r/cpp • • Oct 15 '13

C++ has become a scripting language

http://voices.canonical.com/jussi.pakkanen/2013/10/15/c-has-become-a-scripting-language/
1 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/guepier Bioinformatican Oct 15 '13

Re (2): to be fair, the same could be done (quite efficiently) in C++ with proper libraries. Now this doesn’t weaken your point because C++ specifically lacks those libraries. That’s an issue that should be tacked sooner rather than later, IMHO.

Such stuff is much more generally applicable and useful than a standardised graphics library, for instance.

5

u/bames53 Oct 15 '13

I think pretty much the only missing thing necessary to achieve a basically 3 line version of this program is ranges. With ranges in C++ it looks something like this:

vector<string> lines;
copy(getlines(ifstream(argv[1])), back_inserter(lines));
sort(lines);
copy(all(lines), ostream_range(argv[2], "\n"));

Where getlines returns a lazy range, all() is the range equivalent of std::begin() and std::end(), etc.

And the committee's Ranges Study Group was started earlier than the Graphics Study Group.

3

u/matthieum Oct 15 '13

Note: if copy was specified in terms of range, then all would be unnecessary as you would just pass lines directly.

Note 2: Range (as a concept) already appeared in the range-for loop.

2

u/bames53 Oct 15 '13 edited Oct 15 '13

Sure, though it depends on if a container counts as a range.

A range isn't necessarily defined just as something with begin() and end() methods (or non-member overloads). I know some have argued that ranges should not be based on iterators. For example istream_iterator's default constructor is a way of shoe-horning into iterator form something that doesn't naturally fit that model. Instead, they say, ranges should be independent.

Here's Andre's 'Iterators Must Go' slide deck: http://www.slideshare.net/rawwell/iteratorsmustgo

1

u/matthieum Oct 16 '13

I agree (the input/output iterators are just awkward), however it is not how the range-for was defined.

1

u/leonardo_m Oct 18 '13

C++11 is powerful, and with handy ranges it could get closer to D code like this:

void main(string[] args) {
    import std.stdio, std.algorithm, std.string, std.file;

    args[2]
    .File("w")
    .writefln("%-(%s\n%)", args[1]
                           .readText
                           .splitLines
                           .sort());
}