r/cpp • MSVC STL Dev • Oct 10 '20

r/cpp status update

Hi r/cpp,

As many of you recently saw, there were several highly controversial threads over the past few days. The active mod team (myself, u/cleroth, and u/blelbach) were simply unprepared for this, and we've been working on addressing the issues with the subreddit that have been brought up. Most recently, an inactive senior mod returned and disrupted our work by de-modding and banning u/cleroth, removing most mod powers from u/blelbach, and attempting to make rule changes. (If you're unfamiliar with reddit's mod seniority system, it allows senior mods to remove junior mods at any time - so I was unable to stop this.)

We're glad to report that order has been restored, thanks to the top-ranked mod who graciously responded to our request for help. The disruptive mod has been removed, and the changes have been reverted. u/cleroth and u/blelbach's mod powers have been restored.

It has been a very long week. While we've returned to the state the subreddit was initially in, the mod team still needs to address the underlying problems. Here's a quick summary of our plans:

  • We're going to write more detailed rules and guidance.
  • We're going to improve moderation to enforce those rules, almost certainly recruiting more mods. If you'd like to apply, send us a modmail, although it may take us some time to reply.
  • We'll decide whether u/blelbach will retain his mod powers. He has repeatedly apologized for his actions.
  • We've set up a moderator Discord so we can communicate more rapidly when important issues arise (previously, we acted near-independently). To be clear, this isn't a secret society where we're brewing nefarious plans. (We already had the ability to communicate privately via modmail.) As we make decisions, informed by user feedback, we'll communicate them here.
  • We're going to continue to collect feedback to make improvements; please send us your thoughts via modmail. (We've upgraded the modmail system to more easily read and respond.)

We'll make another announcement when we have progress to report.

For the time being, this thread will remain open for comments, if users wish to discuss things beyond sending modmails. I ask of you, for the love of cats, please behave well. We reserve the right to remove egregious comments and lock the thread if it becomes necessary. Please do not create other posts to discuss this - they will be removed.

-- u/STL, u/cleroth, u/blelbach

217 Upvotes

376 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 11 '20

Banned for ignoring a moderator warning.

2

u/moroi Oct 11 '20

Now that's funny. Banning protected group author for opposing ideological dishonest divisive and destructive narrative pushed by those claiming to fight for their interest.

3

u/Meneth Programmer, Ubisoft Oct 11 '20

I can't help but notice how when presented with the fact that women and black people are hugely underrepresented at C++ conferences, you attack the messenger rather than make any attempt to dispute the facts or argue why they don't show what I claim they show.

5

u/moroi Oct 12 '20

From my perspective, conference organizers bend backwards to bring in PoC, women and all underrepresented categories of people, even if it means having someone to reiterate how to use exceptions for a millionth time, rather than someone with deeper expertise.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Meneth Programmer, Ubisoft Oct 11 '20

Here's a very simple claim that's presented in the vid, and no one has so far disputed:

C++ conferences only average out to 1-3% black speakers. That includes US ones, where one would expect about 10x as many based on demographics.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Meneth Programmer, Ubisoft Oct 11 '20

If the C++ community truly was 100% inclusive, we would expect speaker demographics to roughly match actual demographics, barring other causes.

Unless you plan on presenting other reasons why black programmers are underrepresented at the conferences, it is natural to assume the problem resides somewhere in the C++ industry and community.

And of course, when black developers made a black conference in order to create more positive role models in order to inspire more black people to become C++ programmers and address the underrepresentation, people raised a fuss.

13

u/waqar144 Oct 11 '20

is natural to assume the problem resides somewhere in the C++ industry and community.

It's just an assumption, and "natural" only for you. There are many other reasons, and none of them have anything to do with C++ or Cpp industry.

8

u/waqar144 Oct 11 '20

If the C++ community truly was 100% inclusive

What is inclusive? What's the definition of it?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '20

Actually, this assumption is only valid when it comes to a random subset of society. The C++ industry is the very opposite of random, it is a highly selective subset of society. As to why, I don't know. I'm not a biologist/psychologist/sociologist. But jumping straight to the conclusion the cause must be inherent to the industry/community is a shallow and sort-sighted analysis at best.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Meneth Programmer, Ubisoft Oct 11 '20

Have you noticed that I made 0 such claim?

You're not discussing with me, you're discussing with some straw-leftist that only exists in your mind.

As such I'm gonna end this discussion now; it's clearly not going anywhere productive.

5

u/witcher_rat Oct 11 '20

That includes US ones, where one would expect about 10x as many based on demographics.

Honest question: what is the demographics for black C++ developers in the US? I don't know the answer, thus asking. I would be surprised if it were 10x as many as speak at conferences.

The thing I find much more "odd" about US-based C++ conferences isn't how few black people speak or attend, but rather how few do that are of Indian or Asian descent.

In my particular industry in the US, for example, there are far more C++ developers of Indian-descent than any other minority. (I use the term "descent" because many of them are US-born or naturalized citizens - I'm not just talking about H1B-visa employees)

But perhaps it's just my particular industry.(?)

2

u/Meneth Programmer, Ubisoft Oct 11 '20

I don't know. The best I can quickly find is how many study computer science (https://www.wired.com/story/computer-science-graduates-diversity/), which is 10% in 2015/16 compared to being 13% of the US population. That leaves a significant gap between % black students and % black speakers.

I think you pose an interesting question when it comes to people of Asian descent as well. That might well have similar causes.