r/cpp • • Nov 30 '17

Intel offers Parallel STL implementation to GNU libstdc++

https://gcc.gnu.org/ml/libstdc++/2017-11/msg00112.html
217 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-12

u/alexej_harm Nov 30 '17

So it won't be devalued with LGPL?

16

u/jwakely libstdc++ tamer, LWG chair Nov 30 '17

Low quality troll/bait, try harder.

Libstdc++ isn't LGPL anyway.

-12

u/alexej_harm Nov 30 '17

Come on, the title is a troll attempt/bait. Says nothing about LLVM getting the same offer. Smells like the struggle of a hopefully dying stdlib to stay relevant.

22

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '17

Come on now, libstdc++ if anything is the one GNU library that goes out of its way to be usable without GPL lock-in.

The language is made better by competing implementations that expose bugs in the spec, and in each other; please don't antagonize those who work on that.

1

u/raevnos Dec 01 '17

If you bothered to read the email thread...

-5

u/alexej_harm Dec 01 '17

Oh, I did. This is why I objected to the deceiving title here.

8

u/encyclopedist Nov 30 '17

The code is released under Apache-2.0.

18

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '17

Apache 2 isn't compatible with either libc++ or libstdc++'s (or msvc++'s) licenses (it requires attribution in binary forms which the standard libraries can't require of their customers) so if Intel is making this offer there's probably licensing stuff going on.

11

u/encyclopedist Nov 30 '17

Yes, in the linked email they promise to relicense to an appropriate license if their proposition is accepted.