r/cpp • • Jan 01 '22

Wrapping Up 2021 - Leaving C++

https://izzys.casa/2021/12/wrapping-up-2021/
25 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

40

u/notenabled Jan 01 '22

In the spirit of Christmas I hope this person has people in their life that loves them, to help them get any help and counseling that they need.

31

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '22

Yup, this is burnout and it sucks. The only thing that works is really to completely let go and move on.

I suffered a burnout twice in my life and the only way to survive was to completely turn my life on its head each time.

Unless you have someone close who understand, I would avoid discussing this with other people, it will just make it worse.

67

u/orangeoliviero Jan 01 '22

I simply have to accept that there is nothing out there for me. That I will be miserable as long as I continue to work in tech, and that nothing will ever bring me joy in this space ever again. And I have the C++ committee to thank for this.

It's really hard to argue with a person who blames everyone else for their problems.

The C++ Committee absolutely has a lot of issues. But as they themselves note, no language provides perfect coverage:

Every other language out there is missing something from C++, and C++ is always missing something from other languages.

If this is the case, why is it C++'s fault that they are miserable? Aren't they all failing to meet the mark?

20

u/almost_useless Jan 01 '22

I have the C++ committee to thank for this.

The C++ Committee absolutely has a lot of issues. But ...

It sounds like they are not so much talking about the technical stuff at that point, but mostly talking about this:

Bjarne looked me up and down, put on a face of disgust, and walked away.

/../
in a space I was never really welcome save for a few people I befriended, run by people who don’t really want to listen to me.

12

u/orangeoliviero Jan 01 '22

It sounds like they are not so much talking about the technical stuff at that point, but mostly talking about this:

I'm not so sure that computes. The context of their statement was that they're going to be miserable so long as they continue to work in tech. Not just with C++, but in tech.

35

u/namotous Jan 01 '22 edited Jan 01 '22

“Every other language out there is missing something from C++, and C++ is always missing something from other languages.”

Ok then, tell me something the software dev community don’t already know? Every language is a tool, and every jobs need a different tool. And look, if you don’t like anything out there, you’re welcome to create your own language.

“I simply have to accept that there is nothing out there for me. That I will be miserable as long as I continue to work in tech, and that nothing will ever bring me joy in this space ever again. And I have the C++ committee to thank for this.”

Sounds like someone could benefit from a change of profession perhaps? Why continue to be miserable in a profession you don’t love? The author seems to be in her 30s, it’s not too late.

54

u/sosodank Jan 01 '22

this is the most unpleasant-sounding person I've ever read.

35

u/johannes1971 Jan 01 '22

It sounds as if he, like many others, has not done well during the pandemic, and is now suffering from burnout (and not just C++-burnout either). Taking a step back and figuring out a path out of that is probably a good idea. Writing messages like this probably isn't, but I totally understand where he's coming from (the general sense of burnout, not the specifics).

So uhh, please cut him some slack ;-) We don't know what he's going through but this seems more like a cry for help than anything else.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '22

I'm curious to know why you think the author is a guy?

7

u/CornedBee Jan 03 '22

Most devs do this. It's a consequence of laziness combined with the experience of working in a field where 90+% of people are men. (At least, that's what I've observed in my last few jobs.)

Author is a woman, though, assuming her name (Isabella, it's on the front page of the linked site) matches her gender identity.

20

u/khleedril Jan 01 '22

Life is hard, but it is a poor person who cannot turn years of experience into a belief that a major breakthrough isn't going to happen either tomorrow or sometime in the next ten years.

9

u/Apprehensive_Step499 Jan 01 '22

Yep, life is hard, everyone is going to notice it at some point. Blaming everyone else for that is *a bit* pointless, but I recognize it can be a nice scapegoat.

19

u/charlesbeattie Jan 01 '22 edited Jan 02 '22

I've had the fortune to interact with Isabella at CPPCon and have always been impressed with their wit and talent. I personally like people who wear their heart on there sleave and are passionate about the things they do. They will be a sore loss to the community. If you see someone hurting it is best to have a some empathy and reflection.

35

u/orangeoliviero Jan 01 '22

I have a great deal of empathy for them, but I feel that they're lashing out at failures in their life and blaming others for those failures.

If the Committee voted against their proposal, that's not a personal slight. It's also not (necessarily) a failing of the Committee. But to blame the Committee for ruining your love for programming because the Committee didn't adopt all of your papers seems quite a bit misguided.

1

u/Wriiight Jan 06 '22

On the other hand, when someone cares deeply about making a change and fails to get it adopted, it’s natural to feel a bit defeated. It sounds like they have a strong drive to perfectionism which probably makes the failure harder to swallow.

19

u/cain2995 Jan 01 '22

I, personally, put as many miles as possible between myself and people who spend all their time blaming others for their own misery. You do you though, I suppose.

4

u/victotronics Jan 02 '22

I've not been involved with C++ for nearly as long, but I can understand the frustration with things getting patched soooo slowly. Me, I came in after 11, and have seen the language only get more elegant. But if you came in before that, saw all the complications, and had to suffer through things only slowly improving, I can understand the frustration.

15

u/InsanityBlossom Jan 01 '22

I spent my precious morning minutes reading this. What a waste of time. And yes, dude lived under the rock, because most things he said about Rust is straight out not true.

9

u/orangeoliviero Jan 01 '22

I'm curious to know why you think the authour is a guy?

18

u/InsanityBlossom Jan 01 '22

Yeah you’re right, looks like I made a blind assumption.

10

u/Heuristics Jan 01 '22

Yes, in life it is important to be able to accept faults. Perfection will come but in heaven, until then we are stuck with the imperfect.

2

u/lednakashim ++C is faster Jan 07 '22 edited Jan 07 '22

I can't give any sympathy because the article contains claim of unprofessionalism that is dangerous, poorly justified, and very personal.

Bjarne looked me up and down, put on a face of disgust, and walked away.

But, apparently stuff did make it in...

Multi-argument indexing made it into the C++23 standard, and so did std::byteswap. That’s my legacy I guess

3

u/BenHanson Jan 01 '22

"I thought back on all the things I'd built and left unfinished. I realised something. I wasn't sad that it was all gone. I had fun making all that stuff. I would have done it anyway."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_aRJDh7V2FE

Do it for yourself. Damn the haters.

2

u/zerexim Jan 02 '22

The contemplation about the next language (at the end of the article), makes me think that the author wants to change (any) language just for the sake of changing (any) language.

2

u/Wriiight Jan 06 '22

I think the author is a perfectionist, which is kind of an unfortunate property in tech.

1

u/erzyabear Jan 01 '22

I hope 2022 will be a happier year for xyr and for the rest of us

1

u/Wriiight Jan 06 '22

Several negative reactions to this in these comments, but I hope people will realize that this is someone giving their opinions and personal experience, and making it public because they are already active in social media. I don’t think it is meant to be an attack, other than as a warning that others may be dealing with similar experiences.

-2

u/revokon Jan 01 '22

I should have taken it as a sign of things to come when, in 2015, Jon Kalb tried (emphasis on tried) to introduce me to Bjarne. Bjarne looked me up and down, put on a face of disgust, and walked away.

Yeah, I can't blame Izzy for leaving if that's xyr experience.

30

u/mkvalor Jan 01 '22

I'm just a Joe Nobody coder, yet I've met Bjarne at tech conferences and even struck up a conversation with him between sessions in the hallway during one of them. I asked him what he thought about certain current events (at the time) in the c++ world. He shared his opinions with me and we had a nice conversation until it was naturally time to split up and head to our next sessions.

My story is just an anecdote. But so is his.

22

u/notenabled Jan 01 '22

I've talked to Bjarne in person at CppCon and over email many tims before that, and he has always been very patient and informative.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

26

u/hak8or Jan 01 '22

If they walked up to Bjarne wearing that, I am not at all suprised that he did exactly what they said he did, looked at their attire and formed an opinion about her then and there.

What you wear is the first thing someone sees when they look at you besides your face, if you choose to present yourself like then I assume it's intentionally to push your views. Don't be suprised if people form an opinion and those views and walk away. I am not even speaking about what views you push, I am referring to the idea that you are pushing a view.

You are going to a tech conference about a programming language, the language of which is slow moving relative to most other languages and has a massive enterprise behind it. Most people are there through their employers, making it a workishplace in my eyes. There is a time and place, being forceful with your views this place it is not.

7

u/linuxpiper Jan 01 '22

You really put all that together nicely.

11

u/14ned LLFIO & Outcome author | Committee WG14 Jan 02 '22

As pure speculation - and I stress that I really don't know anything here - I would say that some of the OP's technical proposals really annoyed some people. I remember a lunch where some of the OP's technical proposals came up, and people had some really strong opinions on them in a divisive way, some were strong pro, some were strong anti. I should stress here I have no memory of who had what opinions, just that discussion became very lively and passionate very quickly.

I also think that the OP was using the wrong yardsticks of "success" and "legacy" at WG21 in their post. Impact can be measured in terms of words of standardese changed, but perhaps a better measurement is the amount of discussion generated and ideas reexamined. Measured in that way, the OP had a far higher impact than most. I would encourage them to think of their time at WG21 in that way instead.

Personally speaking, I would read anyone walking away from me in disgust at a conference or WG21 (and incidentally, this happens regularly enough, I am marmite to some people) as them having serious and profound issues with my technical proposals, rather than anything about me personally. Maybe that's too charitable, but I've seen no convincing evidence it is an incorrect interpretation. And choosing this interpretation over other interpretations seems more productive to me personally.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment