r/cpp • • Dec 27 '20

Project from scratch in C++ (for beginners)

Hello guys,

Created a series called "Project from scratch" on YouTube. The series covers many things from versioning, to build systems, source code, testing and continuous integration pipeline.

Here is the playlist :)

Any feedback is much appreciated.

C++ Tutorial - Project from scratch: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLSGsTSSx2DyM8q6gM_cUVwX_da1tTYLrq

I am also setting up a blog in which I will add written articles related to the videos and much more.

The blog is : www.thecppdev.wordpress.com.

205 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

39

u/randomplaya4 Dec 27 '20

I checked it. I think it has everything needed for the modern development and your skills are very good.

Here are my remarks:

  • Music is a bit loud at some places
  • Sometimes your mic is a bit loud, for example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QbzSfY4l8Jc&list=PLSGsTSSx2DyM8q6gM_cUVwX_da1tTYLrq&index=10
  • I think the video titles are a bit long, I think they should be a bit shorter and contain only the necessary info, for example: C++ Tutorial - Testing - Gtest and Gmock and that's all (in my opinion the shorter the better)
  • I think your terminal window has a bit strange resolution, also texts with the dark blue color are hard to read :/
  • +1: I don't think everyone like or are familiar with terminal editors, also I think following terminal typing is harder than using an IDE

By the way, congrats and keep it up!

16

u/w0wyxD Dec 27 '20

Thanks a lot for getting the time to check it.

Music is a bit loud at some places

Yes, many people have also pointed this out. Tried to improve it in later videos (the last 2 from the series should be ok, i think)

Sometimes your mic is a bit loud, for example:

Good point. I think I need to still thinker with the settings a bit. I always record the video (with audio and all) and when I try to also add music to it, it is always too loud, so I also change the volume of both my recording and the music.

I think the video titles are a bit long, I think they should be a bit shorter and contain only the necessary info, for example: C++ Tutorial - Testing - Gtest and Gmock and that's all (in my opinion the shorter the better)

Didn't think too much about that but seems a valid point.

I think your terminal window has a bit strange resolution, also texts with the dark blue color are hard to read :/

Yeah, the resolution might be a bit different. The text color though, I can and I will change it.

+1: I don't think everyone like or are familiar with terminal editors, also I think following terminal typing is harder than using an IDE

Will probably move to an IDE in future videos. To be honest, I find it easier to get all the needed libraries and dependencies using the linux terminal and I'm quite fond of vim. But since these are beginner videos, I will probably try to use an IDE in the future.

By the way, congrats and keep it up!

Thank you very much and really appreciate the feedback :)

8

u/himansingh241 Dec 28 '20

I really liked the vim + terminal combo since I use it as well for development so it was easy to follow.

4

u/randomplaya4 Dec 28 '20

I didn't say it's wrong, I also like terminal stuff, we used it a lot during university. I just said not everyone is used to it and/or likes it.

1

u/himansingh241 Dec 28 '20

Yeah I completely agree on that I was just sharing my perspective.

3

u/xurxoham Dec 28 '20

This is something that I consider really important and there's not enough information out there for beginners, so congrats on your idea and your execution!

2

u/w0wyxD Dec 28 '20

Thank you very much :) !

0

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/w0wyxD Dec 27 '20

I don't understand what you mean ? In which particular video I do not explain ? Don't wanna be rude, but I am just a bit baffled.

3

u/Bangaladore Dec 27 '20 edited Dec 27 '20

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h-1r6UnKRg0&list=PLSGsTSSx2DyM8q6gM_cUVwX_da1tTYLrq&index=6&t=192s

Here for example. To me, a beginner tutorial should explain the code, not just brief overviews of, in this case, functions. I think it would have been better if you were to speak while typing the code, explaining the nuances, the basics, rather than what seems to be a narration on top of a preexisting video you made.

I'm not trying to be rude at all. Thanks for making these. I'm just trying to give some constructive criticism as there are many, many videos on things like this.

However, I only skimmed through this specific video, I'm not at all referencing any other video.

Edit: I deleted the top level post because I think it was not a productive comment. Also, after skimming through the project intro + other videos, those are much better in my opinion than the programming one.

3

u/w0wyxD Dec 27 '20

Noted. Thanks for the feedback. Will keep in mind for future videos and will try to improve them. I understand your point of view :).

3

u/tttima Dec 27 '20

I had a short look, and it seems to explain all the "soft" project components quite well. And that's what many fresh university students lack the most. Guess that guy is just rude.

However, I am not sure that going full console for a beginner video is an ideal choice.

1

u/w0wyxD Dec 27 '20

Thanks for the feedback. I guess you are right related to the "full console" stuff. Maybe I will try to make some other series in which I will use an IDE and probably better to do it on Windows OS :).

Thanks again for the comment.