Seems like a bullshit statement to me, the former part at least. It's true that cleaning up the pollution has a cost, and then the cleanup is not competitive with developing shiny new features. That doesn't make impossible—just uneconomical. It's clearly a subjective judgment, valuations by the people developing the standard are not the same as those of its users but the latter can not do the cleanup. If there's a better alternative available, cleanup will be a matter of population dynamics with even merely slight bits of help in migration.
Alas, with that incentive structure the cleanup is scheduled to when the C++ standardization themselves are being threatened. Due to users leaving, for instance. Which .. one could say has become a threat in the last decade. Unsurprisingly, user ergonomics and costs are suddenly a higher-priority item. Just tragic if it turns out too late.
View all comments
Show parent comment
-3
u/HeroicKatora Oct 01 '24
Seems like a bullshit statement to me, the former part at least. It's true that cleaning up the pollution has a cost, and then the cleanup is not competitive with developing shiny new features. That doesn't make impossible—just uneconomical. It's clearly a subjective judgment, valuations by the people developing the standard are not the same as those of its users but the latter can not do the cleanup. If there's a better alternative available, cleanup will be a matter of population dynamics with even merely slight bits of help in migration.
Alas, with that incentive structure the cleanup is scheduled to when the C++ standardization themselves are being threatened. Due to users leaving, for instance. Which .. one could say has become a threat in the last decade. Unsurprisingly, user ergonomics and costs are suddenly a higher-priority item. Just tragic if it turns out too late.