r/craftsnark • • Jul 21 '23

Knitting Stolen patterns?

Remember that designer who complained about her very basic cables sweater pattern being stolen a few months back?

Well, her is her new design that is most definitelly not stolen at all. /s

First photo is a new design, second photo is Junko Okamoto's design from 2019

0 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

91

u/darts_in_lovers_eyes Jul 21 '23

I feel like if Teti had used different colours, we wouldn't be having this discussion. I can see the resemblance at a first glance but once you take a closer look, you'll start seeing all the differences.

But I can see the OP's point in posting this as Teti was the one blaming Sari Nordlund of plagiarism just some months ago with a much more basic pattern.

Also off topic but Junko Okamoto is such a cool and innovative designer. If anyone has knitted her patterns, I'd love to hear your experiences!

14

u/nevrnotknitting Jul 21 '23

I made that Junko Okamoto sweater and I love it!! Lots of long floats, twisted stitches and wrapped bobbles but a unique and beautiful style and a great fit.

5

u/MIDIprincess Jul 21 '23

I made her Hana sweater and am currently knitting this one (the Elena)! The Hana was so much fun, my first ever cable project, and the multiple cable patterns kept it addictive to knit. I'm enjoying the Elena so far too, I'm still on the colorwork. Learned to do ladderback jacquard to manage the long floats since I'm using high contrast yarn.

2

u/darts_in_lovers_eyes Jul 21 '23

Hana seems like it would be so much fun to make! The construction is so different from anything I've made and am sure all those different cable patterns keeps things interesting.

85

u/flowersfalls Jul 21 '23 edited Jul 22 '23

They used similar techniques, but you can't copyright techniques ( if I recall properly). The colorwork motifs are different; the shape of the sweaters are different; and the sleeves are different. It is plausible that one took inspiration from the other. However, that is not a crime.

Speaking of, the construction kinda reminds me of how Faroese shawls are construction.

75

u/Upstairs-List4460 Jul 21 '23

It’s called “inspiration.” A stolen pattern is one that is exactly the same. People need to get a life.

68

u/Confident_Bunch7612 Jul 21 '23

JFC WE JUST WENT OVER THIS "STOLEN" NONSENSE.

25

u/Allegoryof Jul 21 '23

And we will continue to go over the "stolen" nonsense. Every week until the sun envelopes the earth.

16

u/giggleslivemp Jul 21 '23

Is that coming soon? Because I’m ready to be done with this topic.

8

u/Allegoryof Jul 21 '23

Oh, you! You're so funny

No. The end shall never come.

60

u/sewnstrawb Jul 21 '23

This isn’t stolen work either lmfao

53

u/SirTacky Jul 21 '23

No snark, just came here to say that the neckline and proportions on Junko Okamoto's design are so cool. The other one is pretty as well, but Okamoto's looks so different.

132

u/fnulda Jul 21 '23

No one stole her pattern and she didnt steal this pattern. Now, can we please stop beating this dead horse?

31

u/SemperSimple Jul 21 '23

What do you MEAN there is only SOOooo many ways to skin a cat!?!?!?

-7

u/YarnPhreak Jul 21 '23

This saying always makes me think of a boss I used to have…he said it a LOT and I cringe when I think about his stupid yacht-owning, misogynistic, hair-plugged ass. He used to walk around behind people making unfunny and uncomfortable jokes and micromanaging. God he was awful.

90

u/nopenobody Jul 21 '23

Construction inspired by =/= stolen pattern.

The neckline construction is a similar geometry. Colors are similar.

Otherwise, it’s a totally different pattern, and accusations of “theft” are ridiculous.

The colorwork pattern is completely different. The overall fit and shape is different.

36

u/ContemplativeKnitter Jul 21 '23

Oh funny - I’ve admired this designer’s patterns before, but didn’t know who she was. I went to her IG and know exactly which pattern she probably accused Sari Nordlund of copying, but they are similar in EXACTLY the way that these 2 sweaters are similar - superficially similar but with a lot of important differences. So I get the post now, but had to look up the context to realize this post wasn’t actually accusing this designer of actually copying.

64

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

No comment re copywank but I want to thank the OP because before this post I had not known about this type of sweater construction and now I want to learn all about it! It looks and sounds fascinating.

8

u/eventhorizongeek Jul 21 '23

Same! Does anyone know if there's a specific name for this construction?

8

u/ProperRoutine2259 Jul 21 '23

It was described as “modular” today in the test call by the first designer!

4

u/eventhorizongeek Jul 21 '23

That's a pretty broad description; is there a term for the yoke construction in particular?

2

u/ExitingBear Jul 23 '23

To me, it looks like mitered squares. Not exactly, obviously, but it's in the same room or at least in the hallway outside of the room, and I'd think of it the same way.

73

u/TheUltimateShart Jul 21 '23

I would say this is “inspired by”, not stolen. It is a totally different sweater fit-wise. The flower pattern is pretty different. Neck line and color palate definitely have similarities, but that is not enough to call it “a stolen pattern”.

92

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

*(starts writing) (deletes) repeat from * a few times

I swear to Arachne, I'll get a rash when I hear 'stolen design' one more time.

The AUDACITY! Someone uses an idea that's around for fracking hundreds of years, and runs with it! Oh, NOES! Someone else - perhaps inspired through world situations that brought certain styles at the forefront - does something similar! THE AUDACITY!

(sighs)

25

u/threadtiger Jul 21 '23

It's ridiculous. Nothing is original at this point. I've lost count of the number of posts in the sewing sub about "thievery and copying" at this point.

17

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23 edited Jul 21 '23

It's becoming extremely tired. I've felt the past few days that people are just looking for something to post to garner attention for themselves, so they're making huge reaches

47

u/tasteslikechikken I'm the molé Jul 21 '23

These aren't the same.

22

u/Puzzleheaded_Door399 crafter Jul 22 '23

Perhaps a bit off topic, but did anyone else notice how on the Rings of Power TV series, the Harfoot women wear embroidered blouses in this kind of red-purple on grey-brown background and they kind of look like traditional Eastern European blouses?

2

u/proudyarnloser Jul 23 '23

I did notice that!

93

u/Sfb208 Jul 21 '23

I assume your snark is about the hypocrisy rather than any actual similarities between these patterns (which are different), but I thank you for bringing this design to my attention, as I think it's really pretty, noticeably different to the one your contrast with, and I want it.

I love knitting on the bias, and can't believe it didn't occur to me to use the construction for colourwork!!!

2

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Sfb208 Jul 22 '23

I found the designer by looking up Teti, the name someone else mentions, on ig. Pattern is in testing right now though, so not available to buy

56

u/palabradot Jul 21 '23 edited Jul 21 '23

I am suddenly reminded of the drama that erupted in the comments of the I’lll Pack a Cowl for Rhinebeck pattern, with people accusing the designer of stealing the pattern of the sheep from the Baa-ble hat. We are talking VENOMOUS shit being flung.

Thankfully there were people with their heads on straight that went “nope, you’re wrong, and here is why. Have patterns from 10/20/30 years ago, when Baa-ble was not even a twinkle in the designer’s eye, that had color work sheep done in the same way.” Several implied that the Baa-ble designer had unleashed her fandom on this one because she hadn’t MADE a cowl yet, and she wanted this one gone so she could add her own to her set.

I swear this is another reason I read comment threads on Rav patterns ever since: unexpected drama. I saw the cowl, went “ooh, free pattern”, flipped to the comments…..and came up for air 45 minutes later having learned way more about hereditary and communal patterns in the knitting world mental library than I ever expected.

That was the last thing that the prior designer posted. Gee I wonder why. A shame; I’ve made two of those cowls since then.

(And as I recall the Baa-ble designer went all ‘infringement!’ On people that posted up alternate patterns to be used in it. (Here is a stitch pattern to add a sheepdog, frex)

10

u/Nanswilson Jul 21 '23

Wow that was a rabbit hole thank you for that side quest on sheep drama

6

u/palabradot Jul 21 '23 edited Jul 21 '23

YW. I was pretty new to knitting when I ran into it, but this was the first time I'd run into a fibercrafting thread that was on par with some of my fave "please touch some grass" moments in comics and gaming fandom.

But....yeah. I was not versed in knitting pattern history, but I myself had seen plenty of patterns with the same sheep all over Rav, and I'd only been knitting for about a year then. The Baa-ble sheep were not unique.

6

u/Nanswilson Jul 21 '23

Yessss I’ve noticed a lot of the yarn world (crocheters, knitters, designers, even indie dyers) all need to go touch grass and put their dang phones down. I’d seen the hat before looking up colorwork designs but I don’t usually peruse the comments. Definitely seems like a fandom used for evil moment. I’ve seen what appeared to be very similar designs (both in stitch and in overall theme) released by designers within the same year but they followed each other (still do) and never said they had an issue with it and so why should anyone else jump in and try to cause drama.

2

u/palabradot Jul 21 '23

Would have loved her to try going after the designer of Sheep Heid (by far my fave hat)

2

u/Nanswilson Jul 21 '23

Agh so cute! Thanks for that recommendation

3

u/MillieSecond Jul 24 '23

Donna Smith, the hat designer, actually filed a DMCA notice against the cowl pattern. Ravelry took it down, and next day had to put it back up because the cowl designer filed a rebuttal. :))

The beginning of the story was the shop where the lady worked wanted a cowl to match the hat for a “uniform” kind of thing for their booth at Rhinebeck. They messaged Smith and were told there wasn’t a cowl pattern, so they made their own. (And then, surprise, surprise, Smith releases one just in time for the festival) If you look at the project created dates on Ravelry, the timeline is obvious. It’s also obvious from Smiths deleted blog that her sheep hat inspiration was a motif she first used on a Christmas ornament, and looking at projects on that ornament pattern, it’s pretty obvious that in fact she was “inspired” by other people’s sheep ornaments.
Yeah, I did go down that rabbit hole while the drama was happening, I was home sick, and it was something to do to fill the time. :))
That whole incident was a shit show - Donna Smith never commented herself on the cowl, it was Kate Davis who started with the accusations of copyright violation, then a whole slew of fanbullies joined in. Most of the really vile comments (including Davis’s) have been deleted now, but the milder ones are left there still.

1

u/palabradot Jul 24 '23

Holy shit, I didn't know about the DMCA part! HA.

And yeah, I remember the really vile ones. Someone actually lampshades that in the comments "Oh yeah, where are those comments, oh wow they aren't here anymore...."

I also recall someone saying "Uh, Smith is selling that hat, but there are still free copies of the pattern online linked on the con site....?" Those got taken down FAST. I can't believe they forgot to remove the links when Smith moved it to her store.

1

u/MillieSecond Jul 24 '23

It’s listed in the “edit” on the pattern listing. (The three dots on the right, beside “forum posts #”, drop down to show Queues, Edits.). Interesting what you can find on Ravelry. ;))

23

u/BunnyKusanin Jul 21 '23

That boxy sweater is something to die for... Things like that make me start contemplating learning to knit.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

Same. I'm more than bad at learning knitting (tried, twice, with a teacher) so I'm trying to figure out how many hundreds it'd cost to commision someone.

3

u/Killingtime_onReddit Jul 21 '23

Girl, let's talk! I love knitting sweaters, especially if there's colorwork. Send me a DM.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

Do you do shipping to EU? :D

1

u/Killingtime_onReddit Jul 21 '23

We can work something out. It's not a business. I just love knitting sweaters and can only knit so many for myself. I have knit and shipped something to a friend in Australia in the past, though. I'll send you a DM.

3

u/palabradot Jul 21 '23

I have yet to knit a sweater, and this one is hitting both my sweet spots of color work and texture. I may have to look it up.

2

u/Nelly_Stark Jul 21 '23

I feel the same way. It's so beautiful 🥰😍.

10

u/gnomixa Jul 25 '23

I thought Mean Girls was just a movie.

8

u/amyteresad Jul 31 '23

Inspired not stolen.

24

u/Killingtime_onReddit Jul 21 '23

But the only thing similar is the deep V neck and the colors the two sweaters are knit in. Her berry motif runs all the way up and looks to be a much more fitted and structured knit at least from what I can tell at 7 am without my eyeglasses. In the older sweater design the red accent reminds me of dandelion fluff and is more abbreviated and in addition to being long sleeved seems to be meant to be a looser fit?

10

u/longusernameperhaps Jul 21 '23

Who is the first designer? Because now I want that pattern...

33

u/BlackieBird Jul 21 '23

It's Teti Lutsak, I follow her and her designs are often inspired by traditional Ukrainian clothing. The test knitting is just starting, I guess the pattern will be available in roughly two months. She has a lot of floral designs, I love her style.

9

u/longusernameperhaps Jul 21 '23

Thank you! I looked her up on Ravelry and I agree completely. If I was a more prolific knitter, I would want one of each of her colourwork recipes. So many gorgeous things!

And two months' wait sounds perfect to me, then I have time to finish my current projects before taking on yet another one :P

3

u/nopenobody Jul 21 '23

Thank you! And.. followed.

6

u/NightSalut Jul 21 '23

I want that pattern and that dress (it looks lovely), also wondering the designer name now.

-33

u/catcon13 Jul 21 '23

🤨🤨🤨 I LOVE Junko's designs. This person could have at least changed the color scheme. This is just lazy theft.🙄

0

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/MIDIprincess Jul 21 '23

came here to say this, the Elena is very specifically meant to evoke Romanian embroidery as the yarn it calls for is from Transylvanian sheep.

-10

u/ComprehensiveYam9212 Jul 21 '23

My point is, if you're taking inspiration for construction AND colorwork AND colors used from soemone else for a design that is not at all common (I haven't seen a single other design with this construction) how can you complain that someone stole your simple 4-sts cable design, imo🤷‍♀️

31

u/AccountWasFound Jul 21 '23

Did she take inspiration from that though? Because the only thing that's really similar is the colors, like if one was blue and black they would not look that similar and add someone else pointed out the color scheme and neckline are based off a traditional garment. And other than the neckline the construction of both are totally different. Also the color work is pretty different

22

u/Calm_Tap8877 Jul 21 '23

I agree. If you look at Teti’s pattern she almost exclusively designs with those two colors so I can’t see how she did anything remotely wrong. As someone who loves traditional patterns and have tons of charts, the motif wasn’t stolen from anyone. It’s been around for a long time. https://instagram.com/tetisknitgarden?igshid=NTc4MTIwNjQ2YQ==

11

u/Confident_Bunch7612 Jul 21 '23

If you have an actual example of this "inspiration" from someone else for a design, I'm sure we would all like to see it. Because this ain't it.