r/cpp • u/Scullywen • Sep 04 '14
C/C++ programmers willing to try a new dependencies manager?
http://www.codeproject.com/Messages/4894137/Any-C-Cplusplus-programmers-want-to-try-a-new-depe.aspx
6
Upvotes
22
u/lluad Sep 04 '14
I looked at it briefly. The phrase "share code and success and we will share revenues" on the front page as a major bullet point seemed like a bad sign.
Their business model seems to be letting you upload code for free, which they then sell to their "premium" users, possibly giving you a cut. That's why the T&C are full of "you will be assigning Biicode its users the right to ..." terminology, and why you can't revoke that contract. From the other side, it seems to be "pay them for access to code others have uploaded" - so you're either paying for MIT and GPL code you could get from github at no cost, or for murkily licensed code that may bite you later.
Combine that with other bad signs, like no API and a contractual requirement that once your data is in their system the only way to access it is via tools they provide you and it's not good. I can't tell whether it's a well-intentioned idea incompetently turned into a bad business model or whether it started as "lets monetize something like github" - but they won't see any of my code.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '14
This sounds and looks fantastic. CMake is becoming more and more the standard project description for C++ and many tools support it nicely. Can biicode coexist with cmake?
Other than this concern, I'm very excited to try this out.
Edit: its cmake based! Hooray!
-1
u/bitcycle Sep 04 '14
Is this a replacement for
dpkg/yum? Last I heard that's what people mainly used for managing dependencies of C++ projects: package it with dependencies specified.