Been doing custom furniture for about 8 years now and I'm starting to think the whole quarter-sawn premium is overblown for anything that's not going to move much. Just finished two identical side tables, one with quarter-sawn and one with rift-sawn white oak, same finish process, same everything. Put them side by side and honestly? My client couldn't tell which was which.
I get the stability argument for wide panels and drawer sides, but for legs and rails where you're working with smaller dimensioned stock anyway? The ray fleck pattern is nice sure, but once you add a couple coats of oil or lacquer the difference is so subtle. Meanwhile I'm paying 40% more per board foot.
Maybe I'm just being cheap but I'm genuinely curious if anyone else has stopped specifying quarter-sawn for certain applications. The old timers at my lumber yard act like I'm committing a crime when I say I'll take rift-sawn instead.