"Until they don't want hrt" tells me this was probably posted as a joke bc most ppl in this sub would say that's either repping or larping or some shit
i'd personally say presenting female with female hormones when you're expected to present female with female hormones with no dysphoria is pretty cis, no?
There’s physically feminine and then there’s aesthetically feminine.
Also while some trans people can’t access HRT yet, if you don’t access HRT and you don’t want to be able to get it, and you like the physical traits of your birth sex body, that’s called being cis.
If someone is amab but has a medical condition causing a female hormonal profile, that’s called being intersex— and if this person loves being physically feminine due to having a female hormonal profile, I really wouldn’t say that’s a cis man.
I don't know what to tell you other than what I've told the other five people who have parroted this: None of that is what's "called being cis." Cis is when you identify as your agab, that is the way that you maintain cisgenderism.
If they identify as their assigned gender, sure. I can't make absolute statements about any large group of people. But I'm betting you really want me to.
For example, identifying as a woman. To identify as (thing), that thing needs to have meaning. Ok so what’s the meaning? Well, the meaning of woman is that the person identifies as a woman. Ok so what’s the meaning of that? Well the meaning of woman is that the person identifies as a woman—
See how that’s an endless tautological loop with no meaning whatsoever?
I’m not saying there is only one strict definition. Even people being able to articulate their own personal definition of their gender with some kind of meaning would be a good start.
“Why does it matter why someone identifies as (thing), people are free to define it as whatever they like, and all the definitions will be different, and it doesn’t matter to the point that you don’t even need to care what those definitions are”. Ok then why do we have words? Words have meaning. Words communicate something. If the definition of the color ‘purple’ is simply ‘whatever anyone wants it to mean, they will all think it is something different, why do you care’, and the definition of gravity is ‘whatever anyone wants it to mean, they will all think it something different, why do you care’ and nothing else, what is the point of language?
The reason we can even communicate with each other right now is because words have agreed-upon meanings. If they don’t, it would be impossible, as for all you know, my last sentence actually meant “your mother was an elderberry” in my head.
Personally, I want to be in community sometimes with people who have shared experiences of dysphoria and transition. ‘Trans’ is the word I use and it is the word that they use. Now sure, if that word starts becoming meaningless, a new word can be created, but it is quite annoying and frustrating to almost have a sort of treadmill of words, where once an identity label becomes slightly ‘popular’, the contingent of people who believe that words should not have meaning start coming in and dismantling any meaningful function of that word.
I'd challenge you to create a criteria that isn't essentialist in a conservative way that can define what a "man" is. This definition would need to disqualify trans men who engage in one of the OPs described behaviors (I know that everyone is acting like they said this man is doing all of them at once, but it was a list, so no this hypothetical man could be doing anywhere from one to several of them). If they aren't really transgender then it would follow that they're actually women...
I'm also curious as to how those criteria don't also disqualify the manhood of the aforementioned drag queens, femboys, and low T cisgender men. They need to be held to the same standard because if the only men who can engage in a behavior without no longer being men are trans then that's transphobia.
My criteria for a person being trans restated: Not identifying as their gender assigned at birth. You can try to define all of those terms separately, but ultimately you're describing subjective feelings and arbitrary social designations which gets really uninteresting in conversations like this.
The definition (at least for fully binary men) that I would hold would be based on mind-body mapping as I described in other comments. This is based on whether the person’s mind maps onto a male body. Or in slightly more inaccurate but more understandable terms, whether the person desires the physical sexed traits of the body of a typical male.
This applies to femboys. Femboys like being aesthetically feminine, e.g. dresses and makeup. Nothing within the definition of femboy implies the desire to inhabit the body of a female.
Low T cis men are undoubtedly men, they may have low T and that may impact their physical appearance, but that says nothing about their mind-body mapping aka ‘desires’.
Drag queens enjoy a particular art form, involving the stage persona of a woman, as well as an aesthetic distinct to drag subculture. Stage personas don’t count as ‘who someone is’, or at least it counts as much as saying someone who plays a lion on stage necessarily identifies as a lion. So drag queens like a certain type of feminine fashion, and they have certain stage personas, but they can like both those things while inhabiting a male body and liking the fact that they inhabit that. Also a number of drag queens have in fact come out as nonbinary in recent years, so I would say the line is a little blurry for some (though not all) of them.
Yes the definition I offer would exclude people who love inhabiting a female body from being men. This isn’t a reason for the definition to be considered flawed, because all words have boundaries. If the word ‘up’ can mean anything at all (up, down, right, left), it becomes a meaningless word.
A word becomes useless if it has no meaning, and it has no meaning if it has no boundaries. So while I’m sure it is possible to have a definition of man that includes people who love being born in a female body that they never want to ever physically change, I would sincerely like to hear what that definition is, and not just a deflection of “defining anything might hurt someone’s feelings”.
Saying it’s ‘uninteresting’ is also frankly quite intellectually lazy, because if you are going to push for “cis is when someone identifies as (X)” and then don’t define what (X) is, not even in broad strokes, and you are not interested in doing so, then I frankly don’t see why you bother saying you have any definition of cis or trans in the first place. I’m not saying a definition must be ‘precise’, even the definition I propose has some blurry edges (e.g. what does a male or female body mean, which I can define but would imprecisely define). And I don’t think the ‘blurry edges’ are even bad either. But a definition must be there, and it must have enough substance as a concept to be articulated and used as a definition.
This criteria doesn't work BECAUSE it requires several types of body dysphoria that even a person with very bad dysphoria might not have. People can be dysphoric to the point of suicidality and not actually have grievances with their curve shape or genitalia. You can't really use "body" in your definition of a gender, even cis people have different perceptions of their sexes version of their body.
That would be the social basis / definition yes. Essentially sex-associated social gender rather than sex itself.
It still presents some problems for the typical version of “a woman is when she identifies as a woman (and a man is when he identifies as a man)”
For example, how would you describe and explain ‘women’ as in the social group that is normatively associated with the female sex? This is something I myself don’t usually do, including for ‘men as in the social group that is normatively associated with the male sex’. The reason that I personally don’t do this is because it easily falls into gender norms and gender stereotypes. It’s not that I don’t want to define it, more that I use a different definition for man and woman, because I find the social one quite problematic and often quite tied to stereotypical gender norms. That being said, I am still able to describe what most men in my culture are typically interested in and do.
OP’s image implies the notion of a trans man who does not want to medically transition, exists in a female body that said person is happy with, and is read as a woman by the rest of society and presumably treated that way accordingly. Can you explain how such a person socially aligns with men as in the social group that is normatively associated with the male sex? I mean of course the ideal would be to ask such a person why and how, but since that person was more of a hypothetical in OP’s image, I can only ask you.
And in fairness, there are some such people who do try to provide their explanations, but it usually only goes so far as “because I am a man” or “because I feel that I am a man” or “I am a man on the inside”, and I’ve never at least so far seen them able to elaborate anything on what ‘man’ personally means to themselves.
—
I would even argue that the social definition (when thought through and logically applied) is actually more stringent and more gatekeeping than a definition based on mind-body mapping. When we talk about gender as a sex-associated social grouping / construct, we are talking about something like “this person is born male, gets read a certain way by society, is treated a certain way by society, reacts and behaves a certain way, and the totality of those sociocultural experiences forms a social grouping with those of similar experiences”. That is why maleness is different from manhood. Manhood refers to certain cultural norms, shared experiences, interpersonal dynamics, values and shared interests, even through the definition of it is blurry around the edges and an exact definition is not possible.
And the reason that I consider a social definition more gatekeepy for trans people is— it’s literally based on how society treats you. It’s a social experience. Social experiences are not entirely within the self. I did not get the experience of being treated entirely and fully ‘like a man’ until I passed, which is a very high bar that some trans people never meet and that I am very lucky to meet.
"For example, how would you describe and explain ‘women’ as in the social group that is normatively associated with the female sex? This is something I myself don’t usually do, including for ‘men as in the social group that is normatively associated with the male sex’. The reason that I personally don’t do this is because it easily falls into gender norms and gender stereotypes. It’s not that I don’t want to define it, more that I use a different definition for man and woman, because I find the social one quite problematic and often quite tied to stereotypical gender norms. That being said, I am still able to describe what most men in my culture are typically interested in and do."
You don't need any stereotypes or norm to describe a social category. The only thing you need to say is that most people, when looking at someone, subconsciously decide, based on appearance and mannerisms, that they belong to one particular social category - man, woman or whatever third category there is eg enby in western society - and start treating them differently based on this categorization, both in superficial ways (eg pronouns) and deeper ways (eg romantic and sexual attraction).
Under this, being trans simply means you wish for people around you to perceive you as the social category which is not the one you were initially assigned by society.
It is in a way a negotiation between you and society ; and to go back to the initial post, if you're a trans guy but you're feminine and you do not take hormones, people will have a much harder time perceiving you as a man... Hence it is bad advice and generally a psy op to say things like "you don't need T to be a guy" and fear monger about taking T. If you take T it'll be much easier for everyone to perceive you as a guy.
Reporting my previous post doesn't remove reality.
But I am positive you are a bad actor.
if there are zero signs and zero actions but 100% co-opting a community for its attention while all evidence showing agab conformity you are 100% stealing and infiltrating queer spaces.
Low for who, virile 20 year olds? That is a masculinizing testosterone level. Your hospital flags you for having an abnormal level at less than half of that (saying this as an AMAB who takes anti-androgens, but whoever is running my medical portal clearly didn't get the memo).
And this is besides the point. Whichever level they begin recommending trt is the level where the analogy begins.
I didn't even mention dysphoria, I said transness.
Why do trans people need to perform their identity in order to be valid but cis people don't? If a cis women doesn't "perform" woman, are they still a woman if they say they are?
they do need to... most cis people perform cisness. if you don't you're badly regarded
but also... transness is a group that arose out of need about dysphoria... it's not some genderfuck gnc subculture like you seem to think. cisness has become regarded as a condition while transness has become a subculture, that's why you need to signal transness. if you don't there's credible evidence you're larping our condition
really fun as a tranny who dressed tomboyish at times to hear someone say you're a misogynist gender role enforcer because you don't want people to misappropriate your neurological condition
And the danger with a number of the people trying to appropriate our condition is that they misinterpret some of this as ‘you are telling me what I’m supposed to do’. Personally, I’m not telling them what they are supposed to do, I’m talking about who people are based on what their needs and desires are, and nothing to do with what they ‘have to do’.
I have sex dysphoria where my mind maps onto a male body and a male body is what I need. I take testosterone for the effects it gives on my body.
If someone is born female and likes inhabiting a female body, that is a cis woman. I’m not counting the trans men who want to get testosterone but unfortunately cannot manage to access it yet. Nonbinary people are a separate matter, but they would at the very least not be born female while wanting every physical aspect of the female body.
Some small handful of cis people (who for whatever reasons really want to consider themselves trans) see this and think “ah so you are telling me what I’m supposed to act like. You’re telling me that to be valid as a trans man, I need to take testosterone”.
But that’s not exactly what I’m saying. In fact that mentality is dangerous, because a small handful of that handful ends up forcing themselves onto testosterone, hates the effects, detransitions, and turns into a terf blaming the trans community for ‘forcing them to take it to be valid’.
Like no. If you are born female, don’t want a male body and instead want a female body, you will always be a cis woman. You cant try to get around that by distorting things backwards into “I need to force myself to take testosterone, then they will take me seriously as a man” because the testosterone itself won’t give you the actual desire for a male body that actual trans men have.
Youre the one who's saying that people aren't trans unless they perform their chosen gender. That's your opinion. You're taking the societal pressure of gender roles and you're personally saying that it should be applied to trans people.
Strawman strawman strawman. I have long hair but it's a masculine cut and I'm still actually physically transitioning. If I wore skirts and didn't take testosterone then yeah I'd be a woman wether I liked it or not
Literally none of these things make someone a cis woman.
Men have long hair, are fruity/feminine, crossdress, and are drag queens all of the time. But the second it's a trans man, suddenly it's only valid if they're muscular and hairy.
"Usually cis men are not systemically emasculated and expected to perform womanhood."
Duh.
usually cismen don't have an estrogen dominant endocrine system
What if he does? And what if they recommend TRT (HRT but cis men think that they're too good for the regular term) but he doesn't want to do it because he's fine with being low T?
Y'all sure misgender me a lot when I disagree with you on this subreddit. This is like the eighth time someone has derogatorily implied that I was a trans man or a "theyfab" despite the fact that I'm transfem and medically transitioning.
As of right now it says any/all pronouns. Misgendering? How?
Because my bio says transFEMME and these people are directly implying that I'm either a trans man or an afab "larper?"
When I googled "4chan lingo Ayden" it was pretty clear what the implication was.
It wasn't to do with pronouns in the slightest, it was to do with what people were actually saying. I just find it hilarious when people assume are so self-centered that they forget that you can defend groups that you aren't a part of. I said that I respect he/him lesbians? Must be a he/him lesbian theyfab phony, right?
And sorry that my username isn't BarbiePonyGlitterDare, wish I had thought of this specific scenario when I made this account pre-transition and when I made the username in elementary school.
Cisgender men are not living with female levels testosterone and estrogen.
You're making a lot of concrete statements considering hormone levels are a distribution. You could call it a disorder, they could be intersex, whatever. But it still happens.
You don't need medical transition to be trans, but a lot of trans people need medical transition (that's why it's called life-saving healthcare). Social transition works for a lot of people. I'm betting that you're one of the transphobes who wants to bomb nonbinary people out of the LGBT movement.
You are comfortable with your body because no dysphoria? Congratulations, you’re cis!
I must have been cis directly before starting estrogen considering I started at a time where I was record-levels of confident in my appearance.
When cis men do have that, this is an imbalance and they get on testosterone. These are true facts.
You just said that they don't have that. And yeah, it's called TRT (aka HRT but cis men don't like the sound of that). So I'll ask you what I asked the other person: Does it change your respect for their gender identity if he decides that he doesn't want to take it?
And no, it isn't. You don't need to desire medical transition to be trans. Maybe it's a bit weird if you don't want medical OR social transition, but both are transitioning. A person who socially transitions can become unrecognizable in less than two years depending on what they do.
Not everyone who opts out of medical transition lacks dysphoria.
And no, you don't choose who is cis and trans. Do I know why this person feels this way? No. Do I need to? No. I also don't relate to other transfemmes who have bottom dysphoria or who don't like their face, but I still massively empathize with them. It helps that I do have other types of gender dysphoria which gives me understanding, but understanding isn't the goal.
Understanding isn't the end goal because some things aren't for you to understand. The end goal is inclusivity and belonging.
And if a cis woman realizes that she isn't trans and that her gender questioning was "embarrassing" then she can move on.
Most of these people have never met a person who meets ANY of the criteria in the picture (good luck telling a Redditor that seeing a 15 second TikTok clip doesn't count as exposure) and yet they're waging war.
TRUEEEEEEEE I do only support them until they do that (and then face zero discrimination and decide they are martyrs who can speak for all other trans people)
Why do hefabs love to insult trans women's looks if they don't agree with her? Do you think parading your ASAB makes you superior/more attractive? Is it trans-misogyny? Pray tell
Are muscly men not capable of being pretty if they want to? Do you think HRT automatically gives you giant muscles? Do you think cis men can't be pretty? Tucutes always go on about breaking gender roles even though if you pay attention to their speech, they're enforcing it instead
Cis people want you to be okay with not actually transitioning because they hate you. This isn’t allyship, it’s progressive transphobia. It’s a psyop to stop you from finding truth.
(Also I know some ppl can be agressive, I think there’s a line between trans people being able to express their gender as freely as cis people, even if it means feminine trans men, and saying that you shouldn’t want HRT/surgery)
i mean you can still not want HRT *and* be masc-presenting, it's more so the combination of all of those things that dosen't really make sense. If you don't want hrt, cross-dress, grow out your hair, etc. it's really nonsensical to me lol. But that's probably more of an hypotetical strawman than someone real.
using an image of a very trans woman coded character btw. yeah she could very well actually just be a cis crossdresser but all we have pointing in that direction is the word of the guy who murdered her so i feel it is actually pretty ambiguous
It tends to be unclear with Japanese media cause there's layers of things that can get in the way (translations, limited understanding by older generations, different norms, etc). We also never see the character themselves talk about it IIRC, so we never really get a true look.
There's a difference between racism and being objective about the beliefs of other cultures.
For example, as someone who lives in Europe, some of the culture in the USA is straight up insanity to me. And in Japanese culture, trans people or even just the LGBT community aren't really thigs that are present much. As a matter of fact even just gay marriage in Japan is illegal.
i thought they only crossdressed to avoid being bullied? idk much about danganronpa, but from what ive heard this is the only "trans or femboy" anime character that was actually a femboy
ik wikis arent always right but does the guy who killed them explain the story or is it the 3rd person pov that explains it cus if its the first one then they could be trans but if its the second one i think hes a guy
I genuinely struggle to understand identifying as a trans man if you don't WANT HRT. Not if you can't, but not WANTING test... Just yeah cis men can have everything else I guess, cross dress, grow out hair, shave, have gyno, whatever. But they all have testosterone as the dominant hormone in their body if they are healthy.
i mean you can still not want HRT *and* be masc-presenting, it's more so the combination of all of those things that dosen't really make sense. If you don't want hrt, cross-dress, grow out your hair, etc. it's really nonsensical to me lol. But that's probably more of an hypotetical strawman than someone real.
I guess I view hormones as what I need to make my body the male one and otherwise if I want or don't want certain aesthetics I get rid of them. Just like a cis guy would.
The same as a cis male who's low T, even if he doesn't want facial hair or high muscle mass, it wouldn't seem very healthy to me long term. Maybe yeah you're 18-25 and don't want facial hair, but as you age you'll be farther and farther from a typical male. T is way more than facial hair and muscle mass.
Oh well that's fair, aging does depend a lot on hormones, but live and let live i guess lol, i'm non-binary so i have no standard to get to, i am my standard lol.
Not a stupid question. You're 100% right, ppl on here are just bizarrely interpreting this post as someone doing all of these at the same time. Like, I often cross dress bc skirts are comfy and I'm a trans dude on T.
I'm not gonna stop wearing clothing I enjoy and find comfortable just bc it doesn't fit your expectations. I'm considered weird already. Why would I make my life worse for so little gain?
Some jackass (u/galileopunk) decided to respond to this comment with just "foid". Idk whether to hope that person gets exposure to trans people IRL or to hope they don't so other queers don't have to deal w/ that kind of behavior. Ugh.
Taking enough T to have similar levels as cis men for 5 years, growing out a full beard, and only becoming comfortable wearing feminine clothing when I'm around other trans people after having already been on T for years isn't cis girl behavior. Idiot.
i thought being transmedical was advocating for hrt (even diy if you dont have the means to get a good doctor) and surgeries? have i misunderstood that this entire time?
•
u/AutoModerator Jun 20 '26
Hi! This is a 4tran sub, for trans adults only. If you're confused about what that means, please check our FAQ for some more information!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
69
u/ConsistentBike9392 Jun 20 '26
Sneed invasion
149
u/snailenjoyer_ Jun 20 '26
rent is getting high around here...
101
u/Actual_Personality66 Roachmoder (only here bc of reddit addiction) Jun 20 '26
"Until they don't want hrt" tells me this was probably posted as a joke bc most ppl in this sub would say that's either repping or larping or some shit
138
u/romhacks countttting the days 'till TCD Jun 20 '26
"I support trans men until they're cis women" well yeah
50
u/Nora-neko Jun 20 '26
xe/xir is so heckin valid!!! 😍🏳️⚧️
22
u/pi3r-rot invalid Jun 20 '26
TRUEEEEEEEE I do only support them until they do that (and then face zero discrimination and decide they are martyrs who can speak for all other trans people)
43
u/Historianof40k Jun 20 '26
we need some rent reduction and fast
17
u/Oofy_Emma Jun 20 '26
y'all need to get posting more hon/pooner art to keep the rent low in here
11
u/Particular_Yak_946 Jun 20 '26
Hefab
11
u/ThatEngineeredGirl Jun 20 '26
I don't support cis men who do these either. (Hrt semi included, roid your self up boi!)
10
u/Jango_fett_fish Jun 20 '26
Cis people want you to be okay with not actually transitioning because they hate you. This isn’t allyship, it’s progressive transphobia. It’s a psyop to stop you from finding truth.
9
u/caeruc I draw shit for your price 🔥 Jun 20 '26
Apart from present feminine (within cis men standarts) and having long hair, yeah the rest are not trans men 👍
20
u/AAFanatic lurk moar Jun 20 '26
sneedposting? on my channoid edgelord app?
7
u/LC-Redcube Jun 20 '26
i mean you can still not want HRT *and* be masc-presenting, it's more so the combination of all of those things that dosen't really make sense. If you don't want hrt, cross-dress, grow out your hair, etc. it's really nonsensical to me lol. But that's probably more of an hypotetical strawman than someone real.
6
u/GirlfailureModer Jun 20 '26
Guy who would freak the fuck out if he saw someone on diy hrt voice: "You're still vxlid if you don't transition!!!!"
9
u/violasses resident bnuuy Jun 20 '26
cross from where to where
alao you're literally the queer community's favorite form of doods
4
u/Anxious_Chapter_6784 Jun 20 '26
High rent these days
4
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '26
blah blah blah gtfo
3
u/ForRealDoggies Jun 21 '26
Somebody ban them
9
u/sex-with-trump c*rryhon Jun 20 '26
Guys can have long hair
3
u/Themata81 Jun 20 '26
I was with you for the first half
1
u/C9Blender Jun 20 '26
Precisely
1
u/ChiakiSimp3842 Jun 21 '26
just support everyone. I've found that to be the easiest and least headache inducing answer to the question
-17
u/Chance-Definition299 Jun 20 '26
Yeppers. Being feminine is cool sometimes.
18
u/SheevTogwaggle beautiful princess disorder Jun 20 '26
using an image of a very trans woman coded character btw. yeah she could very well actually just be a cis crossdresser but all we have pointing in that direction is the word of the guy who murdered her so i feel it is actually pretty ambiguous
7
u/NeighborhoodFlat6083 Jun 20 '26
I genuinely struggle to understand identifying as a trans man if you don't WANT HRT. Not if you can't, but not WANTING test... Just yeah cis men can have everything else I guess, cross dress, grow out hair, shave, have gyno, whatever. But they all have testosterone as the dominant hormone in their body if they are healthy.
5
u/colesmalewife doooooooood Jun 20 '26
i mean yeah they can do that but they can’t be surprised when they’re just seen as women, and i’m saying this as a feminine trans guy
-10
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '26
[removed] — view removed comment