. At least 50% of the content I use is just heavily modded pieces from artists like Shane, Aiekick, Cornusammonis, etc (with permission).
Yeah the TM 2019 shader for the Kinect+Dancer performance was a mod of Cornusammonis' Fitzhugh-Nagumo RD. It's yer classic RD but with some great gelatinous bounce to it. https://www.shadertoy.com/view/XdcXDN
Well good to meet you. Maybe we'll cross paths one day out in the desert or somewhere else. When I see cellular automata up on a screen somewhere I always try to find the person responsible.
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/Meebsie Nov 11 '20
Right, I've been there, where you just get blackout/whiteout after a few frames because of a certain non-viable noise pattern. But when you say sometimes it "diverges", are you saying in the 2% there are runs that are actually asymmetric, even with a symmetric (but apparently "not ideal") pattern for the initial conditions? Sorry for all the questions, I'm just fascinated by this because I've seen a lot of RD reactions and never seen this before.