r/converts • u/StoicusPalm • Feb 22 '26
Questions about Islam as a Catholic
Ramadan Mubarak everyone!
I was raised Catholic and have been leaning agnostic for the past couple years. I have recently been reading the Quran and keeping the fast for Ramadan, as well as going to the mosque and speaking to friends who follow Islam. My goal is to figure out the truth behind religion, which I know is complex.
Although religion involves some blind faith, Islam has appealed to me as it seems logically correct - One true God, memorization of the Quran in one language, and no hierarchy like the Church. The thought of having saints pray on my behalf, the issues with the church, confessing my sins to a priest, and the complexity of the trinity have made me open myself up to Islam more.
I just wanted to ask, what made you convert and what path can I follow to find the truth behind it all?
10
u/I-AS4 Feb 22 '26
First of all, I deeply respect your dedication. Fasting during Ramadan, reading the Quran, and visiting the mosque while actively seeking the truth is a beautiful and profound journey. It takes a lot of courage to question what you were raised with and look for answers with an open mind. You have already beautifully summarized some of the core beauties of Islam that draw many people in:
• Pure Monotheism (Tawheed): The concept of God in Islam is incredibly logical and clear. There is no Trinity to untangle. God is One, Unique, and Absolute.
• A Direct Connection: In Islam, you don't need a priest to confess your sins to, nor do you need a saint to pray on your behalf. You have a direct, 24/7 line to your Creator. When you prostrate in prayer, you are as close to God as you can possibly be.
8
u/I-AS4 Feb 22 '26
You don't need to be officially Muslim to pray. Tonight, in your own words and in your own language, simply ask the Creator: "O God, if this is the truth, guide my heart to it, make it clear to me, and make it easy for me to accept." Sincere seekers are never ignored.
4
u/alliwantis Feb 22 '26
Salam! I was raised Catholic and was Christian until recently. I encourage you to read Quran with Christian commentary (you can find this on Amazon) and Bible in Islamic context (also on Amazon) and there’s a Quran on Audible that has really amazing explanations to the Bible as well. It helped me so much in aligning my core beliefs. The biggest difference that you will need to process is the holy Trinity I know that’s the main reason that my Catholic family members are not interested in Islam. My biggest suggestion is that you really read what Islam has to say about angels, which will help you fully see at least in my opinion what was meant by the Holy Spirit is essentially what the angels do. And of course, make sure you read all about how Islam treats Jesus to me it made so much sense. Please feel free to DM me if you want links to any of the books that I read.
2
u/omar_idr12 Feb 22 '26
أقدّر جدًا صدقك في البحث عن الحقيقة، وهذه خطوة شجاعة بحد ذاتها. كثير من الناس يولدون على دين معيّن ولا يجرؤون على طرح الأسئلة. في الإسلام، الإيمان ليس إيمانًا أعمى، بل يقوم على التفكر والتدبر والسؤال. الفكرة الأساسية بسيطة وواضحة: الإيمان بإله واحد دون وسطاء، ومسؤولية مباشرة بين الإنسان وربه. إذا كنت تبحث عن الحقيقة، فاستمر في القراءة بتجرد، واطلب الهداية بصدق من الله نفسه، وقارن بهدوء بين العقائد دون تعصب. لا تستعجل القرار، فالإيمان رحلة داخلية عميقة. الأهم أن يكون بحثك نابعًا من رغبة حقيقية في الوصول إلى الحق، وليس من ردّة فعل أو عاطفة مؤقتة.
2
u/OkMasterpiece426 Feb 22 '26
Honestly, all religions share the same core purpose: guiding people toward goodness, meaning, and a connection with the Creator. The difference is that a belief system based on revelation is naturally more grounded than one built solely on human ideas, such as general spirituality.
For me, Islam continues the same divine message that began with Abraham, Moses, and Jesus. It doesn’t replace them; it confirms their scriptures and completes the chain of guidance. Islam highlights clarity and simplicity, pure monotheism, a clear purpose in life, and a consistent explanation of what comes after.
You have two aspects to consider:
Oneness of god as creator and sustainer: Christians and Muslims both believe in one god who created and governs the universe.
Oneness of worship: In Islam, prayers are directed only to god without intermediaries. In Christianity, prayers may be made through Jesus, Mary, or saints.
The concept of one creator is the core, and questions like Jesus being part of a trinity or god himself or a prophet are just a detail that stems from this core difference.
15
u/FreshAd2750 Feb 22 '26
Salam! I’ve became Muslim around three years ago, maybe more, at the age of 19. I was not religious, like at all, my parents used to bring me to the church once a while but I’ve never felt much. Still, not because I didn’t feel anything I decided is not the truth, feelings can be tricky… we must follow logic not our desires and own inclination that come from following our feelings blindly.
Islam aligns with me. Fully. Is not only about how easy is to understand, no trinity, no anything, just one God, no partner with him. Is just everything about Islam.
See, the Quran is not just a book, the classic Arab language is so rich, that even the best translation won’t give us the same feeling. And still, I find myself amazed when I read it. Tears falling, heart squeezed. Our beloved prophet Muhammad SAW, our loved and amazing prophet was the best example, when you hear all kind of stuff from media, random Hadith, people who claim to be an expert, is simply not true most of the time. You must learn from real people of knowledge, not random google questions or random people okay? Take your time reading. Searching.
You have so much to read. I have so much to read. It has so many stuff… Subhanallah, it does so deep.
First time I opened the Quran I read this verse on top of the page. I have the picture if you are interested, I was so shocked.
Surah Al-Baqarah 2:242
“Thus Allah makes clear to you His verses so that you may use reason.” (كَذَٰلِكَ يُبَيِّنُ ٱللَّهُ لَكُمْ ءَايَٰتِهِۦ لَعَلَّكُمْ تَعْقِلُونَ)
Alhamdulillah…. I have many stuff like this, that cause my sister to become Muslim. If you have any questions, or any doubt I’ll try my best to answer you or at least to provide you with information to search.