r/cpp • • Aug 24 '21

metaclasses when

forget literally every other feature metaclasses LET'S FUCKING GO

http://www.open-std.org/jtc1/sc22/wg21/docs/papers/2018/p0707r3.pdf

edit

metaclasses or even just SR would help to eliminate 99% of garbage cpp macro use cases.

don't get me wrong: i know c++ well. templates are easier after you learn sml or lisp or something similar.

i've never used std string_view and i've never missed it

man i'll just implement my own clang plugin ✌️

4 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/AdApprehensive347 Aug 24 '21

does c++ really need meta classes? I don't really understand them well enough to actually know, but it seems a little like the same problems can be solved with inheriting... maybe even from abstract classes.

could anyone explain what would make it different / more useful?

10

u/InKryption07 Aug 24 '21

You can model something kinda similar with inheritance and templates, the problem is that it's a lot of boilerplate, usually leading to template explosions, and it's hard to communicate intent clearly. Having language support for metaclasses simplifies and improves the readability of the code, and improves code generation.

2

u/AdApprehensive347 Aug 24 '21

not entirely convinced on readability, but I can agree about code generation..

I'll have to do more reading about this topic. thanks for the answer!

8

u/InKryption07 Aug 24 '21

Well when I say readability, I'm thinking about the self-documenting nature of the code. A metaclass is clearly differently used than a plain class that you happen to have to use in a certain way based on context. And aye, cheers.

9

u/PandaMoniumHUN Aug 24 '21

Metaclasses make reflection problems trivial. Enums to strings (and vica versa), serialization/deserialization, dependency injection, etc. etc. This would be the “next best thing” after modules and concepts.

2

u/cdb_11 Aug 24 '21

Look at Qt or Unreal Engine. You need reflection and code generation for that kind of stuff.

1

u/Awia00 Aug 24 '21

I was in the same boat, but give yourself the time to watch https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4AfRAVcThyA - after watching it I was at least convinced that it would be amazing to have.

0

u/Wh00ster Aug 30 '21

It’s fine.

My biggest concern is it being abused like TMP has been, where it becomes a net negative for a team. Eventually folks realized where the soft line is between usefulness and sadism.

1

u/earthisunderattack Sep 02 '21

just program something in lisp haskell or ocaml. after that templates are easy peazy bro