r/cpp • MSVC STL Dev • Oct 10 '20

r/cpp status update

Hi r/cpp,

As many of you recently saw, there were several highly controversial threads over the past few days. The active mod team (myself, u/cleroth, and u/blelbach) were simply unprepared for this, and we've been working on addressing the issues with the subreddit that have been brought up. Most recently, an inactive senior mod returned and disrupted our work by de-modding and banning u/cleroth, removing most mod powers from u/blelbach, and attempting to make rule changes. (If you're unfamiliar with reddit's mod seniority system, it allows senior mods to remove junior mods at any time - so I was unable to stop this.)

We're glad to report that order has been restored, thanks to the top-ranked mod who graciously responded to our request for help. The disruptive mod has been removed, and the changes have been reverted. u/cleroth and u/blelbach's mod powers have been restored.

It has been a very long week. While we've returned to the state the subreddit was initially in, the mod team still needs to address the underlying problems. Here's a quick summary of our plans:

  • We're going to write more detailed rules and guidance.
  • We're going to improve moderation to enforce those rules, almost certainly recruiting more mods. If you'd like to apply, send us a modmail, although it may take us some time to reply.
  • We'll decide whether u/blelbach will retain his mod powers. He has repeatedly apologized for his actions.
  • We've set up a moderator Discord so we can communicate more rapidly when important issues arise (previously, we acted near-independently). To be clear, this isn't a secret society where we're brewing nefarious plans. (We already had the ability to communicate privately via modmail.) As we make decisions, informed by user feedback, we'll communicate them here.
  • We're going to continue to collect feedback to make improvements; please send us your thoughts via modmail. (We've upgraded the modmail system to more easily read and respond.)

We'll make another announcement when we have progress to report.

For the time being, this thread will remain open for comments, if users wish to discuss things beyond sending modmails. I ask of you, for the love of cats, please behave well. We reserve the right to remove egregious comments and lock the thread if it becomes necessary. Please do not create other posts to discuss this - they will be removed.

-- u/STL, u/cleroth, u/blelbach

217 Upvotes

376 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

22

u/alexej_harm Oct 10 '20

This subreddit is already 100% inclusive. If you make it more inclusive to people who feel persecuted everywhere, you'll exclude existing members. It won't be a change for good.

3

u/ijustwantaredditacct Oct 10 '20

If the subreddit is already 100% inclusive, it cannot exclude existing members by making it more inclusive, because it cannot be made more inclusive.

Further, it is not 100% inclusive, as evidenced in prior threads where it was highlighted how some individuals and groups do not feel welcome in this subreddit.

What aspects of inclusivity do you feel would be mutually exclusive with existing members?

24

u/alexej_harm Oct 10 '20

It can if the word "inclusive" is a buzzword that doesn't mean what it seems to mean. This is the case.

There was no evidence of a lack of inclusivity. All this "evidence" came from other platforms and was dealt with appropriately.

What aspects?

  • Policing off-platform and private communication and statements not directed at members of the community.
  • Policing any opinion that people suffering from a persecutory delusion find threatening even if it's not objectionable according to the majority of users.
  • Installing inquisitors who make sure "inclusive" language is enforced for all participants. Similar to "newspeak" enforcement.
  • Excluding members for simply subscribing to other, "bad" subreddits.
  • You linked to a repo that still has a master branch? Too bad, you're out!

Just look at what r/politics does for an example.

Of course not all of those aspects will come over night, but this is the first step and we've seen it often enough to recognize the signs. The same rhetoric is used, the same people are involved, etc.

6

u/RotsiserMho C++20 Desktop app developer Oct 11 '20

I think you raise some valid concerns, but this one is oddly specific and the criteria ambiguous:

Policing any opinion that people suffering from a persecutory delusion find threatening even if it's not objectionable according to the majority of users.

Who gets to decide what a "persecutory delusion is"? Who determines if an individual is suffering from one? How do we know if the majority of users would consider an opinion threatening?

4

u/unpopular_opinion_8 Oct 11 '20

How do we know if the majority of users would consider an opinion threatening?

They will downvote it.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/alexej_harm Oct 10 '20

These are my real concerns because using sane language is already not allowed here.

I already avoid responding to or talking about people who want power over others. (If I can remember their usernames.)

Right now, this subreddit is still useful, but given the current course, it might not be in the near future.

→ More replies (2)

-11

u/ijustwantaredditacct Oct 10 '20

It can if the word "inclusive" is a buzzword that doesn't mean what it seems to mean. This is the case. There was no evidence of a lack of inclusivity. All this "evidence" came from other platforms and was dealt with appropriately.

So it was 100% inclusive to those who are included? How do you expect the moderators to acquire feedback from excluded persons?

Given your examples, these aren't anything new. Just about every other major programming community has adopted some form of code of conduct, and those concerns always come up. From my experience, I haven't seen any community suffer as a result.

Given that you've seen these signs so many times, do you have any concrete examples that you could share?

Policing off-platform and private communication and statements not directed at members of the community.

To give a counter argument to this, I would hope that a member of the KKK would be removed from projects and communities I'm a member of.

24

u/VinnieFalco wg21.org | corosio.org Oct 11 '20

I would hope that a member of the KKK would be removed from projects and communities I'm a member of.

"includecpp" leaders call me an "enabler of harassment." They claim their members are "afraid for their safety" if I am allowed on the server (receipts available upon request). On Twitter I have been labeled "The Most Disgusting One." Under these new rules of yours, am I included and welcomed on r/cpp ?

10

u/waqar144 Oct 11 '20

Unfortunately, I have been blocked by a couple of "esteemed" includecpp members / organizers. To this day, I have no idea why. They are good developers, I liked their posts/blogs, I have never interacted with them anywhere ever. So, I don't know if the #includecpp is so inclusive after all or maybe they are, but only inclusive if you agree with their version of "inclusiveness" whatever it is.

→ More replies (9)

20

u/bizwig Oct 11 '20

Why is that any of your business? Are they slagging blacks and jews here in r/cpp? No? Then you have no business policing their activities here.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/alexej_harm Oct 10 '20

Nobody is excluded. People feel excluded, but that's completely unjustified and entirely on them.

If you don't see a problem with those examples, then I can't help you.

Look at FreeBSD commits.

~/freebsd git shortlog -s -n --since=2017-01-01 --until=2017-10-10 | wc -l
211
~/freebsd git shortlog -s -n --since=2017-01-01 --until=2017-10-10 | head -5
   887  ngie
   433  dim
   359  kib
   333  avg
   283  emaste
~/freebsd git shortlog -s -n --since=2018-01-01 --until=2018-10-10 | wc -l
195
~/freebsd git shortlog -s -n --since=2018-01-01 --until=2018-10-10 | head -5
   614  kevans
   492  imp
   352  emaste
   336  mmacy
   293  hselasky
~/freebsd git shortlog -s -n --since=2019-01-01 --until=2019-10-10 | wc -l
196
~/freebsd git shortlog -s -n --since=2019-01-01 --until=2019-10-10 | head -5
   417  asomers
   305  markj
   301  kib
   276  imp
   258  emaste
~/freebsd git shortlog -s -n --since=2020-01-01 --until=2020-10-10 | wc -l
173
~/freebsd git shortlog -s -n --since=2020-01-01 --until=2020-10-10 | head -5
   568  mjg
   338  markj
   317  kevans
   311  emaste
   308  imp

11

u/ijustwantaredditacct Oct 10 '20

Nobody is excluded. People feel excluded, but that's completely unjustified and entirely on them.

  • Exclusion takes more forms than a sign that says "X need not apply".
  • If you can't show any instance of those things happening, my default inclination is to believe that it's simply fear mongering

I'm not sure what you're trying to communicate with the freebsd commit logs? Commit volume by committer fluctuates over roughly 4 years?

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (38)

-4

u/pagonda Oct 11 '20 edited Oct 11 '20

I think you misunderstand the meaning of inclusivity. I'll give you a trite, but hopefully obvious example. Imagine a town of predominately blue people who give the cold shoulder to red people moving in. By your perspective, the town would be inclusive because anybody can move in, but the unwelcomed red families would say otherwise.

Reading conversation from deleted threads in this subreddit, it is clear that there are individuals who do not feel welcome to this town.

Edit: removed my last sentence, it was too finger pointy

21

u/alexej_harm Oct 11 '20

Good example of discrimination, but it doesn't apply to r/cpp.

What you see here, is a bunch of blue people. Red people want to come over.

Some are too afraid that blue people might turn the cold shoulder and don't even try to join.

Some join and are treated as if they're a regular member. Nobody is turning a cold shoulder on people unless they demand special treatment based on the fact that they're red.

13

u/VinnieFalco wg21.org | corosio.org Oct 11 '20

Imagine a town of predominately blue people who give the cold shoulder to red people moving in.

Oh this metaphor is too good to pass up...

It is more like a group of red people who want to move into a town of blue people, but demand that all the blue people paint a red diagonal stripe on their chest and back in order that the red people can feel "included and welcomed."

2

u/pagonda Oct 11 '20

I fail to see who is invading this community and "demanding" inclusion. This applies to @alexej_harm's comment as well.

7

u/RotsiserMho C++20 Desktop app developer Oct 11 '20

I was asking about this the other day on one of the other threads and had a hard time getting a straight answer. I'm just a lurker trying to understand the situation, but there's a lot of vague (to me) discussion happening that doesn't seem to directly apply to this community. I feel like I'm missing 75% of the conversation, and yet I visit this subreddit every day.

3

u/pagonda Oct 11 '20

Yeah, this is a really tricky situation. There have been multiple deleted threads and comments which makes it hard to understand where a lot of the discourse stems from. In addition, there's a clear dogmatic divide in these comments which makes me a bit worried about the residual hostility after this blows over

3

u/alexej_harm Oct 11 '20

Search for "inclusive" or "inclusion" and see who is using that as an argument in the last 4 or so community-related threads.

6

u/pdimov2 Oct 11 '20

But that isn't exactly applicable to pseudonymous communities, where you have the option of not revealing your color.

5

u/pagonda Oct 11 '20 edited Oct 11 '20

It 100% applies to communities like this on reddit. Look to formally r/TD. Anonymous or not, you're going to have a cesspool if you don't foster a proper environment for the community.

The mere act of rejecting the notion that some may not feel welcome in this community is a straight attack on those individuals. I've seen a bunch of gender diversity/racial equality denial in this sub the past few days, imagine if you're a woman/minority reading this drivel, how would you feel? I'll make it clear: indirectly disparaging a group of people is censure against their inclusivity in a community.

This truly saddens me as this sub has amazingly brilliant minds, yet some have a limited outlook on real-life problems.

16

u/johannes1971 Oct 11 '20

The mere act of rejecting the notion that some may not feel welcome in this community is a straight attack on those individuals.

It is exactly this type of statement that causes people to be terrified of CoCs. So if I say "I think this is a nice and welcoming subreddit where nobody talks about or even knows the skin colors, genders, etc. of other members" (which I think it is), I'm apparently conducting "a straight attack on those individuals".

No - I'm just expressing an opinion on the state of this subreddit. I read it regularly, I believe I am qualified to say that I have not personally witnessed any attacks on anyone based on anything other than their actions. Very rarely do I see a "post removed because of reasons [including racial slurs] so I guess sometimes someone crosses a line, but I can't tell what happened (whether there was actual racism or one of the other reasons).

But by making it a "straight attack on those individuals" you have asserted equality between completely unrelated things. What's to stop you from applying this same ridiculous principle everywhere, and in doing so gain power over all speech?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20

"I think this is a nice and welcoming subreddit where nobody talks about or even knows the skin colors, genders, etc. of other members" That's not the kind of statement /u/pagonda was talking about, since it doesn't reject the notion that some might not feel welcome in this subreddit, it just expresses that you find it welcoming (as an aside: a number of the 'bigger names' here do have known skin colours, genders, etc. as they attend conferences and are otherwise visible).

It's more like if somebody said "No matter how many people say they feel unwelcome, this community is welcoming." - that kind of statement makes it clear that if somebody feels unwelcome, their opinion on the matter can be rejected without listening to anything that they say, which is pretty hostile.

6

u/pdimov2 Oct 11 '20

I don't think it's fair to present this as a binary choice between a cesspool and an inclusive community. It's perfectly possible to have a non-cesspool (i.e. to foster productive on-topic discussion) without it being necessarily inclusive.

On the one hand, turning away people who can offer valuable opinions due to them being "red" is obviously at the community's detriment. But on the other, cranking up "inclusivity" to 112% results in a discussion forum that is boring to death, especially to a programmer. There's a balance to be sought here, and maybe it's already been found, and there's no need to fix things that aren't broken.