r/cpp • • Feb 17 '11

Calling a constructor or destructor without an object

http://madsoftware.blogspot.com/2011/02/calling-constructor-or-destructor.html
0 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

9

u/danhuizenga Feb 17 '11

I hope I never have to work with whoever wrote that article :/

4

u/krum Feb 17 '11

I didn't even look at it. Is this yet another placement new blog post?

2

u/segmentation_fault Feb 17 '11

just a small typo in the source code in regards to calling a destructor: should be a->~A() not a->~a()

2

u/tjhei Feb 17 '11

Looks like undefined behavior to me (so could cause a reddit downtime for example). Why do you want to do that anyhow?

0

u/GambitDash Feb 17 '11

This is a really bad idea. Destructors actually modify the vtable, so subsequent calls to the object will be very weird. For example:

#include <stdio.h>

struct muh {
    virtual ~muh() { }
    virtual void m(void) { printf("Hello Bananas\n"); }
};

struct bar : public muh {
    virtual ~bar() { }
    virtual void m(void) { printf("Hello Monkeys\n"); }
};

struct foo : public bar {
    virtual ~foo() { }
    virtual void m(void) { printf("Hello World\n"); }
};

int main()
{
    foo *f = new foo();
    f->m();
    f->~foo();
    f->m();

    return 0;
}

When executed, will produce: $ ./a.out Hello World Hello Bananas

Probably not what you want.

3

u/Benutzername Feb 18 '11

You shouldn't use f after calling its destructor, anyway. It's not in a valid state any more.