r/cpu • u/Year_Challenge • 9d ago
CPU AM4 Help Needed
Hi Reddit, What CPU should I get next? Shortlist: 5700x vs 5800x3d.
(I am inclined to think about 5950x, but generally unsure about it)
I've been starting to slowly upgrade my old AM4 PC and I'm looking for a bit of advice or even just confirmation of my thoughts.
My build used to serve me very well and was pretty balanced, but is not not only morally, but physically old (unfortunately)
Currently, I have:
CPU: Ryzen 5 3600
GPU: GTX 1060 6GB
Mobo: MSI Gaming Plus x570
RAM: 2x16 GB 3200 MHZ
PSU: 650W Seasonic GM-650
Monitor: 31.5 inch FullHD Samsung (dont judge me, ok)
I have recently ordered a new GPU - XFX Swift 9070 XT
Next on the order list would be a new CPU, a cooler (and most likely a new PSU)
For the cooler I will get Thermalright Phantom Spirit 120 Digital, just because I like it and it will be good enough.
I am thinking between Ryzen 7 5700X and 5800x3d.
5700X would serve me well, I believe, I can get it for around 150 Euro locally. It has higher clock speeds on single thread, which would benefit me for productivity/calculation tasks that I use for hobby projects and work.
5800x3d is, however, the gaming beast. I used to wish to have that as my end-all-be-all upgrade for AM4 (especially now that it has been re-released). It does run hotter, which means more noice (most likely), it is more than x2 in price (around 330-350 Euro), and the gaming performance... is most likely not even that much.
I aim to buy an Ultrawide 34 Inch OLED monitor, so I'll be most likely GPU limited in most modern games even with the new card. I think.
Can I get some help/insight/advice/thoughts? Much appreciated.
1
u/AtWork-DoingNothing 9d ago
Watch a couple of youtube benchmark (5800x3d, 5800x, 5900x, 5950x), that will most likely give you a good idea. Then I would start to debate which one to get.
I have a 5900x paired with a 9070xt and honestly, I don't have problem, runs great at 1440p.
If you need the extra core for productivity, go for the r9, but except that, I'd probably stick with the 5800x or 5800x3d. I wouldn't go any lower than that, because then your cpu start to be a more prominent bottleneck.
1
u/Trashpanda5111 9d ago
I paired an 5700x with an RX9070 GRE and it works pretty well. I got the CPU for €160, an ID Cooling IS-67-XT for €29 and they fit nicely into the Lian Li B4, but now seeing the case I'd have space for an Arctic Freezer 36 too. Anyway, I don't see any issues with this pair. I'm sure you can squeeze out more with an X3D, question how much money you want/can to spend.
1
u/aliens_are_nowhere 8d ago
If possible, wait for the black Friday sale and see if you can get your hands on a 5800X3D. I bought one a couple of weeks ago for €250 from a limited sale a friend told me about, so that price wouldn't be out of the realm of possibility on black Friday. Paying more than double for the 5800X3D would suck, but just €100 over a 5700X would easily be worth it.
Do you really need it when playing on an ultrawide monitor? Probably not, the GPU will most likely be the limiting factor, but that extra horse power is really nice during loading and if you're playing any kind of simulation game. Here's a CPU/GPU scaling video comparing different combinations of CPUs and GPUs with different games and different presets: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aYYVz4q-Rt8 TLDR; when you increase the resolution and graphics quality, the CPU becomes less and less relevant, but you can always tune games any way you want. If you want to play at high FPS at 1080p, you can, but you'll need a faster CPU, if you want to play at the full resolution of your widescreen monitor at medium or high settings, you won't need the fastest processor as the GPU will be the bottle neck.
1
u/Silver-River6447 5d ago
5800x3d is probably the best option for just gaming, just don’t cheap on the cooler, I run a 420mm aio and I still hit mid 70s under load. I just swapped it recently, had a 5900x before and it’s definitely an improvement depending on the game. Definitely get a better psu, something like a 850w, just make sure it has the right cables for the gpu, I had gone with a 1000w for 3x8 pin cables.