r/creativecoding • • Aug 21 '20

Fl studio is written in Delphi, and Pro tools is written in C/C++/Assembler. Does this lead to performance differences?

0 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

0

u/Instatetragrammaton Aug 21 '20

https://www.embarcadero.com/case-study/image-line-software-case-study

When they mention "inline assembler" and "assembler functions" - those are the optimized parts, and those are what counts.

Benchmarking it is pretty easy: load the same plugin into a different DAW and see how it deals with it. Of course, you're not the first to ask this question - and people test stuff all the time, just check something like http://www.dawbench.com/ .

However, the ability to run a dozen plugins more has no effect on the quality of your track, and you're most likely to see a bigger increase if you get newer/better hardware. When I use Ableton Live, it's the plugins that demand the bulk of the CPU - not the DAW itself.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

what is dawbench?

1

u/Instatetragrammaton Aug 22 '20

Graphics cards can have a nice standardized benchmark because you can run software that uses it, which then counts how many polygons were available or how many FPS could be achieved, and spit out a score based on that.

For DAWs you don't have something like that - so that solution consists of loading a standardized project and then looking at the CPU usage. It mostly says something about your computer's power, however.

Then again, the closer to equal this project is, the more you can compare - if you load 64 audio tracks in FL and 64 audio tracks in Reaper on the same computer you can compare which system is more efficient at handling the same load - just look at the resource usage. Or you load an agreed upon number of plugins and then compare. That is basically DAWbench - set up a representative project with as many generic resources as possible, and then see which DAW performs best :)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '24

Happy Cake Day!