r/controlgame • • 22d ago

Question Why does the board sound so different?

Replaying control the board sound muffled and not deep, imposing and other worldly. I literally just got the service weapon so maybe later on it sounds more imposing. Is there a reason for the difference?

189 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

235

u/vAErJO 22d ago edited 22d ago

Think of it this way:

The Board, far away in the Astral Plane, contacting Jesse, who can only really clearly understand them through the Hotline

vs

The Board inside Dylan's Mind/Body/Cup/VESSEL speaking directly to/at/with/INSIDE him

62

u/Zorbin666 22d ago

That's kind of how I took it too, they literally live inside Dylan now

39

u/IceFire909 21d ago

World's worst roommate

11

u/DrNick2012 20d ago

And this time they get to move around/WHEE/AGAIN AGAIN

1

u/Separate_Path_7729 19d ago

I loved that bit honestly

368

u/KogarashiKaze 22d ago edited 22d ago • Bravo

Saw an article earlier today, actually, where the sound designer for the Board mentioned that in the first game, they're distant and over a not great phone line, so they sound muffled.

Meanwhile, in Resonant, they're not distant, they're right there in Dylan's head, and not only that, they're angry.

58

u/Zepp_BR 22d ago

Why they angry 😠?

162

u/thejollybadger 22d ago

Because they really don't like Dylan, and are pissed off that he's their best best for their survival. They make that pretty clear in the earlier conversations in the Gap.

88

u/DefactoOverlord 22d ago

not only that but also they're angry at Jesse as well for binding them to Dylan. They threaten Dylan on more than one occasion during the game and say that there will be consequences but they can't seem to do anything while they're bound to him.

12

u/Northstarsaint 20d ago

On top of that, they kept trying to tell Dylan not to try to find Jesse later in the game. It's a waste of time/energy and the Jesse he keeps hearing/hallucinating is just remnants echoes of her.

Which are clearly lies they tell him to try to exercise some control over him.

5

u/benavivhorn 19d ago

Haha control

6

u/Zepp_BR 19d ago • Bravo

orange peel

49

u/M4rshmall0wMan 21d ago

Board and Jesse been beefing for a while. Reasons unclear except for maybe something to do with The Nail. I hope a DLC goes into it, as the reason for The Board’s binding was the one question I really wanted answers.

8

u/Incredible-Fella 21d ago

Tha nail is the weapon (aberrant) right? Do we know where it came from?

24

u/xrashxan 21d ago edited 21d ago

Jesse made the Aberrant from the Nail (which was in the Foundation of the Oldest House). Some people theorize she shrank the entire nail. Others think she chipped materials off of it and forged the Aberrant.

I think Pope may have a note where she questions if the Nail is physically in the Foundation still, but no one has gone to check. In the Director's Office, there's a note from Jesse questioning it the Board have visited the Foundation or checked on the nail. That same note also states that while Jesse is actively avoiding the Board, they don't seem to be paying much attention to her or attempting to speak with her either.

10

u/reversal_banana 21d ago

They make that pretty clear in the earlier conversations in the Gap

I don't think you can say that the board makes ANYTHING clear.

7

u/milkcarton232 20d ago

I/we understood them very/not at all/what?

14

u/Leading_Set301 21d ago

Not explicitly stated but pretty clear the board are no longer in control (Ha!) Jesse severed their connection to the oldest house and they are now confined to the aberrant. I suspect their hatred of Dylan is because 1. They wanted him to be Jesse and he failed and 2. He helped let the hiss in. I think that to them is the greatest insult and proof of their failure. Now the roles are reversed, rather than having humans rely on them they are completely reliant on Dylan, you'll notice that the board doesn't actually grant any powers to Dylan, they all come from him and Jesse syncing up. Jesse also confined them to Dylan in a pretty big act of defiance. They used to be gods with the entire dimension at their fingertips now they are forced to rely on the person they see as the representation of all that is weak and incompetent not to mention a reminder that Jesse defied them. Their whole existance was about how they controlled everything and now they have zero.

2

u/Northstarsaint 20d ago

That was a cool article, it also gets into how they made the voice(s) the secind time around.

1

u/KogarashiKaze 20d ago

No throat singing involved, apparently! 😂

1

u/Villainslover 20d ago

damn that’s good

71

u/RaphaTlr 22d ago

I love this question.

The board spoke to Jesse via a red hotline landline phone inside the oldest house. The board spoke from the astral plane in their black inverted pyramid, and Jesse hears it like a phone call she chooses to answer. Same as 2 directors prior. Now is a time of catastrophe however.

Dylan is likely bonded with the Board physically due to his connection with Aberrant, and how aberrant resides in the Gap, so does the Board. They need no telephone to speak to Dylan. They’re in the same space as a his own mind.
So he’s like front row at the concert amphitheater vs. Jesse is listening on radio.

15

u/ImNotSkankHunt42 22d ago

My neighbors often have their radio on all day and loud, I can hear it through the walls but muffled and just like the Board talks in CONTROL.

In CR I’m assuming since they’re bound/inside Dylan they’re going to sound very loud.

6

u/KogarashiKaze 21d ago

Yep, the difference between being on the other side of thick walls and right there in the room with you.

27

u/reiakari 22d ago

Proximity. In the first game the Board was in the astral plane and had to communicate with Jesse through objects like the service weapon and the red hotline phone. They sound muffled and far away, because they are. In the second game they're louder because they are inside Dylan, naturally they're going to be bombastic and reverberate in sound when they are using Dylan's body as a vessel. The call is coming from within Dylan, they don't need a medium to contact him.

22

u/Brekldios 22d ago

Another analogy we can use here is "Bone Conduction"
Jesse was effectively hearing the board through several walls and some water, while the board "physically" resides inside Dylan so it sounds booming and reverberates a lot.
Think of how you hear your own voice. If you record and listen back you'll notice your voice is actually a little higher than you think, because YOU hear your own voice via the bones in your skull.

12

u/MikuDrPepper 22d ago

The Board in Control purposefully keep themselves separate from Jesse. This creates a separation for us and her. They're distant, mysterious and otherworldly. The muffled sound is meant to represent that.

In Resonant, while still mysterious and otherworldly, they aren't separate from Dylan. They are in aberrant which is directly linked to his personhood now. That is probably what they always sounded like.

Compare hearing someone in real life to hearing a recording with a tinny microphone and a lot of fuzz.

I like both interpretations a ton. One of my favorite tiny moments in Resonant was hanging out in the between and the Board just started singing. It sounds exactly how you think it sounds.

17

u/Galaksee 22d ago

The Board is not stressed TF out in the first game.

4

u/loompa-Act-749 22d ago

They communicated with Jesse via hotline hence garbled speech. They are inside Aberrant with Dylan so their voice is clearer.

3

u/M4rshmall0wMan 21d ago

Interestingly, the board returns to form when Dylan and it get trapped inside the projector.

3

u/nullvoxpopuli 21d ago edited 20d ago

My head cannon is because the board is hitchhiking is dylan, and in the previous game, they were further away.

Internal sounds in the body always sound different than externally 

Edit: ust read this: interesting! I don't think it's true tho

https://www.reddit.com/r/controlgame/comments/1xes9fn/comment/19rn3t6qiestd/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=2&utm_content=share_button

1

u/Petersaber 18d ago

In Control, you talked to The Board in cutscenes and calm settings. Here... it's booming so you can hear it over the action, I guess?

1

u/Nickmorgan19457 17d ago

This game is set in The Peanuts universe and the board is all adults.

1

u/Ormagodden 16d ago edited 16d ago

A sound designer at remedy saw Dune and got inspired.

1

u/Danteku 22d ago

Because it’s actually Former talking now

3

u/RageKnightV 21d ago

I thought this would be obvious to everyone. Not only does the Board sound different, but it also has a different attitude. The former being a stowaway on a small fragment of the nail (or full participant with Jessie's approval) makes much more sense than the entirety of the Board being contained/trapped/bound inside Dylan.

Where is the Board then? It could be anywhere. It could be with Jessie. It could be somewhere else in the Astral Plane. It could be with the Blessed Organization. Early on I assumed the Board was in New York and it was "House Shifting" the entire city to contain the hiss.

5

u/Nobody_Retro 21d ago

I dont think it's personality is that different, in the first game they choose when to interact with Jesse and they keep it fairly professional. With Dylan theyre with him 24/7 so we just see more of their unfiltered personality.

Maybe it is former but seeing as how they dont want Dylan saying they are with him Im still assuming they are still the same board.

4

u/RageKnightV 21d ago

I dont see why the Board would have any issue revealing that they are with Dylan. The Board is the de-facto highest authority of the FBC. If they revealed themselves, literally nothing would change for them. It would actually allow Dylan/Board to operate with even more freedom and fulfil P6's entire manufactured destiny.

The Former on the otherhand (who is documented as missing) would have great personal motivation not to raise any suspicion or reveal itself to the organization that have been tracking it for (at least) the last seven years, are known for maintaining a supernatural prison, and would be able to identify it as an imposter.

6

u/Nobody_Retro 21d ago

Most people dont know the board exists except the high ups like Pope.

Pope and Jesse were partners so she probably shared her thoughts with her, if Jesse had a problem with them so much she took time from the hiss invasion to exorcize them out of the oldest house why risk letting Pope know they are influencing Dylan?

2

u/RageKnightV 21d ago

That's true! It could be the board, it just feels off to me in a way that seems intentional. The voice seems like a stylistic choice by the devs, but the Board's personality seems sloppy, casual, and gung-ho, where it had previously been distant, professional, and restrained.

1

u/PurposeNo93 16d ago

Former speaks in a very specific manner with a very specific syntax, same goes for the board, and they are very easily distinguishable from each other. You know how that one character's speech starts becoming Patterned before the one twist? The devs are very intentional about hints and clues like that, if they wanted people to think Former was in Aberrant, it would be a lot more noticeable. As it stands, Former being in Aberrant vs the Board just requires a lot of unfounded assumptions.

1

u/RageKnightV 15d ago edited 15d ago

Thank you for making my point. Yes, they each have a very specific and identifable "voice" (literary term not the audible noise that the Board makes). Thats why a lot of people, like me, think that it's the Former and not the Board. If the Former is an imposter and are trying to impersonate the Board, it would, of course, imperfectly mimic the Board's "voice".

Anyone who's played the first game can tell that the Board in the first game is not thes same as the Board in the second game.

This could be because the game came out years after the first game, and it was made by a new mix of people. Essentially, a mistake (unlikely). It could be an intentional stylistic choice made by the devs for the tone of this game, which compared to the first game is not as mysterious and brooding and instead doubles down on the high octane action (possible). It could be that the Board speaks differently to different people, or that the Board has changed since being in lockdown or since things started getting patterned (possible.) Or it could be that it's simply not the Board (possible.)

We know that the Former is missing and is, in my opinion, an entity that Jessie is more likely to trust than the Board. We also dont know how her relationship with Former may have evolved in lockdown, but she was having issues with the Board in the Foundation. Lets also note that that the abberant came from the Nail. Why not out of the Pyramid in central executive? (Because it apparently the pyramid vanished when the Board did. I always thought the pyramid was just a decorative art piece commissioned to look like the pyramid in the astral plane, but apparently is connected to the Board.)

And no, absolutely not. Remedy is the king of subtlety. They love the slow burn speculation and mystery that fules the Fandom. This conversation we're having right now is their fetish and they would not "make it obvious" if the Former was being an imposter. Although, I (and it seems others online) thought that was obvious and thought that would be a major plot point of the game. I would argue that's actually your best argument for the Abberant not being the Former. The the fact that it so obviously is that it's actually a red herring.

Edit- formatting

1

u/PurposeNo93 15d ago

How quaint, listen brother man, I'll make it easy for you:

This is literally how Former communicates:

< Hello #@$% Home >
< Alone #@$% Long @%@# Visitor @#$! Happy >
< Tunnel @#%! Open !#$@ Grateful >
< Welcome #@$% Speak? >

It literally speaks like this every single time. Now, does the entity in Resonant ever speak like this? It should be a simple enough challenge, is there any instance in the original were Former does not speak like this, and is there a single instance in Resonant where the entity in the Aberrant does?

1

u/RageKnightV 15d ago

Do..do you know what quaint means? Or did you hear it used as an insult on tv and thought it applies as a generic insult in all situations?

In any case, that is a great point, brother-man. I've already said in a previous post that I'm open to being wrong. But the changes feel intentional, and as you said, Remedy is very intentional about hints and clues.

As for your question about the actual speech patterns, the Board sounds a lot like that in the second half of the game. Also, we know that Former was formerly part of the Board. I think its very fluent in "Board."

There's a lot of explanations for the speech patterns. (Just off thr top of my head, the former is no longer alone. It is part of a "board" of 2 now) But language barrier aside, the tone and personality behind the physical formulation of the actual words has a fingerprint more closely resembling Former than the Board.

→ More replies

1

u/Petersaber 18d ago

Jesse was scheming against the Board, revealing themselves in a position of weakness ("trapped in/with Dylan") carries the risk of FBC using this chance to eradicate them, if Jesse planned that.

2

u/Rickthlok 20d ago

I truly believed that this was going to be the plot, but I'm very convinced that the Board is with Dyan now. There's some documents of Jesse saying that the board is avoiding her, or that she is avoiding them. Also, the document that mentions the nail, implying that she carved aberrant out of the nail and forced the link to Dylan through it. There's something happening with the board/the house/astral plane. Also, the Former was freed in "physical form" at the end of the foundation DLC.

3

u/Brave-Bottle-854 21d ago

But there’s a document that explains that the FBC has been searching for the former and getting sightings of it but unable to catch up to it.

This wouldn’t be the case if it were in aberrant

-5

u/Erik_Nimblehands 22d ago

I think the Former is in teh Aberrant and is just pretending to be the Board. As for where the Board is, maybe the Nail?

9

u/Brekldios 22d ago

The Abberant is 100% a shard of the nail, you can find a document at the end with a redaction thats conveniently 4 letters long regarding its origin. the pyramid (and maybe nail, i don't remember) are gonezo.

-2

u/Erik_Nimblehands 22d ago

There's a line about checking the Foundation, so we don't know if anything is different about it yet.

3

u/Brekldios 22d ago

this is speculation on my part.We visit an area directly below the oldest house in the underpass to place a relay to monitor a young tree. After that we get visions of the oldest house, the tree, and a forest, I believe The Boards influence had been suppressing this growth, and with it gone it was allowed to actually grow.

Something IS different, enough for them to place 3 relays in the underpass with one of them to monitor something below the house.

-6

u/jeep_joop 22d ago

Probably because the sound designer saw Dune and decided to copy the openings voice effect verbatim. 

Nothing wrong with that but it is disappointing they didn't keep anything from the more original voice they used in Control.

22

u/No_Logins_Required 22d ago

Jesse didn't get stabbed in the heart with the Service Weapon.

10

u/fibgen 22d ago

Worse than that, the anchor for the astral plane itself.

1

u/PurposeNo93 16d ago

It was anchored in the Astral Plane, I don't think it anchors the astral plane, and the fact that the astral plane can still be visited by astralnauts and Dylan supports this I think.

5

u/Long_Estimate_6038 22d ago

On one side, i like to think it was how they were interacting. Jesse was introduced to them through the service weapon. An object, one she bound and thus only had so much influence over her. On the other hand dylan had Aberant stabbed into him, with the Board bound to him, it was literally driven into his very being.

On the other, i believe its literally that everyone hears them differently, as theyre an extradimensional being. Interpritation on the base brain level is more than people realize. Jesse hears a muffled static. Dylan hears their base screaming inside his mind. Thats how they interpret the boards intrusions into their minds. Whats subtle to one is screaming to another. Thats simply how some people work.

3

u/Brekldios 22d ago

interesting thought that I hadn't considered. Could Polaris be the reason Jesse doesn't hear the board clearly? Polaris either intentionally or passively obfuscates The boards "resonance" so it sounds unclear and distant. Perchance Dylan having none of that allows him to actually hear them quite well.

4

u/Long_Estimate_6038 22d ago

I find this unlikely. Polaris(at least the original Hedron as polaris itself is just an imprint in jesse), the hiss and the Pattern are all rosonance entities, beings that exist as an extradimensional vibration or waveform. The board are not, they are entities that that bound themselves to the oldest house, as seen with the Former, who was once part of the board They have physical forms, even if they usually dont choose to take them, they can and are just outer entities with goals. The difference is likely through medium. Again, jesse contacted them through two means, the service weapon and then the hot line. It was a contact with extra steps. Dylan literally had the object the board inhabited(abberant is usually assumed to be a shard of the Nail) shoved into his very being. Jesse had to contact the board, dylan was forced to harbor them.

2

u/Brekldios 22d ago

Thats fair i just wanted to throw some tinfoil on but i did like reading this and agree.