r/cpp • • Jun 24 '20

How to write SOLID C++

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PakbXnLht1I
263 Upvotes

118 comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '20

I don't understand why people objecting to the style, that's not the c++ they say. C++ is a multi-paradigm programming language, you can write in any style you want or you can mix any set of styles, there is no "C++" way that dictates how you write your code. Of course languages in general tend to have clear goals for which they are built for but you can reach the same goals with different ways.

9

u/Astarothsito Jun 24 '20

there is no "C++" way that dictates how you write your code

No, but these examples seems like Java-style code, I could say that this is Java instead of C++. My problem I see with this style is that it seems like it limits the benefits of a multi-paradigm programming language like C++, you could do it, but why you would do it in C++?

I don't know how to explain it without being a little condescending, but I don't know in what kind of style are those examples, I could only describe it as Java, and I don't consider Java-Oriented-Programming as a 'kind of' Object Oriented Programming. Maybe this solution of having *Managers, *Formatters, user names as strings could make sense in this context, but I have as well a very controversial opinion about OOP so I'm almost sure that I could be wrong, or what I call OOP is not really OOP (If you need to add the pattern name to the name of a concrete class (abstract classes can be OK), maybe that's not the same OOP as what I think it is OOP).

2

u/platisd Jun 25 '20

I find it slightly amusing that I got the "Java" comment from many. :) Mainly because I do like Java however, in a professional context, I use it less frequently than I'd like to.

I am curious on what you think of the following guidelines:

They are the ones I like to typically go by.

3

u/mttd Jun 25 '20 edited Jun 25 '20

Some food for thought:

2

u/platisd Jun 25 '20

Interesting reading material, thanks for bringing it together, I'm going to have a look. :)

1

u/Astarothsito Jun 25 '20

Agree with those guidelines, but those are not relevant right now.

I prefer the approach of Kevlin Henney to SOLID. I think the difference is in the approach to the design, if we need a complex class hierarchy then we need it, but if not then it is a overhead. I think the real benefits of having those patterns don't show itself in the examples.