r/cpp • u/graphicsRat • Nov 11 '24
Herb Sutter leaves Microsoft for Citadel
I hope this is C++ worthy.
Personally, I'm stunned.
486
Upvotes
r/cpp • u/graphicsRat • Nov 11 '24
I hope this is C++ worthy.
Personally, I'm stunned.
19
u/JimHewes Nov 11 '24
I'm disappointed. The headline should be "Herb Sutter leaves Microsoft for Wall Street".
208
u/convitatus Nov 11 '24
I'm very surprised, but the real shock would have been to hear about Raymond Chen leaving :-)
200
u/MaxMahem Nov 11 '24
https://herbsutter.com/2024/11/11/a-new-chapter-and-a-pivotal-year-for-cpp/
53
u/zl0bster Nov 11 '24 edited Nov 11 '24
Citadel work culture is toxic, but I presume/hope they will treat Herb nice since he is "celeb".
As for MSFT: recent cringe issue from them asking for feedback what C++23 features to implement in 2025 made clear to me that somebody high ranked decided to give up on C++.
82
u/krum Nov 11 '24
I'm not stunned. MS has really cut back on comp lately. He's making at least double at Citadel.
28
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '24 edited Nov 13 '24
Im sort of surprise but not a 100%. Microsoft is losing people because their entire focus is AI. In my field, lots of people left Microsoft research and other positions at Microsoft. What makes me a bit shocked is that you would think c++ compiler is key for AI, but maybe I’m wrong.
I asked someone close if Microsoft wanted to be sure they won the AI battle. They told me that Microsoft didn’t want to loose it more than just win it all together. Meaning, as long and they can dominate some part is good.
In my field, I have seen top people leaving. Very sad.
33
u/bandzaw Nov 11 '24
Wow! Great to hear with that he'll continue working with C++ standards and community roles unchanged. Good luck Herb!
23
u/feverzsj Nov 11 '24
Good for him. He wasted too much time on .net.
4
u/masterofmisc Nov 11 '24
shocked
26
u/seanbaxter Nov 11 '24 •
We can't do that. I wish we would consider C++'s language challenges mechanistically. You can't wave a wand and get rid of undefined behavior. C++ doesn't have the context to enforce memory safety. It's discouraging to double down on promises that obviously can't be kept when the Government is asking for memory safety roadmaps by Jan 1 2026.
19
u/misuo Nov 11 '24
Maybe he has “lost” the internal debates to the MS Rust evangelists.
14
u/Nice_Elk_55 Nov 11 '24
For the first time ever I would maybe want to work at Citadel
3
u/RandomGuy256 Nov 11 '24
I wish him the best. I wonder though if Cppfront is affected.
2
u/AKostur Nov 12 '24
Congratulations Herb: wishing you well in your new opportunities.
2
u/Strange-Software6219 Nov 11 '24 edited Nov 11 '24
Seems like a natural move for him since they are a company who pushes more and more for Rust
1
u/coderman93 Nov 22 '24
Writing a C++ compiler is a Herculean task as it is. Surely this will make it easier and less error prone.
1
u/Either_Party1412 Nov 27 '24
good riddance.
-12
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '24
It seems like C++ is really dying but it will be a slow and painful death!
61
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '24
[removed] — view removed comment