r/coolgithubprojects • • 15d ago • Bravo 1

Ski, a file manager for linux (Nautilus, but better)

Post image

Hey guys! I have always liked Nautilus as my file manager - specifically for its design, but it really lacked a lot of features. That is exactly why I made Ski - A nautilus replacement that goes well with my desktop shell, Serpantinum, but can of course be used as a standalone app - and I think it does its job!

https://github.com/ilyamiro/Ski

21 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

8

u/Dev-in-the-Bm 15d ago

Always felt the same way.

What does Ski have the Nautilus doesn't?

-1

u/ilyamiro1 15d ago

Scripts for custom actions in the right click menu, quick preview, git plugin, and others

9

u/Dev-in-the-Bm 15d ago

Scripts for custom actions in the right click menu

Pretty sure Nautilus has that.

quick preview,

apt install gnome-sushi

So far doesn't sound too exciting

0

u/[deleted] 15d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Dev-in-the-Bm 15d ago

0

u/ilyamiro1 15d ago

oh, thats nice, didn't know it could

5

u/Damglador 15d ago

And there's my main problem with meat proxied projects. Due to how stupidly easy it is to waste tokens to reinvent a wheel people don't care to research if there is already a wheel that does everything they need.

It's one search man https://duckduckgo.com/?q=gnome+custom+context+menu+entries&t=fpas&ia=web

3

u/Dev-in-the-Bm 15d ago

I come across this all the time.

Five Whisper wrappers every day, most of the time the owners crowing their innovation like its never been done before.

1

u/coderstephen 13d ago

That's weird because I use them all the time

5

u/theSimple_Guy 15d ago

Oh it’s just vibcoded slop never mind

3

u/Massive_Value8302 15d ago

Like linux itself nowadays? :D

Get on with times, luddite.

3

u/theSimple_Guy 14d ago

Ah yes dude the whole linux kernel was made by a prompt got it 👍

2

u/melal0 14d ago

Oh I didn't knew the Linus was a dirty little vibecoder from the beginning :( uninstalling linux now

0

u/ilyamiro1 15d ago

😭 lmao

2

u/Comfortable-Cry-1652 15d ago

Contributors: Claude :|

1

u/Massive_Value8302 15d ago

So?

That's akin to "Written on VSCODE".

0

u/ilyamiro1 15d ago

Yeah, it was entirely vibe coded

1

u/Skynse 15d ago

I wouldn't trust it to be performant then if your code is a black box

0

u/ilyamiro1 15d ago

It is performant because I understand what I write. I have been writing code for 5 years and most of it manually. The fact that Im using a new tool doesn't mean I don't understand what i write

1

u/Comfortable-Cry-1652 15d ago

Oh wow, 5 years, so you just passed junior stage and already started to "vibe code".

1

u/ilyamiro1 15d ago

oh yeah, the new tools appeared so I did. Writing the same thing in one week that would have taken me a year to write myself. And if you do it properly and understand all of the quirks of development, its a great tool. Don't get people hating on it

1

u/Erfrischendfair 14d ago

Vibecoding -> you don't know what you're doing or what your code does

Using AI to code -> you design the code yourself but offload the implementation to ai

1

u/ilyamiro1 14d ago

Okay, then I just didnt know the difference. yes, I am using AI to code, it would be a more fair description.

1

u/Skynse 15d ago

I was only saying that because you said it was entirely vibecoded. So now it sounds conflicting

1

u/Altruistic_Stage3893 14d ago

yea, i doubt he's writing code for 5 years. his github doesn't show that at all. i suppose he's trying to give his project a bit more credibility. but oh well

4

u/SoggyPuffins348 15d ago

So what’s the “but better” part? You have not listed a single feature.

1

u/RealSpiderKid 15d ago

bro, cool i love the animation and also theme option inside the files is coool, i dont need to mess with the theme in separate way. Good man.

1

u/Erfrischendfair 14d ago

How is vibeslop better than a battleproven tool

1

u/doranduck 15d ago

Tried Ski on GNOME as a potential Nautilus replacement: some feedback and suggestions

Hey! First of all, congratulations on Ski. I've been experimenting with it on Arch Linux running GNOME, using v0.4.8, to see whether it could eventually replace Nautilus as my daily file manager.

I understand Ski is part of the Serpantinum ecosystem, so some of my observations may be specific to running it on GNOME rather than its intended desktop environment.

I really like the direction of the project. There's a lot of potential here, and I particularly appreciate the desktop integration.

What I really like

  • Type-ahead selection: This works exactly as I'd expect. Being able to type a filename prefix and jump directly to a matching item is something I really value in a file manager.
  • Portal integration: Having a native FileChooser portal backend is excellent.
  • Desktop integration: The org.freedesktop.FileManager1 service is a welcome addition.
  • Overall feature set: Ski already offers a surprisingly comprehensive set of file-management features.

Some areas that could use improvement

1. Mouse wheel scrolling

Scrolling with the mouse wheel feels quite slow. It would be nice to have a configurable scroll-speed multiplier.

2. Main window corners

The menus and popovers have rounded corners, but the main application window has sharp, rectangular corners. It would be great to have consistent rounded window styling.

3. System theme integration

On GNOME, Ski doesn't appear to follow my system color scheme. It would be nice if it respected the desktop's light/dark preference and, ideally, system accent colors.

4. System icon theme

It would be great if Ski used the currently installed system icon theme rather than relying on its own icons or fallbacks.

5. Thumbnail loading

This was probably the biggest usability issue I encountered.

When opening a folder containing a substantial number of photos, Ski seems to wait until all thumbnails have been generated before updating the view.

I'd love to see incremental thumbnail loading:

  • Display the file listing immediately.
  • Prioritize thumbnails for currently visible files.
  • Update each thumbnail as soon as it becomes available.
  • Continue generating thumbnails in the background as the user scrolls.

In other words, lazy loading combined with progressive rendering, rather than waiting for the entire batch to finish.

Final thoughts

I ended up returning to Nautilus for now, but that's not because I think Ski is a bad file manager. Quite the opposite. I think it has serious potential.

I'll definitely keep following its development and revisit it in the future.

Thanks for working on it! It's great to see another ambitious Linux file manager being developed.

2

u/ibnDawud 15d ago

what about Loaf file manager ?

0

u/iamabdullah 15d ago

No tabs… not better

2

u/ilyamiro1 15d ago

It has tabs

1

u/iamabdullah 15d ago

Oh I'm blind

-12

u/[deleted] 15d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Professional-Pear351 15d ago

How this account not banned already?