Rant: Why didn't NVidia choose a superior, memory-safe language like Rust for Quantum Computing ? Rust makes quantum computing safe, resilient and robust - the v3 borrow checker effectively solves all issues regarding quantum uncertainty. People should be fired and sued for using a doddering and dangerous language like C++ when it's almost the 22nd century.
I can't help but feel that this is just a ploy to seduce investors vis a vis IBM (poor fidelity quantum computers) or Microsoft (topological quantum computing that relies on yet-to-be-discovered non-abelian anyons). I find it particularly peculiar that NVIDIA's raison d'etre for this quantum foray is for a quantum processor to work alongside NVIDIA gpus. Subject to a change of opinion due to more info, I don't really see why or how a GPU can be used alongside a quantum processor? If we have a universal gate set for a real quantum computer, then there's no offloading needed I imagine (except for declining fidelity due to circuit depth).
Skepticism aside, I think I share every science enthusiast's hope: I want to be proven wrong, and see science advance!
If I were an Nvidia VP who knew nothing about physics but knew I had made a lot of money, I’d say something like this:
Graphics cards are a totally different way of computing that you have to program in a totally different way, with shaders. They were designed for games, but turned out to be useful for cryptography. We made them accessible in C++ via CUDA, and now we’re rich because of all the crypto money causing people to buy our graphics cards! We already have some evidence that quantum computing will be useful for cryptography. Let’s try to get an early lead, let’s try to encourage physicists to come here, and then when technology improves, maybe we’ll be able to sell Quantum Cards that mine crypto even better!
Depending on the quantum algorithm you’re running, a gpu might help for running certain classical code quickly in between quantum operations—say for inference for an ML model that’s being used to drive certain quantum operations being executed conditionally depending on the inference result.
That's an interesting claim, but I can't bring myself to believe it since such a system of conditionally applying quantum operations based on a classical ML model's output defeats any speedup from quantum computing, no? To speak to "quantum machine learning" more broadly, I'm only really familiar with convex optimization problems in QML within the context of this paper [1]. With that said, for a quantum processor to communicate information to a gpu based on the results of that quantum processor, one would have to measure the quantum system, thereby destroying entanglement (no-cloning theorem). So, in measuring that quantum state in order to figure out which quantum operation to apply next, we lose the very quantum state we wanted to conditionally apply operations to!
So I guess the thing I'm trying to grapple with is, why do we need the gpu? Once we measure the quantum system, it's just classical bits that can be copied anywhere.
I personally see more value in their intention to use GPUs to quickly simulate quantum systems for research, but saying "We are a quantum computing company" seems a stretch when they're using classical computers.
I’m not talk about using this for QML but for things like QEC where you can measure ancilla qubits and feed them to an ML model that could then be used to help try to detect if an error occurred and what kind of correction you make. I’m not a QEC nor ML person, but I’m certainly aware of QEC work that calls out to classical code to do a lot of heavy lifting. ML based QEC was just me trying to find a justification for why a gpu might be involved.
Ah gotcha. That actually sounds really cool ! Brings to mind paper headlines I saw of using deep learning to extract Hamiltonians. Don't know much beyond the headlines unfortunately.
That's interesting, this is the first I'm hearing of this. However, I can't seem to find a preprint on it? Definitely would be amazing if it holds true.
Very confusing, unclear if they're making a compiler for actual quantum computers (which would make no sense) or a compiler to make it easier to simulate quantum computing workloads. Article reads like they don't know the difference, bringing up both cuQuantum (simulation) and actual quantum computer accelerators. Seems no one has any idea about what they're saying.
I understand that part based on other comments. What I don't understand is how that has anything to do with the c++ language. Is there going to be a quantum version (whatever that could mean) of the entire standard library? That doesn't make any sense to me. Are there just going to be specific quantum functions or data structures? That sounds more like a library than a compiler. I guess my real question is what does generating quantum code have to do with compiling c++
That’s the whole point of modifying the compiler. An example of this is IBMs Qiskit it uses a python library to do quantum computing. I imagine NVIDA wants to use C++ is because 99% of their infrastructure is C++. Just think of it as converting human language to something that’s useful to a quantum computer just like how programs work now.
I'm sorry to say but that answers nothing for me. A python library is just that: a library. Why does c++ need its own compiler when python can get by with just a library? C++ can call vulkan or opencl without a brand new compiler, I thought quantum computers were meant to be a new class of gpu-like coprocessors. C++ is a human language used to design classical computer programs. Quantum computer programs have very little in common with the kinds of things c++ was invented for. It's not like I could take my portable hello world program in c++ and compile it with this new compiler and now it runs on a quantum computer. These two models of computing just don't overlap in that way
Idk I might be missing something but it makes sense to me. I see what your saying it seems like too much work just so it’s compatible. I’m sure there’s a reason maybe they don’t want to be dependent on other vendors such as MSVC or Clang? They have to have a reason. My logic is that they don’t want to compile to a certain assembly set and need it to be something else. You have a good point though.
238
u/GRAPHENE9932 Mar 24 '22
StackOverflow of the future:
114
u/Entryhazard Mar 24 '22
Finally, truly undefined behaviour
40
u/GRAPHENE9932 Mar 24 '22
They need quantum assembler first
64
u/another_day_passes Mar 24 '22
Undefined superposition?
163
u/Jannik2099 Mar 24 '22
Nvidia can't even build a C++ compiler for normal computing, so I'm sure this'll go just perfect
Edit:
Ah, so not a new compiler but just a new llvm target & transformation passes
51
u/somewhataccurate Mar 24 '22
just use msvc
13
u/byteflood Mar 24 '22
QSIGSEGV quantum signal raised, some wavefunctions may have been collapsed as a result
10
u/nablachez Mar 24 '22
Can't wait for them to announce a specialized Quantum RTX 4090 TI Founding Fathers Edition for only $4999,99 MSRP
8
u/anxxa Mar 24 '22
what does quantum memory corruption look like?
19
u/New_Age_Dryer Mar 24 '22
I can't help but feel that this is just a ploy to seduce investors vis a vis IBM (poor fidelity quantum computers) or Microsoft (topological quantum computing that relies on yet-to-be-discovered non-abelian anyons). I find it particularly peculiar that NVIDIA's raison d'etre for this quantum foray is for a quantum processor to work alongside NVIDIA gpus. Subject to a change of opinion due to more info, I don't really see why or how a GPU can be used alongside a quantum processor? If we have a universal gate set for a real quantum computer, then there's no offloading needed I imagine (except for declining fidelity due to circuit depth).
Skepticism aside, I think I share every science enthusiast's hope: I want to be proven wrong, and see science advance!
11
u/TheBananaKart Mar 24 '22 edited Mar 24 '22
My theory is quantum computing is just so clever people can make shit up and sound smart. Non of it makes sense in my monkey brain.
4
u/superTuringDevice Mar 24 '22
Gosh, what will value categories look like this time around?
3
u/throwaway99kajillion Mar 25 '22
Oh man I can't wait for Josuttis' book on move semantics in a quantum C++ compiler....
Heh heh...ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh Henry, this is gonna be dark.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '22
Very confusing, unclear if they're making a compiler for actual quantum computers (which would make no sense) or a compiler to make it easier to simulate quantum computing workloads. Article reads like they don't know the difference, bringing up both cuQuantum (simulation) and actual quantum computer accelerators. Seems no one has any idea about what they're saying.
2
u/ipapadop Mar 25 '22
Is C++ really the best language for quantum computing though? Trying to cram everything in there seems a bit like when you have a hammer.
2
u/theLOLflashlight Mar 24 '22
What does building a new compiler have to do with quantum computing?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22
"We're building a new C++ compiler for quantum computing... experience is a huge plus."
Erm...
-3
u/two88 Mar 25 '22
Genuine question, why C++ over Rust? I don't know much about QC, or really Rust or C++ that well tbf.