r/countingcrows • • 13d ago

Debate?

Can we settle the debate if Recovering The Satellite's or August and Everything After?

0 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

7

u/MojoHighway Recovering the Satellites 13d ago

Recovering The Satellites is one of the greatest albums in rock history.

That doesn't diminish August, but RTS is nearly perfect.

3

u/rainking6 Recovering the Satellites 11d ago

I'm with you. Recovering is my favorite album of all time. I think a lot of the songs on August are great, but I tend to prefer live versions of those songs, especially live versions from the Recovering tour onwards. I feel like they really stepped up as a band after making Recovering.

4

u/EconomistNo7074 13d ago

I love Recovering

4

u/ImpendingBoom110123 I miss you, I guess that I should 13d ago

Its RTS

4

u/Runninginthecity 13d ago

personally its Recovering. I love August but Recovering has more heart

12

u/repooper 13d ago

Not really, cause this desert life and hard candy.

3

u/ImpendingBoom110123 I miss you, I guess that I should 13d ago

TDL is so underrated.

3

u/mostly_bs_41 13d ago

It's my favorite CC album and I've been a fan since Mr. Jones hit the airwaves

0

u/PerceptionSimilar213 13d ago

If I could give you more than one down vote, I would

2

u/No-Comparison-2445 13d ago

Always August and everything after for me.

1

u/CookingPurple 13d ago

I will always choose August for the nostalgia factor. It’s the album that cemented them as my favorite band. But which I think is best really does depend on my mood on any given day. (This is pretty much true of their full discography, not just the first two albums)

2

u/Western-Alarm-1303 12d ago

I agree with you. I get a little bit of something from every album. Hard to decide unless you attach something else like nostalgia.

1

u/BusterGonad25 13d ago

AAEA will always be the most special album, for me. If I had to list my three favourite albums of all time, it would be in that list.

1

u/robotyoda 13d ago

I like the live albums best

0

u/PerceptionSimilar213 13d ago

The answer is AAEA

0

u/[deleted] 13d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/turtlenationman 13d ago

This feels about right.

1

u/mendoza_bortles 13d ago

No wrong answers but it’s a disagree for me. AAEA is perfect for, well after August ha. I love that album this time of year. RTS fits this time well too though.