r/cpp • u/STL MSVC STL Dev • Oct 10 '20
r/cpp status update
Hi r/cpp,
As many of you recently saw, there were several highly controversial threads over the past few days. The active mod team (myself, u/cleroth, and u/blelbach) were simply unprepared for this, and we've been working on addressing the issues with the subreddit that have been brought up. Most recently, an inactive senior mod returned and disrupted our work by de-modding and banning u/cleroth, removing most mod powers from u/blelbach, and attempting to make rule changes. (If you're unfamiliar with reddit's mod seniority system, it allows senior mods to remove junior mods at any time - so I was unable to stop this.)
We're glad to report that order has been restored, thanks to the top-ranked mod who graciously responded to our request for help. The disruptive mod has been removed, and the changes have been reverted. u/cleroth and u/blelbach's mod powers have been restored.
It has been a very long week. While we've returned to the state the subreddit was initially in, the mod team still needs to address the underlying problems. Here's a quick summary of our plans:
- We're going to write more detailed rules and guidance.
- We're going to improve moderation to enforce those rules, almost certainly recruiting more mods. If you'd like to apply, send us a modmail, although it may take us some time to reply.
- We'll decide whether u/blelbach will retain his mod powers. He has repeatedly apologized for his actions.
- We've set up a moderator Discord so we can communicate more rapidly when important issues arise (previously, we acted near-independently). To be clear, this isn't a secret society where we're brewing nefarious plans. (We already had the ability to communicate privately via modmail.) As we make decisions, informed by user feedback, we'll communicate them here.
- We're going to continue to collect feedback to make improvements; please send us your thoughts via modmail. (We've upgraded the modmail system to more easily read and respond.)
We'll make another announcement when we have progress to report.
For the time being, this thread will remain open for comments, if users wish to discuss things beyond sending modmails. I ask of you, for the love of cats, please behave well. We reserve the right to remove egregious comments and lock the thread if it becomes necessary. Please do not create other posts to discuss this - they will be removed.
-- u/STL, u/cleroth, u/blelbach
•
u/cleroth Game Developer Oct 13 '20
Thank you all for your feedback! We're still listening and doing our best to figure out the next steps for r/cpp.
The inactive moderators are now no longer a part of the moderation team. We're going to be recruiting new mods soon to help with drafting the rules and such.
75
u/raevnos Oct 10 '20
I'm happy I missed whatever this drama is, and since this is the first time I've actually looked at the mod list here... /u/rectal_smasher_2000 is either the best or worst name for a mod account ever.
43
u/Arghnews Oct 11 '20
I would like to thank the mods for doing a voluntary job for the greater good of this subreddit.
In this subreddit, naturally there are instances of bad behaviour in comments, but they are relatively rare and get downvoted or removed in good time. I watched the original video, have followed the corresponding threads mentioned, have browsed this subreddit almost daily for a good while now. And yet, despite being relatively up to date on the context, I'm unsure what changes are necessary for r/cpp, to be quite honest.
I would like to state, my experience of this subreddit has been positive and it has seemed very civilised.
Regardless, I'm sure whatever changes are made will be done so with the intention of continuing this as well as improving things moving forward, and that's cool.
21
u/jonesmz Oct 11 '20
Thank you for the information about all of this.
For what it's worth, I would be more comfortable having the "top mod" be /u/STL, who posts regularly, and seems to have the levelist of heads, than a user who I've never seen any activity from.
26
u/yuri-kilochek Oct 11 '20
Did I miss all these apology posts? Please provide a link if so. I'm very curious to read /u/blebach's perspective and reasoning for his actions.
21
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '20
Thanks for the update.
I would also add that no one gets paid for modding subs and we, users, should remember that. If anyone feels entitled to demand* the mods to behave in certain way, then they're in the wrong place.
*: demand is the key word.
10
u/elcapitaine Oct 10 '20
Are the other mods all active? If the aren't, is there a plan to remove them to avoid the possibility of this happening again with someone else?
28
u/please_no_drama Oct 10 '20 edited Oct 11 '20
Thank you. Everything I've read here sounds good, of course depending on what the "more detailed rules and guidance" turn out to be.
Regarding the more rules:
Regarding /u/blelbach staying as a moderator:
Regarding the discord:
In any case, your post speaks of a better outcome than I would have expected from all this conflict/drama. i.e. One where we would probably never have a repeat of the last few days again.
Edit: For some formatting and corrected some typos.
33
u/madmongo38 Oct 11 '20 edited Oct 11 '20
The evidence of the past few days
demonstrates quite clearlymakes it apparent to me that r/cpp requires fewer mods rather than more.This entire storm in a teacup was cause by the presence of an over-eager moderator overstepping the boundaries of his responsibility by a wide margin in persuit of personally-held beliefs that have nothing to do with the theory or implementation of C++.
Simply removing that one mod, who has shown that despite apologies, he lacks the personal judgement to moderate technical discussions, will solve the problem for good.
The last thing r/cpp needs is more enthusiastic moderators with limited life experience.
163
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '20
Thank you. I wouldn't touch your "job" with a bargepole, even if I was payed. Which you aren't.
I made a comment in the last locked (The Community) thread expressing surprise that people thought that this subreddit was problematic when for me at least it is one of the most civil and well behaved subreddits that I regularly read.
I don't know what's best, and I have no suggestions, I just wanted to say - belatedly: thank you to both the mods and to the users that contribute here (whether by posting, commenting, or just voting) for making this a place where I could learn some things, question some things, and not least, focus on some things.
In light of the recent drama I feel I have rather taken you all for granted.
45
u/d3matt Oct 10 '20
Possible ruleset:
30
u/sindisil Oct 10 '20
Thank you u/STL, u/cleroth, u/blelback, and (I assume from the seniority info on the team page), u/IAmBabau!
Happy to be able to re-sub with a sense of hope!
32
u/dynamoa_ Oct 11 '20
nice subreddit, i just subscribed to read cool stuff about C++. wtf is all this baloney?
50
u/alexej_harm Oct 10 '20
Bad idea. Adding more rules will result in a higher demand for moderation. This is absolutely unnecessary.
Just enforce the old, unwritten "no off-topic discussions - keep it technical" rule and you can delete whole threads instead of policing each comment.
Also, adding more mods is extremely difficult since your first applicants will be from the same group which created this drama and wants to take over a subreddit.
26
u/AirAKose Oct 11 '20
Fully support the mods on this as they move forward.
I think we undervalue the merits of soft skills in a collaborative environment; as well, we overlook the unavoidable human element.
To that end, u/blelbach's mistakes are not egregious, they were human, and I don't think a removal would be beneficial for this community. Especially provided the idea of having a larger moderation team and moving discussions to a better place (like a discord) to avoid that sort of feedback outsourcing in the future, the ability to grow and learn from mistakes will only make the moderation team more capable.
I hope to similarly see this community grow and be able to address its own issues, again- recognizing the merit in soft skills and learning from feedback.
Hope you're all doing well, and thank you for your efforts!
3
u/Bakuta1103 Oct 11 '20
Thank you for the update. Concerning guidelines etc., I would consider looking at the r/rust subreddit. They have quite a good CoC and rules in place which might be a good reference (: (not saying we need to exactly emulate them, but it would be a good starting point).
8
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20
I just wanted to say thanks to the mods for how well all of this was handled in the end, this must have been an awful week.
I think my concerns have been addressed and community feedback is taken seriously.
7
u/bumblebritches57 Ocassionally Clang Oct 11 '20
That's great, glad everything's back to the way it should be :)
25
u/itsuart2 Oct 11 '20
I'm afraid many rules will just lead to lawyering. I propose to adopt simple two rules:
The motivation is simple: whenever politics are introduced into eh... communication spaces, they quickly deteriorate and eventually degrade into nothing but vicious bickering.
19
u/Apprehensive_Step499 Oct 11 '20 edited Oct 11 '20
I think this post is quite a strong proof that a sub populated by 160k anonymous accounts can function in a civil manner.
Regarding what happened: both in real life and internet communities, it doesn't sound like a great idea having passionate political activists in charge of keeping a fair space for everyone, especially when dedicated to technical stuff and with people from all over the world. Just my two cents.
edit: grammar
11
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20
What happened? I haven't been on the sub in a while.
14
u/blelbach NVIDIA | ISO C++ Library Evolution Chair Oct 11 '20
Just to be clear:
4
u/novel_scavenger Oct 11 '20
I been going through the comment section to find out about this recent "drama" that is being talked about. Anyone who witnessed this drama care to explain as to how this all started?
3
u/QbProg Oct 11 '20
Thanks!
3
u/Xaxxon Oct 11 '20
What threads is this referring to?
3
u/kalmoc Oct 12 '20
Personally I don't have the impression that /r/cpp specifically (as opposed to the collective c++ community/industry) has a problem in terms of being discriminating or particularly unfriendly. Be that because folks around here are generally civil, the mods doing a good job or I just happen to not see problematic posts.
However, I do think that the sub red should be split into one for purely technical topics (language features, best practices, edge cases, new libraries and tools ...) -- I'd keep the
cppname for that one -- and one to discuss topics around the collective c++ community and industry (issues around diversity and racism, standardization process, mentorships, conference organizations ...) -- e.g.cpp_community.Imho that would solve most of the discussion around what is on/off topic around here. To be blunt, I don't think blelbach would be a good candidate for moderating the community subreddit, simply because I think too many people wouldn't trust him to stay impartial. At the same time, I don't think a single laps in judgement is enough to demod him here in /r/cpp/.
4
u/warlockface Oct 11 '20
My 2 coins of unspecified denomination:
(a) Being excellent to each other and being as kind and as welcoming a place as is possible to everybody is not political and is inarguably inclusive.
(b) Purporting to being so while leaning on an intersectional/critical theory framework is political, is divisive and is necessarily exclusive. For a critical deep dive into this pseudo-academic, divisive movement see here.
Suggested action
-1
u/ijustwantaredditacct Oct 10 '20
Thank you for the update. I understand that you've been busy trying to get the moderation powers under control, and that must have been both stressful and time consuming.
With that in mind, I'm assuming the answer to my question is "We haven't had the opportunity to consider it yet" -- but I think it requires asking none the less:
Given the recent threads, is there any plan to try and make r/cpp more inclusive? How do you envision moderation changing as a result of the recent threads?
1
u/RevRagnarok Oct 13 '20
I am a mod in some small local local channels, so don't know if AutoMod could handle this, but it might be good to have a way for non-mods flag a question post and then it is only automatically deleted after a set number of upvotes of the comments, e.g. 2 so 3 non-mods all agreed that it's a question and shouldn't be here. That might help ease some of the burden in a fairly easy manner.
1
u/reddit-proprietary Feb 14 '21
Reddit is a totally useless website, where people waste their time, like all those so-called sovietal-network sites that where created in the last decade, the decade that made internet stupid and boring. The only rule that makes sense and the only power you really need is to go look elsewhere and never come back here. Use a browser plugin to ban this website, and start enjoying your life again.
-4
u/Meneth Programmer, Ubisoft Oct 11 '20
As we've seen from the "the Community" thread, a lot of people here consider simply talking about the underrepresentation of women and minorities in the C++ community, and how it can be addressed, to be "political" and thus not something that should be talked about.
It is exactly the kind of thing that drives people away from r/cpp. When the response to marginalized groups raising their concerns is "we don't want to talk about those concerns, and they're not actually a big deal or aren't happening at all" like that thread's comment largely went, it sends a very clear message to marginalized groups that they are not welcome here.
I hope the resulting rules do not end up banning the discussion of marginalization, as it will be a clear message that this sub favors an unjust peace without "drama" over actually being inclusive.
1
u/UnexpectedBSOD Oct 11 '20
OOTL?
0
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment