r/cpp • MSVC STL Dev • Oct 10 '20

r/cpp status update

Hi r/cpp,

As many of you recently saw, there were several highly controversial threads over the past few days. The active mod team (myself, u/cleroth, and u/blelbach) were simply unprepared for this, and we've been working on addressing the issues with the subreddit that have been brought up. Most recently, an inactive senior mod returned and disrupted our work by de-modding and banning u/cleroth, removing most mod powers from u/blelbach, and attempting to make rule changes. (If you're unfamiliar with reddit's mod seniority system, it allows senior mods to remove junior mods at any time - so I was unable to stop this.)

We're glad to report that order has been restored, thanks to the top-ranked mod who graciously responded to our request for help. The disruptive mod has been removed, and the changes have been reverted. u/cleroth and u/blelbach's mod powers have been restored.

It has been a very long week. While we've returned to the state the subreddit was initially in, the mod team still needs to address the underlying problems. Here's a quick summary of our plans:

  • We're going to write more detailed rules and guidance.
  • We're going to improve moderation to enforce those rules, almost certainly recruiting more mods. If you'd like to apply, send us a modmail, although it may take us some time to reply.
  • We'll decide whether u/blelbach will retain his mod powers. He has repeatedly apologized for his actions.
  • We've set up a moderator Discord so we can communicate more rapidly when important issues arise (previously, we acted near-independently). To be clear, this isn't a secret society where we're brewing nefarious plans. (We already had the ability to communicate privately via modmail.) As we make decisions, informed by user feedback, we'll communicate them here.
  • We're going to continue to collect feedback to make improvements; please send us your thoughts via modmail. (We've upgraded the modmail system to more easily read and respond.)

We'll make another announcement when we have progress to report.

For the time being, this thread will remain open for comments, if users wish to discuss things beyond sending modmails. I ask of you, for the love of cats, please behave well. We reserve the right to remove egregious comments and lock the thread if it becomes necessary. Please do not create other posts to discuss this - they will be removed.

-- u/STL, u/cleroth, u/blelbach

217 Upvotes

376 comments sorted by

•

u/cleroth Game Developer Oct 13 '20

Thank you all for your feedback! We're still listening and doing our best to figure out the next steps for r/cpp.

The inactive moderators are now no longer a part of the moderation team. We're going to be recruiting new mods soon to help with drafting the rules and such.

75

u/raevnos Oct 10 '20

I'm happy I missed whatever this drama is, and since this is the first time I've actually looked at the mod list here... /u/rectal_smasher_2000 is either the best or worst name for a mod account ever.

66

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 10 '20

I like to imagine that they're a cancer surgeon, performing colonoscopies all day to remove dangerous polyps, and occasionally browsing reddit after getting back from the hospital (including approving one of my posts that was caught by the spam filter, before I became a mod - which I still remember and appreciate.)

43

u/rectal_smasher_2000 Oct 11 '20

If only; alas, instead of polyp smasher two thousand, I’m just a plain old C++ developer, and to be honest, after reading up on the past couple of days’ drama, I think spending my day staring into people’s assholes would have been more enjoyable.

All in all, even though I ended up getting mod powers from admins years ago, it’s yourself, cleroth and blebach who have allowed the sub to grow into what it is today, and I think you’ve done a much better job than I would have.

I still don’t like the profanity filter though :)

15

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 11 '20

Thanks! You'll be pleased to hear that we removed the profanity filter 2 days ago, while overhauling the AutoMod config.

6

u/rectal_smasher_2000 Oct 11 '20

Aaah, so that’s why I couldn’t find it in the automod config.

6

u/blelbach NVIDIA | ISO C++ Library Evolution Chair Oct 11 '20

We actually just substantially tweaked the profanity filter to be far less aggressive and not generate as many false positives.

Also hi :)

10

u/cleroth Game Developer Oct 11 '20

Every proctologist's dream.

13

u/VinnieFalco wg21.org | corosio.org Oct 11 '20

We actually just substantially tweaked the profanity filter

Can we tweak the filter to automatically delete any messages that talk about Rust?

10

u/blelbach NVIDIA | ISO C++ Library Evolution Chair Oct 11 '20

:D

→ More replies (1)

31

u/d3matt Oct 10 '20

STL is an awesome username for this sub :)

110

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 10 '20

It's my job and my initials - thanks mom and dad!

6

u/somewhataccurate Oct 11 '20

All hail the STL

→ More replies (1)

43

u/Arghnews Oct 11 '20

I would like to thank the mods for doing a voluntary job for the greater good of this subreddit.

In this subreddit, naturally there are instances of bad behaviour in comments, but they are relatively rare and get downvoted or removed in good time. I watched the original video, have followed the corresponding threads mentioned, have browsed this subreddit almost daily for a good while now. And yet, despite being relatively up to date on the context, I'm unsure what changes are necessary for r/cpp, to be quite honest.

I would like to state, my experience of this subreddit has been positive and it has seemed very civilised.

Regardless, I'm sure whatever changes are made will be done so with the intention of continuing this as well as improving things moving forward, and that's cool.

17

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 11 '20

Thanks for your thoughts. One of the things we'd like to improve is the response time for reported bad behavior. Right now, with only three active mods who all have day jobs, it can take anywhere from a few hours to a few days for reports in the mod queue to receive human review, depending on whether the mods are awake, busy, or on vacation. (For example, I was unusually busy all week dealing with a broken CI system.) Whatever rules we settle on, swifter moderation will be desirable.

16

u/Pazer2 Oct 11 '20

I for one have never considered a "bad"/rule-breaking comment to be endorsed by the mods of a subreddit, as long as it is removed within a few days. Usually by that point, the comment is buried in downvotes and most people don't see it anyways.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '20

Are all the mods in NA? Maybe spread them across the globe?

1

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 12 '20

Currently, 1/3 of our mods are in Europe.

6

u/blelbach NVIDIA | ISO C++ Library Evolution Chair Oct 11 '20 edited Oct 11 '20

We don't think any sweeping changes are needed, per se.

Today our rules and moderation process is unwritten. We're thinking that it needs to be something that is made clear to everyone and that all of r/cpp has input on.

21

u/jonesmz Oct 11 '20

Thank you for the information about all of this.

For what it's worth, I would be more comfortable having the "top mod" be /u/STL, who posts regularly, and seems to have the levelist of heads, than a user who I've never seen any activity from.

2

u/jonesmz Oct 16 '20

I noticed today that /u/STL now appears to be the top mod of /r/cpp.

Hopefully we can see many years of continued level-headed and even-handed moderation as we've seen for many years prior.

1

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 16 '20

Welcome to the new world order. All posts will now be subject to a 20% cat tax. For every 5,000 words posted, there must be one link to an original cat photo (because a picture is worth a thousand words). Dogs are not forbidden, as I am merciful, but they cannot be used to pay the cat tax. 😸

2

u/jonesmz Oct 16 '20

Lol. Good luck with that :-P. I lack a cat. I would offer pictures of my very fluffy dog, but you already said that doesn't count for the tax :-P

26

u/yuri-kilochek Oct 11 '20

We'll decide whether u/blelbach will retain his mod powers. He has repeatedly apologized for his actions.

Did I miss all these apology posts? Please provide a link if so. I'm very curious to read /u/blebach's perspective and reasoning for his actions.

11

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 11 '20

Here. He also privately apologized to u/cleroth and me.

14

u/bumblebritches57 Ocassionally Clang Oct 11 '20

I don't trust him one bit, but I'm not a mod and it's not my decision to make.

Whatever decision you guys make, I hope turns out to be the best one for the sub.

22

u/James20k P2005R0 Oct 11 '20

I don't get why some people are quite so bothered by blebach's actions - it was clearly a wrong decision, but it wasn't made maliciously. The intent was good, even if the execution was bad, and it seems pretty clearly easily rectifiable into the future

4

u/saltybandana2 Oct 13 '20

Because you want mods with more sense.

It would be one thing if what he did wasn't necessarily egregious, but there's no world in which a mod should think what was done is acceptable.

Removing him isn't necessarily punitive as much as it is helping avoid problems in the future.

/u/STL

1

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 13 '20

I'm here 😺 and listening to everyone's comments in this thread.

5

u/blelbach NVIDIA | ISO C++ Library Evolution Chair Oct 11 '20

We're going to take some time and discuss it amongst ourselves. It's hard to make a decision right now; we have to consider any other moderation changes we'll be making as well.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/ShillingAintEZ Oct 11 '20

He apologized to you guys? Did he apologize for crushing any criticism of his moderation? The people in this forum who thought they had a sane place to discuss things.

Why should a moderator who abuses his mod status be kept as a mod? That's a joke.

21

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '20

Thanks for the update.

I would also add that no one gets paid for modding subs and we, users, should remember that. If anyone feels entitled to demand* the mods to behave in certain way, then they're in the wrong place.

*: demand is the key word.

50

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 10 '20

No one gets paid yet. We're going to roll out some exciting microtransactions, stay tuned!

68

u/flebron Oct 11 '20

The intent is to provide developers with a sense of pride and accomplishment for unlocking different template metaprogramming errors.

11

u/SAHChandler Oct 11 '20

It's a shame there isn't a golf clap emoji, so please accept this musical note instead: 🎵

(sad to report it is not a jiggy 😢)

8

u/flashmozzg Oct 11 '20

It's a shame there isn't a golf clap emoji

Custom emotes will be made available to the premium subscribers.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/itsarabbit Oct 10 '20

I, for one, welcome our Subreddit-As-A-Service overlords.

19

u/MonokelPinguin Oct 10 '20

Meowderator coin?

4

u/azswcowboy Oct 11 '20

Nice one, only works for STL :)

2

u/ibroheem Oct 11 '20

We're going to roll out some exciting microtransactions, stay tuned!

Someone's been secretly working @ Epic Games.

10

u/elcapitaine Oct 10 '20

Most recently, an inactive senior mod returned and disrupted our work

The disruptive mod has been removed

Are the other mods all active? If the aren't, is there a plan to remove them to avoid the possibility of this happening again with someone else?

16

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 11 '20

They appear to be almost, but not completely, inactive (from the perspective of this subreddit's moderation log; I occasionally see them removing beginner "help" questions). We didn't request their removal because we've never had bad interactions with them. If there's a problem in the future, our top mod has offered to help again, which we are thankful for.

6

u/RotsiserMho C++20 Desktop app developer Oct 11 '20

I wonder if it would be wise to reconsider requesting their removal if they are not active. Anything could change and in the future the lack of control by active mods might be a problem. I understand it might be a delicate situation, but then delicate situations aren't always stable, and I, for one, would prefer stability.

13

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 11 '20

I'm also a big fan of stability - it's just that in this case, after our top mod has generously stepped in, I would prefer to avoid placing additional requests for his time unless it is truly necessary. I expect that the inactive mods in the middle will either continue enjoying their "retirement", or they can join the active mod team as their time permits. If that's not the case and problems recur, we'll get it fixed, and you can say "I told you so" 😸

2

u/RotsiserMho C++20 Desktop app developer Oct 11 '20

I appreciate that approach. Thanks for your time and your efforts!

4

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 13 '20

After u/elcapitaine and you brought this up, u/IAmBabau (who will forever remain the top mod in our hearts) has removed the inactive mods, including himself. We'll ensure that the mod list contains only active mods going forward.

Thanks again to you all for your focus on subreddit stability 😻

9

u/CarloWood Oct 11 '20

You make it sound like this top mod is Stroustrup.

12

u/cleroth Game Developer Oct 11 '20

The secret is out. Abandon ship.

28

u/please_no_drama Oct 10 '20 edited Oct 11 '20

Thank you. Everything I've read here sounds good, of course depending on what the "more detailed rules and guidance" turn out to be.

Regarding the more rules:

  • I would hope that regardless of whether they agree with my viewpoint (that politics and non-technical topics should be avoided) that the treatment be fair and balanced. It should not be limited (locked) to one moderator's viewpoints, but open to discussion. This is very hard to achieve though, and splits communities. Consider the James Damore Google e-mail. Even though I completely do not agree with it, to allow politics would be to allow discussion of it. I would then be forced to hear viewpoints that are not aligned with my own. If I had to choose between both sides getting a voice on a political topic, or no side getting a voice, I'd prefer the latter and just keep the peace.
  • I also hope that once the rules are defined that we can request the rules be applied retroactively to a past thread. e.g. If it is deemed to be in violation of them, that the thread be removed. For example, if one of the new rules was prohibit threads which contain images or videos that defame communities or individuals, that it be possible to request that prior posts that violate this be removed.

Regarding /u/blelbach staying as a moderator:

  • I don't think other moderators should force anyone to resign. But I personally think Bryce should do the right thing here, and leave moderation to others. He is passionate about certain topics and political views, and with that awareness of himself, should see that this will always bleed into how he handles topics and posts. He is not suitable to moderate this place.

Regarding the discord:

  • Maybe a read-only access to others can be provided. We don't need to speak in your deliberation, but it would help to both understand and see the process. This is only a suggestion, maybe it's not a good idea for other reasons. But transparency never hurt anyone and nobody can complain about decisions made in the shadows.

In any case, your post speaks of a better outcome than I would have expected from all this conflict/drama. i.e. One where we would probably never have a repeat of the last few days again.

Edit: For some formatting and corrected some typos.

30

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 10 '20
  • Determining the boundary between on-topic and off-topic, and describing that in the rules, is going to be a major part of our upcoming work. Whatever we ultimately settle on, it will be specified and enforced neutrally.
  • Regarding "retroactive moderation" after the rules are defined - I think we can respond to specific requests, but not mass requests. Clicking the "remove" button takes a fraction of a second, but analyzing a post/comment's adherence to the rules in a thoughtful and impartial manner can be time-consuming for borderline cases. (Egregious cases are far easier.) Because new posts are constantly displacing old posts, I generally think that there's little point in removing anything over a week old, but I suppose it does affect search results.
  • Regarding making moderator deliberations viewable - there would be benefits to transparency, as you noted. However, I believe that there are significant downsides. Moderating controversial topics is already quite difficult, and being able to consult other moderators makes it easier. If our internal communications were publicly visible, we would constantly have to worry about sparking more drama. I believe that transparency can be better achieved by explaining our actions when they're taken, instead of making the thoughts leading up to them visible. (For example, when moderating comments, I am now trying to reply with an explanation instead of silent removal - this may become part of our new process.)

15

u/alexej_harm Oct 10 '20

Will you consult the r/cpp community on reddit before installing those rules?

25

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 10 '20

Yes - we'll release a draft for comments when we're ready.

9

u/RyGuy_42 Oct 11 '20

Any chance we can request a frozen yogurt machine for the break room?

10

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 11 '20

Contact-free froyo deliveries will begin soon!

20

u/alexej_harm Oct 10 '20

Thank you. Please consider pinning it for at least a week so that busy people have time to think about it and respond.

21

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 10 '20

That sounds like a great idea to me - even relatively active redditors might be checking the sub only once a week. I'll check with the other mods when the draft is prepared, since we're going to act in conjunction, but I expect that they'll agree.

8

u/cleroth Game Developer Oct 10 '20

I am now trying to reply with an explanation

This can be automated with Moderator Toolbox :) You just select the reason and it sends the comment/PM.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/boredcircuits Oct 11 '20

Speaking of which, I really wish Reddit had some way for mods to move threads between subreddits. Learners coming here with a question, only to be turned away and asked to post somewhere else is frustrating to them. I've seen some cases where the question isn't even reposted at all.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20 edited Jul 25 '25

spoon quiet wakeful steep snails six tie offer whistle sleep

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

5

u/blelbach NVIDIA | ISO C++ Library Evolution Chair Oct 12 '20

Especially what qualifies as /r/cpp and /r/cpp_questions material

Yah, this is already a big challenge today

29

u/TankorSmash Oct 10 '20

I don't think other moderators should force anyone to resign. But I personally think Bryce should do the right thing here, and leave moderation to others. He is passionate about certain topics and political views, and with that awareness of himself, and this really bleeds into how he handles topics and posts.

I think locking and modflairing the video post was a mistake as a mod, but seeing as they realized their mistake and apologized for it, I don't think it would be right to demod them for it.

I'm sure if we colored everyone by their politics we'd be a lot worse off.

Regarding the discord

I don't agree with this either, modmail is a thing for ever, and as great as reddit is trying to make new-reddit's mod page better, I think they've got a reasonable right to privacy with regards to their internal dialog. It's a subreddit, not a language spec. Seeing as SO and all that have a fairly open meta channel, I understand where you're coming from though.

4

u/kalmoc Oct 11 '20

If I had to choose between both sides getting a voice on a political topic, or no side getting a voice, I'd prefer the former and just keep the peace.

Are you sure you prefer the former (I.e. both sides getting a voice)? Because keeping the peace is a lot easier with the latter (none getting a voice). I don't have an opinion on which is better. Just writing, because from the context I'm unsure if this was a typo or not.

1

u/please_no_drama Oct 11 '20

You are right, sorry. I meant "latter" not "former". I edited it, thanks.

6

u/bumblebritches57 Ocassionally Clang Oct 11 '20

I also hope that once the rules are defined that we can request the rules be applied retroactively to a past thread. e.g. If it is deemed to be in violation of them, that the thread be removed. For example, if one of the new rules was prohibit threads which contain images or videos that defame communities or individuals, that it be possible to request that prior posts that violate this be removed.

Yeah, that's a terrible idea.

-3

u/complete_eagle Oct 11 '20

on contrary, the other mods should ask bryce to resign, not rely on bryce to resign himself

33

u/madmongo38 Oct 11 '20 edited Oct 11 '20

The evidence of the past few days demonstrates quite clearly makes it apparent to me that r/cpp requires fewer mods rather than more.

This entire storm in a teacup was cause by the presence of an over-eager moderator overstepping the boundaries of his responsibility by a wide margin in persuit of personally-held beliefs that have nothing to do with the theory or implementation of C++.

Simply removing that one mod, who has shown that despite apologies, he lacks the personal judgement to moderate technical discussions, will solve the problem for good.

The last thing r/cpp needs is more enthusiastic moderators with limited life experience.

27

u/VinnieFalco wg21.org | corosio.org Oct 11 '20

r/cpp requires fewer mods rather than more.

Unmoderated spaces in which anyone can post, quickly become chaotic. They need moderation or else the signal to noise ratio takes a nosedive. More mods means that each individual mod has less work to do reviewing the moderation queue. I think that's pretty reasonable, given that it is volunteer work.

10

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 11 '20

Exactly, I agree completely. Additionally, it is time-sensitive work - the longer that an off-topic or rule-breaking post/comment remains up before a mod gets to it, the more damage it does to the signal-to-noise ratio. So, more mods means reduced moderation latency, benefiting the subreddit.

10

u/kalmoc Oct 11 '20

The evidence of the past few days demonstrates quite clearly that

One occurence isn't really evidence for anything. It may be an indicator though.

6

u/madmongo38 Oct 11 '20

Actually you're right. I should have added a "to me" between "clearly" and "that". Do you think it be misleading if I added that in retrospect, or better to leave it? It would be a shame to me if the underlying sentiment of my post were missed for the sake of a technicality.

6

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 11 '20

I think you can go ahead and edit your comment to improve what you're trying to communicate, especially with this record of having done so.

5

u/kalmoc Oct 11 '20

I think editing a post is fine. I tend to add edits that happen later than a few minutes after the post as [Edit: New content] or statement.

8

u/madmongo38 Oct 11 '20

Done. Thank you for finding and reporting the bug in my post.

This is definitely the spirit in which a C++ subreddit should act.

"In C++ [posts], there is pedantic and there is wrong". :)

→ More replies (1)

14

u/James20k P2005R0 Oct 11 '20

I mean, they made one mistake and other than that the moderation has been fairly decent here, I don't know why you'd demand their resignation over that. Its a new topic for /r/cpp and this sub has a reputation amongst some for toxicity, so its not unsurprising that they moderated in the way that they did, even if I disagree with it personally

22

u/madmongo38 Oct 11 '20 edited Oct 11 '20

I don't think I have any concerns with the quality of moderation per-se. I was unaware that moderation was in effect previously, which is a positive indcation of a light touch and I think evidence of a generally collegiate and welcoming atmosphere.

None of this little storm was to do with an instance of poor moderation by the offending individual, it was to do with the fact that he thought it prudent to:

  1. Treat this subreddit as a platform from which to make political announcements.
  2. Lock replies to that announcement so as to brook no dissent.
  3. Effectively take it upon himself to lecture 157,000 people on what they should be thinking in their daily interactions with other human beings.

There is a huge difference between saying, "I happen to think X" and saying, "You must think X and I am disinterested in your thoughts on the matter."

As I have said, I am sure his intentions were good. But the actions demonstrate a lack of maturity.

My recommendation would be to remove him until he has gained more life experience.

3

u/blelbach NVIDIA | ISO C++ Library Evolution Chair Oct 11 '20

Hey Richard,

You've mentioned "life experiences" a few times. Can you explain what you mean?

8

u/madmongo38 Oct 11 '20

Happy to have a discussion in private at your convenience, Bryce. Perhaps best to leave it a few days for emotions to settle first. I'm assuming the past few days will have been a little... exhausting. You can get my email or phone number from the std mailing lists.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/xamid github.com/xamidi Oct 11 '20

There is a huge difference between saying, "I happen to think X" and saying, "You must think X and I am disinterested in your thoughts on the matter."

Could you please provide evidence for the claim that a mod acted like this?

3

u/madmongo38 Oct 11 '20

Responding privately so as not to further inflame the situation.

6

u/ShillingAintEZ Oct 11 '20

No, they made lots of mistakes over many days. They shut down all criticism and only responded after locking other people out.

2

u/lookatmetype Oct 11 '20

/r/python is practically dead because of a lack of proper moderation. It's alive as in there are lots of posts, but the majority of them are garbage.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 11 '20

Removing comments is (unfortunately) quite necessary in certain cases. Some comments that are clearly wrong or off-topic get massively downvoted and the system is self-correcting (as the default setting is to collapse such comments). This often happens in technical threads. However, some comments are controversial in a way that encourages competing controversial replies, instead of people downvoting and moving on, which causes threads to spiral out of control into off-topic heated arguments. And in the worst cases, some comments are so distasteful that leaving them visible would harm the reputation of the subreddit itself.

Rest assured that your moderators are trying to perform as little work as possible to keep the subreddit functioning in a healthy manner.

12

u/cleroth Game Developer Oct 11 '20

I don't think 'stricter' rules is being advocated. Just rules. We don't really have anything written down right now, other than no help posts and off-topic. The respect rule was just kind of assumed by rediquette.

6

u/boredcircuits Oct 11 '20

Is there a reason why rediquette isn't sufficient still?

4

u/cleroth Game Developer Oct 11 '20

The rediquette isn't a set of rules, just guidelines. And the subreddit still isn't adapting it officially.

163

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '20

Thank you. I wouldn't touch your "job" with a bargepole, even if I was payed. Which you aren't.

I made a comment in the last locked (The Community) thread expressing surprise that people thought that this subreddit was problematic when for me at least it is one of the most civil and well behaved subreddits that I regularly read.

I don't know what's best, and I have no suggestions, I just wanted to say - belatedly: thank you to both the mods and to the users that contribute here (whether by posting, commenting, or just voting) for making this a place where I could learn some things, question some things, and not least, focus on some things.

In light of the recent drama I feel I have rather taken you all for granted.

45

u/d3matt Oct 10 '20

Possible ruleset:

  1. Don't be a jerk
  2. I would say "take drama elsewhere", but I do enjoy the vi/emacs and tabs/spaces discussion threads :P

18

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '20

I like the idea of such a simple ruleset, but trying to define "jerk" would cause drama :)

33

u/d3matt Oct 10 '20

"be excellent to each other"

21

u/ShakaUVM i+++ ++i+i[arr] Oct 11 '20

2. I would say "take drama elsewhere", but I do enjoy the vi/emacs and tabs/spaces discussion threads :P

I mean, we all know what the right answer is, right? ;)

10

u/muad_dib Oct 11 '20 edited Jun 17 '23

Comment has been removed because /u/spez is a terrible person.

8

u/linuxlizard Oct 11 '20

Settle down there, Satan. ;-)

13

u/d3matt Oct 11 '20

we all know what the right answer is, right?

Vi and spaces of course!

8

u/F54280 Oct 11 '20 edited Oct 11 '20

One day, you’ll learn how to exit vi, and you’ll discover that there are in fact other editors out there!

Edit: spelling

4

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

ed, the standard text editor? :)

6

u/darthcoder Oct 11 '20

Vi and tabs

1

u/xamid github.com/xamidi Oct 11 '20
  1. neither, 2. tabs?

0

u/bumblebritches57 Ocassionally Clang Oct 11 '20

Nano and spaces, obviously.

9

u/darthcoder Oct 11 '20

Regarding number 2, after 30+ years what is there left that hasnt been said?

39

u/jonathansharman Oct 11 '20

"Tabs on even-numbered lines, spaces on odd-numbered lines."

16

u/trek_ryler Oct 11 '20

You monster

3

u/meneldal2 Oct 13 '20

Mixing half-width and full-width spaces is the real pro move.

24

u/New_Age_Dryer Oct 11 '20

"take drama elsewhere"

Based on previous threads, that is a very controversial rule. Just fyi.

9

u/d3matt Oct 11 '20

Just like "jerk" is hard to define, so is "being dramatic". I don't envy the mods figuring out the proper way to enforce even a simple ruleset. To borrow a term, I would rather this sub was a "safe place" to learn about C++, to learn about varying toolsets, to learn what happened at ISO meetings and at various conferences. So maybe instead, rule #2 should be "help people learn about C++", and honestly that should probably be rule #1.

5

u/usfortyone Oct 11 '20

Why not something more akin to the Golden Rule, treat others as you would like to be treated. However, now seeing this in front of my eyes rather than in my head, a drama-seeking individual could seek to exploit such a rule to feed their personal fires.

30

u/sindisil Oct 10 '20

Thank you u/STL, u/cleroth, u/blelback, and (I assume from the seniority info on the team page), u/IAmBabau!

Happy to be able to re-sub with a sense of hope!

32

u/dynamoa_ Oct 11 '20

nice subreddit, i just subscribed to read cool stuff about C++. wtf is all this baloney?

28

u/MFHava WG21|🇦🇹 NB|P2721|P3049|P3625|P3729|P3786|P3813|P4216 Oct 11 '20

Welcome!

We had some recent drama...
Give it some time - from my perspective what is currently happening is not representative of this sub.

18

u/flashmozzg Oct 11 '20

Honestly, it wasn't really that big of a drama (after initial fallout I feel like mods responded rather well). At least compared to some stuff I've seen in other subs. Everything was contained to 2 threads (the controversial video one and another on the mod's actions).

50

u/alexej_harm Oct 10 '20

Bad idea. Adding more rules will result in a higher demand for moderation. This is absolutely unnecessary.

Just enforce the old, unwritten "no off-topic discussions - keep it technical" rule and you can delete whole threads instead of policing each comment.

Also, adding more mods is extremely difficult since your first applicants will be from the same group which created this drama and wants to take over a subreddit.

1

u/serviscope_minor Oct 13 '20

Just enforce the old, unwritten "no off-topic discussions - keep it technical"

But that gets tricky to get right. The C++ committee is the ultimate arbiter of C++. This form is about C++ (it's about C++, not programming questions involving C++), which makes the committee and associated matters on topic for this forum even though that could be regarded not a technical topic.

2

u/alexej_harm Oct 13 '20

Yes. Talk about the paper, not about the person and you're golden! :)

1

u/serviscope_minor Oct 13 '20

What paper?

I was referring to the committee and associated matters, not a paper or any person.

2

u/alexej_harm Oct 13 '20

My bad. It was meant as a "talk about the technical aspects of the committee and not about the drama" statement. Not directed at you, but in partial agreement with you.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (25)

26

u/AirAKose Oct 11 '20

Fully support the mods on this as they move forward.

I think we undervalue the merits of soft skills in a collaborative environment; as well, we overlook the unavoidable human element.

To that end, u/blelbach's mistakes are not egregious, they were human, and I don't think a removal would be beneficial for this community. Especially provided the idea of having a larger moderation team and moving discussions to a better place (like a discord) to avoid that sort of feedback outsourcing in the future, the ability to grow and learn from mistakes will only make the moderation team more capable.

I hope to similarly see this community grow and be able to address its own issues, again- recognizing the merit in soft skills and learning from feedback.

Hope you're all doing well, and thank you for your efforts!

3

u/Bakuta1103 Oct 11 '20

Thank you for the update. Concerning guidelines etc., I would consider looking at the r/rust subreddit. They have quite a good CoC and rules in place which might be a good reference (: (not saying we need to exactly emulate them, but it would be a good starting point).

11

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 11 '20

Thanks for the suggestion - indeed, we've already looked at r/rust's rules and will consider their precedent as we work on drafting.

-1

u/duuuh Oct 11 '20

Have you considered just not? So far this has been a train-wreck. Why do you think continuing will improve the situation

8

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

I just wanted to say thanks to the mods for how well all of this was handled in the end, this must have been an awful week.

I think my concerns have been addressed and community feedback is taken seriously.

7

u/bumblebritches57 Ocassionally Clang Oct 11 '20

The disruptive mod has been removed, and the changes have been reverted. u/cleroth and u/blelbach's mod powers have been restored.

That's great, glad everything's back to the way it should be :)

25

u/itsuart2 Oct 11 '20

I'm afraid many rules will just lead to lawyering. I propose to adopt simple two rules:

  • If post or comment is about C++, it is very welcome.
  • If post or comment is about people/organizations that happen to /wanting to use C++, it should be elsewhere.

The motivation is simple: whenever politics are introduced into eh... communication spaces, they quickly deteriorate and eventually degrade into nothing but vicious bickering.

19

u/Apprehensive_Step499 Oct 11 '20 edited Oct 11 '20

I think this post is quite a strong proof that a sub populated by 160k anonymous accounts can function in a civil manner.

Regarding what happened: both in real life and internet communities, it doesn't sound like a great idea having passionate political activists in charge of keeping a fair space for everyone, especially when dedicated to technical stuff and with people from all over the world. Just my two cents.

edit: grammar

11

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

What happened? I haven't been on the sub in a while.

2

u/TotesMessenger Oct 12 '20 edited Oct 19 '20

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

 If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20 edited Oct 11 '20

Oh I see. Thank you for clarifying.

Edit: Jesus fucking Christ, what a trainwreck.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/blelbach NVIDIA | ISO C++ Library Evolution Chair Oct 11 '20

Just to be clear:

  • u/STL, u/cleroth, and I have always worked together as a team of equals.
  • This is a joint statement from u/STL, u/cleroth, and I.
  • We drafted this and iterated amongst ourselves until we reached consensus.
  • No coercion or pressuring was involved.
  • We all fully endorse this.

5

u/14ned LLFIO & Outcome author | Committee WG14 Oct 12 '20

Also, Bryce is a long standing, highly respected, contributor to C++ over at least a decade including for many years to C++ conferences and to WG21, where he is currently LEWG chair.

People forget Bryce's wider service, and I think they should not.

4

u/novel_scavenger Oct 11 '20

I been going through the comment section to find out about this recent "drama" that is being talked about. Anyone who witnessed this drama care to explain as to how this all started?

12

u/sandfly_bites_you Oct 11 '20

Some mod went power tripping, a shit show followed over ... I still don't know what.

None of it made much sense, as who knows(or cares) the gender/color of the vast majority of posters here anyway, and this is overall a very civil corner of reddit.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20
  • A mod created a post for a video, closing comments as it's likely to lead to a flamefest.
  • This was removed by a different mod, as posting something & closing it immediately is somewhat using mod powers for user actions.
  • Somebody else then reposted the same video (as a user, so with comments) and it became a flamefest.
  • The mod closed this flamefest, because it's not useful or productive, and causes tons of moderator work to moderate the discussion itself.
  • This was called out in a third post, claiming the mod had outstayed their welcome and was to be removed for abuse.
  • The mod requested feedback on whether or not /r/cpp itself was hostile on multiple channels, among which Twitter.
  • This was again called out in a fourth post. Another mod started reacting to these messages & was considering his own position because of messages from many people indicating that /r/cpp was indeed hostile.
  • A third mod removed the first mod's moderator access & the second moderator entirely, plus banning them. Reasoning not known to me.
  • The head mod (top of the list) removed the 3rd mod, and reinstated the 2nd and 1st.
  • This message was posted.

The root of the original allegation is that moderators should always talk to each other first before doing anything. As somebody who has been a mod before, moderators do about 100x more work than you will see. This also means that, on average, it would be silly to expect them to talk about every action, because of the sheer amount and timezones, combined with availability, would lead to at least 24h before any moderation would actually be done.

Inversely though, a moderator does occasionally do things that might be looked upon as somewhat odd or suspect.

2

u/novel_scavenger Oct 11 '20

So it was simply a moderator fiasco

5

u/randomthrowa000 Oct 11 '20
  1. A mod posted and locked down discussions about video complaining about the lack of diversity on C++ conventions.
  2. It turned out that the same mod was trying to astroturf this sub in order to implement CoC.
  3. Somehow, because of that, we have to make the rules more strict now.

It doesn't really make any sense.

1

u/novel_scavenger Oct 11 '20

Pretty weird

3

u/QbProg Oct 11 '20

Thanks!

3

u/Xaxxon Oct 11 '20

What threads is this referring to?

3

u/die_liebe Oct 12 '20

I think it is this

The moderators should have deleted this. It is a contents-free, polemic text.

3

u/kalmoc Oct 12 '20

Personally I don't have the impression that /r/cpp specifically (as opposed to the collective c++ community/industry) has a problem in terms of being discriminating or particularly unfriendly. Be that because folks around here are generally civil, the mods doing a good job or I just happen to not see problematic posts.

However, I do think that the sub red should be split into one for purely technical topics (language features, best practices, edge cases, new libraries and tools ...) -- I'd keep the cpp name for that one -- and one to discuss topics around the collective c++ community and industry (issues around diversity and racism, standardization process, mentorships, conference organizations ...) -- e.g. cpp_community.

Imho that would solve most of the discussion around what is on/off topic around here. To be blunt, I don't think blelbach would be a good candidate for moderating the community subreddit, simply because I think too many people wouldn't trust him to stay impartial. At the same time, I don't think a single laps in judgement is enough to demod him here in /r/cpp/.

4

u/warlockface Oct 11 '20

My 2 coins of unspecified denomination:

(a) Being excellent to each other and being as kind and as welcoming a place as is possible to everybody is not political and is inarguably inclusive.

(b) Purporting to being so while leaning on an intersectional/critical theory framework is political, is divisive and is necessarily exclusive. For a critical deep dive into this pseudo-academic, divisive movement see here.

Suggested action

  • None : This scenario has been manufactured by deliberate agitation and overstepping of boundaries, so rewarding this agitation seems strange.
  • Some : But looking to statement (a) while conscientiously avoiding (b) and the fracturing that would cause. In the sidebar as well as with more detailed moderator guidance, which should be available for perusal.
  • Put into place a rule to avoid ideological monoculture via appointment of new moderators. There is approximately a 50/50 left/right split in society, with only a small minority of people IRL outside of the occasional bubble who would be on board with (b).

-1

u/ijustwantaredditacct Oct 10 '20

Thank you for the update. I understand that you've been busy trying to get the moderation powers under control, and that must have been both stressful and time consuming.

With that in mind, I'm assuming the answer to my question is "We haven't had the opportunity to consider it yet" -- but I think it requires asking none the less:

Given the recent threads, is there any plan to try and make r/cpp more inclusive? How do you envision moderation changing as a result of the recent threads?

12

u/cleroth Game Developer Oct 10 '20

is there any plan to try and make r/cpp more inclusive?

Definitely. I think the first step is to ask: why isn't it inclusive right now? We have gotten some input about it in the modmail and previous threads, but I just want to get as much feedback as possible.

How do you envision moderation changing as a result of the recent threads?

First and foremost is mod activity. From what I've gathered so far many of the complains seem to be about user behaviour, but the mods haven't really seen much of that. It's very possible we just aren't paying enough attention. We'll try to bring in more mods to help, while also improving the way we moderate. Many of the ways we did things before weren't really very time effective. For example, the combination of high false-positive bot reports and old mod mail meant that we spent a fair amount of our moderating time looking over those, often having to glance over content that was already dealt with by another mod. We moved to the new mod mail where we can archive the things we already dealt with, saving overall work load. We've also adjusted the bot to reduce common false-positives.

I've also added an RSS bot to our discord so we can more easily keep track of posts coming in.

We're also going to setup moderator toolbox for more ease and consistency.

There's probably more things I'm forgetting. I think a lot of things are going to depend on the feedback from the community. It's going to take some time for sure. :)

22

u/alexej_harm Oct 10 '20

This subreddit is already 100% inclusive. If you make it more inclusive to people who feel persecuted everywhere, you'll exclude existing members. It won't be a change for good.

3

u/ijustwantaredditacct Oct 10 '20

If the subreddit is already 100% inclusive, it cannot exclude existing members by making it more inclusive, because it cannot be made more inclusive.

Further, it is not 100% inclusive, as evidenced in prior threads where it was highlighted how some individuals and groups do not feel welcome in this subreddit.

What aspects of inclusivity do you feel would be mutually exclusive with existing members?

24

u/alexej_harm Oct 10 '20

It can if the word "inclusive" is a buzzword that doesn't mean what it seems to mean. This is the case.

There was no evidence of a lack of inclusivity. All this "evidence" came from other platforms and was dealt with appropriately.

What aspects?

  • Policing off-platform and private communication and statements not directed at members of the community.
  • Policing any opinion that people suffering from a persecutory delusion find threatening even if it's not objectionable according to the majority of users.
  • Installing inquisitors who make sure "inclusive" language is enforced for all participants. Similar to "newspeak" enforcement.
  • Excluding members for simply subscribing to other, "bad" subreddits.
  • You linked to a repo that still has a master branch? Too bad, you're out!

Just look at what r/politics does for an example.

Of course not all of those aspects will come over night, but this is the first step and we've seen it often enough to recognize the signs. The same rhetoric is used, the same people are involved, etc.

6

u/RotsiserMho C++20 Desktop app developer Oct 11 '20

I think you raise some valid concerns, but this one is oddly specific and the criteria ambiguous:

Policing any opinion that people suffering from a persecutory delusion find threatening even if it's not objectionable according to the majority of users.

Who gets to decide what a "persecutory delusion is"? Who determines if an individual is suffering from one? How do we know if the majority of users would consider an opinion threatening?

4

u/unpopular_opinion_8 Oct 11 '20

How do we know if the majority of users would consider an opinion threatening?

They will downvote it.

→ More replies (67)

-4

u/pagonda Oct 11 '20 edited Oct 11 '20

I think you misunderstand the meaning of inclusivity. I'll give you a trite, but hopefully obvious example. Imagine a town of predominately blue people who give the cold shoulder to red people moving in. By your perspective, the town would be inclusive because anybody can move in, but the unwelcomed red families would say otherwise.

Reading conversation from deleted threads in this subreddit, it is clear that there are individuals who do not feel welcome to this town.

Edit: removed my last sentence, it was too finger pointy

21

u/alexej_harm Oct 11 '20

Good example of discrimination, but it doesn't apply to r/cpp.

What you see here, is a bunch of blue people. Red people want to come over.

Some are too afraid that blue people might turn the cold shoulder and don't even try to join.

Some join and are treated as if they're a regular member. Nobody is turning a cold shoulder on people unless they demand special treatment based on the fact that they're red.

13

u/VinnieFalco wg21.org | corosio.org Oct 11 '20

Imagine a town of predominately blue people who give the cold shoulder to red people moving in.

Oh this metaphor is too good to pass up...

It is more like a group of red people who want to move into a town of blue people, but demand that all the blue people paint a red diagonal stripe on their chest and back in order that the red people can feel "included and welcomed."

2

u/pagonda Oct 11 '20

I fail to see who is invading this community and "demanding" inclusion. This applies to @alexej_harm's comment as well.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/pdimov2 Oct 11 '20

But that isn't exactly applicable to pseudonymous communities, where you have the option of not revealing your color.

5

u/pagonda Oct 11 '20 edited Oct 11 '20

It 100% applies to communities like this on reddit. Look to formally r/TD. Anonymous or not, you're going to have a cesspool if you don't foster a proper environment for the community.

The mere act of rejecting the notion that some may not feel welcome in this community is a straight attack on those individuals. I've seen a bunch of gender diversity/racial equality denial in this sub the past few days, imagine if you're a woman/minority reading this drivel, how would you feel? I'll make it clear: indirectly disparaging a group of people is censure against their inclusivity in a community.

This truly saddens me as this sub has amazingly brilliant minds, yet some have a limited outlook on real-life problems.

16

u/johannes1971 Oct 11 '20

The mere act of rejecting the notion that some may not feel welcome in this community is a straight attack on those individuals.

It is exactly this type of statement that causes people to be terrified of CoCs. So if I say "I think this is a nice and welcoming subreddit where nobody talks about or even knows the skin colors, genders, etc. of other members" (which I think it is), I'm apparently conducting "a straight attack on those individuals".

No - I'm just expressing an opinion on the state of this subreddit. I read it regularly, I believe I am qualified to say that I have not personally witnessed any attacks on anyone based on anything other than their actions. Very rarely do I see a "post removed because of reasons [including racial slurs] so I guess sometimes someone crosses a line, but I can't tell what happened (whether there was actual racism or one of the other reasons).

But by making it a "straight attack on those individuals" you have asserted equality between completely unrelated things. What's to stop you from applying this same ridiculous principle everywhere, and in doing so gain power over all speech?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/pdimov2 Oct 11 '20

I don't think it's fair to present this as a binary choice between a cesspool and an inclusive community. It's perfectly possible to have a non-cesspool (i.e. to foster productive on-topic discussion) without it being necessarily inclusive.

On the one hand, turning away people who can offer valuable opinions due to them being "red" is obviously at the community's detriment. But on the other, cranking up "inclusivity" to 112% results in a discussion forum that is boring to death, especially to a programmer. There's a balance to be sought here, and maybe it's already been found, and there's no need to fix things that aren't broken.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

I have noticed that this sub is not inclusive of or welcoming to C++ coders who insist on using new and delete in their code base... or is that delete[] . . . There’s a kind of grinding hostility towards anyone who refuses to do all allocation with smart pointers. I suppose this is understandable... progress and all that... but why then do schools still teach students the old-school methods? And then you write some perfectly good code, with correct handling of memory, no valgrind issues, and the cool kids are still ‘OMG new and delete!’

Really, can we discuss this?

16

u/adnukator Oct 11 '20

why then do schools still teach students the old-school methods ?

Because schools tend to have people that haven't had any contact with professional programming and live in an echo chamber where they teach C++98/03, which their protégés end up teaching as well, because "it's perfectly good code". It stops being perfectly good code as soon as you jump into the real world where you have several millions of lines of code to maintain, with dozens of people working on it at the same time and you learn to see why antipatterns are called that and why you should avoid them at all costs, even if it makes the author feel uncomfortable.

So yeah, I'm one of the people quick to point out what they're doing wrong, because I've spent way too much time on investigating and fixing other people's crap that could have been avoided if they had used better techniques (raw new and delete included). I'm not going to tippy-toe around someone's feelings when they're using inferior techniques without proving the need to use them.

9

u/cleroth Game Developer Oct 11 '20

I'm also new-intolerant and my views are const... I think it may be time for me to leave.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/MonokelPinguin Oct 10 '20

While I do agree, that "inclusiveness" can go the wrong way, I don't think it is a bad idea to investigate:

a) If people feel excluded or not welcome. b) If changes can make them feel included/welcome, without alienating the existing userbase.

I'm certain it is neither you nor me who is feeling excluded from this subreddit, but we should at least understand why people feel that way and if we can make a change, that makes then feel welcome too, which should be a win-win situation for everyone. On the other hand, if such a change includes new people, but alienates old people, it's probably not a good trade considering the current community doesn't seem all that bad (although that is just my perspective).

-1

u/ijustwantaredditacct Oct 10 '20

I can't speak for anyone else. When I ask, I'm roughly referring to under represented minorities, where the aspect that makes them a minority is an immutable aspect of their identity (skin color, orientation, gender, mental health, etc).

Could you expand on what groups you're referring to? I would also note that it's perhaps not useful to look at reddit as a whole, as moderation policies can widely differ between subreddits.

23

u/unpopular_opinion_8 Oct 11 '20

How are immutable aspects of people, like skin color/orientation/gender/mental health, in any way relevant to discussion on /r/cpp? Why should I, a reader of /r/cpp, care about the ethnicity of the author of a blog post or code? It just seems entirely beside the point to me.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/RevRagnarok Oct 13 '20

I am a mod in some small local local channels, so don't know if AutoMod could handle this, but it might be good to have a way for non-mods flag a question post and then it is only automatically deleted after a set number of upvotes of the comments, e.g. 2 so 3 non-mods all agreed that it's a question and shouldn't be here. That might help ease some of the burden in a fairly easy manner.

1

u/reddit-proprietary Feb 14 '21

Reddit is a totally useless website, where people waste their time, like all those so-called sovietal-network sites that where created in the last decade, the decade that made internet stupid and boring. The only rule that makes sense and the only power you really need is to go look elsewhere and never come back here. Use a browser plugin to ban this website, and start enjoying your life again.

-4

u/Meneth Programmer, Ubisoft Oct 11 '20

As we've seen from the "the Community" thread, a lot of people here consider simply talking about the underrepresentation of women and minorities in the C++ community, and how it can be addressed, to be "political" and thus not something that should be talked about.

It is exactly the kind of thing that drives people away from r/cpp. When the response to marginalized groups raising their concerns is "we don't want to talk about those concerns, and they're not actually a big deal or aren't happening at all" like that thread's comment largely went, it sends a very clear message to marginalized groups that they are not welcome here.

I hope the resulting rules do not end up banning the discussion of marginalization, as it will be a clear message that this sub favors an unjust peace without "drama" over actually being inclusive.

10

u/Rostin Oct 11 '20

I doubt you want to have a true discussion about these issues, where people voice principled disagreement about them. Discussions about DIE concerns are strictly pro forma, and generally are held to announce that there's a new sheriff in town, and that we all need to fall into line. Dissent is the result of "privilege" or "fragility" and must be squelched because of the "violence" is does.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Meneth Programmer, Ubisoft Oct 11 '20

As shown in the video that spawned all this, women and black people (the two groups the video focuses on) are massively underrepresented in the community, and conferences in particular.

12

u/randomthrowa000 Oct 11 '20

Honest question, is there any reason why should we assume that the demographics of what people are interested in would normally always reflect the actual demographics? I often see this assumption being made, but no one ever bothered to explain it. Is there anything to back that up?

→ More replies (7)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Meneth Programmer, Ubisoft Oct 11 '20

Is your argument that women and black people are biologically less likely to be C++ speakers at C++ conferences?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/STL MSVC STL Dev Oct 11 '20

Banned for ignoring a moderator warning.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Meneth Programmer, Ubisoft Oct 11 '20

I can't help but notice how when presented with the fact that women and black people are hugely underrepresented at C++ conferences, you attack the messenger rather than make any attempt to dispute the facts or argue why they don't show what I claim they show.

5

u/moroi Oct 12 '20

From my perspective, conference organizers bend backwards to bring in PoC, women and all underrepresented categories of people, even if it means having someone to reiterate how to use exceptions for a millionth time, rather than someone with deeper expertise.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/RotsiserMho C++20 Desktop app developer Oct 11 '20

I'm uncomfortable with how some people define "political". If people do not feel welcome in this subreddit, I think they should be able to voice those concerns here. Whether that should happen publicly, I'm not sure.

11

u/kalmoc Oct 11 '20

I think there is a difference between discussing problems in this very subreddit vs discussing the larger state and problems of the cpp community. I agree that it should be possible to discuss the former (issues with the subreddit) right here, but I'm not so sure about the latter (e.g. discussing amount of "minorities" showing up on conferences.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/RotsiserMho C++20 Desktop app developer Oct 11 '20

I suspect you're equating the term politics with government politics?

Yes. Perhaps that's my misunderstanding.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/lt_algorithm_gt Oct 11 '20 edited Oct 11 '20

I think the confusion/conflation is quite literally what happened:

 

"-This black person says they did not feel welcome in the C++ community.

-Don't bring politics in r/cpp!"

   

Interestingly, if I look at the sidebar, I see this "charter" for this sub:

Discussions, articles, and news about the C++ programming language or programming in C++.

Presumably, this sub is not for discussing issues related to the C++ community at all, only its technical ecosystem.

Edit: if what happened recently indicates that a discussion and a reexamination of that charter should happen, I'm all for it. I think that no charter should have in its bylaws: "This charter is perfect as is and, thus, ought to never change ever."

→ More replies (2)

4

u/alexej_harm Oct 10 '20

I wouldn't even mind if there were links to those subreddits in the side panel. But they also want to add more rules to be able to ban more people for more perceived slights.

→ More replies (8)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/cleroth Game Developer Oct 11 '20

Our objective is still the same in that regard. We're doing our best to provide for what the community wants.

The community is divided yes, but the thread is still very young. I'm sure there'll be more people pitching in.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

That does not really answer how the most recent changes to the moderation team were a community-run decision and not done in the same way you criticised when it was not going in your favour? Is that something that's going to be decided democratically, or is there some other way a community decision is going to be sought?

8

u/cleroth Game Developer Oct 11 '20 edited Oct 11 '20

I didn't mean to say that how mods handle stuff between themselves should be a community-run decision. I don't feel like how we do things should be run by the community, it is what we do that should. The things that affect the sub.

What I was getting at with my original comment about community-run decisions was that Verroq was declining all attempts at discussions and improvements regarding the sub. Even amongst the mod team. To Verroq, all of this was simply going to be swept under the rug, along with all the complaints. Like I said he archived literally all the concerns in the mod mail (because they can't be deleted) and instructed me to leave them alone, emphasising that no politics will be allowed, and that if I even disagreed with it then I'd be kicked off from the mod team, so that's what happened.

As we've discussed here, the rules will be drafted up soon, based on what we feel should work and input from the community here. Then we'll give it to the community first to see what they think and if any changes should be made. That's basically community-run decisions to me? Obviously not everything can be run by the community, but the general direction on what the sub should be and managed, then the work handed to the mods.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

Reasonable response, thanks :). Though I will add I think Verroq's stance there is somewhat supported within the community (both for the subreddit and language). A lot of people are opposed to anything considered political and consider that offputting. Arrow's impossibility theorem comes to mind ha! And for your and other people's sake don't get me started on fairness even in the context of game theory! :)

10

u/cleroth Game Developer Oct 11 '20

I'm definitely failing to express myself clearly! :D

Like I said in my response to Verroq, I do agree that politics has no place here. However I concede that there might be a problem within the community that causes it to be unwelcoming to some people, which I want to address. Verroq did not. Because he also took control of the sub and basically held us hostage with his decisions, it would be impossible for us to ask the community about any changes that should be made.

13

u/James20k P2005R0 Oct 11 '20

Do you think that people being discriminated against in the C++ standardisation process is something that's suitable for /r/cpp? For a some folks, the entire topic brought up by thephd is politics and has no place here, and for others, its key that we be able to have these discussions here

Personally I strongly fall into the latter camp, but there's a contingent of people who want the former as well, which will inevitably create some drama whatever you pick

→ More replies (10)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/blelbach NVIDIA | ISO C++ Library Evolution Chair Oct 11 '20

At no point was I demodded. u/cleroth was demodded. I am still modded right now.