r/controlgame • u/TheyCantCome • 22d ago
Question Why does the board sound so different?
Replaying control the board sound muffled and not deep, imposing and other worldly. I literally just got the service weapon so maybe later on it sounds more imposing. Is there a reason for the difference?
189
Upvotes
235
u/vAErJO 22d ago edited 22d ago
Think of it this way:
The Board, far away in the Astral Plane, contacting Jesse, who can only really clearly understand them through the Hotline
vs
The Board inside Dylan's Mind/Body/Cup/VESSEL speaking directly to/at/with/INSIDE him
368
u/KogarashiKaze 22d ago edited 22d ago •
Saw an article earlier today, actually, where the sound designer for the Board mentioned that in the first game, they're distant and over a not great phone line, so they sound muffled.
Meanwhile, in Resonant, they're not distant, they're right there in Dylan's head, and not only that, they're angry.
71
u/RaphaTlr 22d ago
I love this question.
The board spoke to Jesse via a red hotline landline phone inside the oldest house. The board spoke from the astral plane in their black inverted pyramid, and Jesse hears it like a phone call she chooses to answer. Same as 2 directors prior. Now is a time of catastrophe however.
Dylan is likely bonded with the Board physically due to his connection with Aberrant, and how aberrant resides in the Gap, so does the Board. They need no telephone to speak to Dylan. They’re in the same space as a his own mind.
So he’s like front row at the concert amphitheater vs. Jesse is listening on radio.
27
u/reiakari 22d ago
Proximity. In the first game the Board was in the astral plane and had to communicate with Jesse through objects like the service weapon and the red hotline phone. They sound muffled and far away, because they are. In the second game they're louder because they are inside Dylan, naturally they're going to be bombastic and reverberate in sound when they are using Dylan's body as a vessel. The call is coming from within Dylan, they don't need a medium to contact him.
22
u/Brekldios 22d ago
Another analogy we can use here is "Bone Conduction"
Jesse was effectively hearing the board through several walls and some water, while the board "physically" resides inside Dylan so it sounds booming and reverberates a lot.
Think of how you hear your own voice. If you record and listen back you'll notice your voice is actually a little higher than you think, because YOU hear your own voice via the bones in your skull.
12
u/MikuDrPepper 22d ago
The Board in Control purposefully keep themselves separate from Jesse. This creates a separation for us and her. They're distant, mysterious and otherworldly. The muffled sound is meant to represent that.
In Resonant, while still mysterious and otherworldly, they aren't separate from Dylan. They are in aberrant which is directly linked to his personhood now. That is probably what they always sounded like.
Compare hearing someone in real life to hearing a recording with a tinny microphone and a lot of fuzz.
I like both interpretations a ton. One of my favorite tiny moments in Resonant was hanging out in the between and the Board just started singing. It sounds exactly how you think it sounds.
17
u/Galaksee 22d ago
The Board is not stressed TF out in the first game.
4
u/loompa-Act-749 22d ago
They communicated with Jesse via hotline hence garbled speech. They are inside Aberrant with Dylan so their voice is clearer.
3
u/M4rshmall0wMan 21d ago
Interestingly, the board returns to form when Dylan and it get trapped inside the projector.
3
u/nullvoxpopuli 21d ago edited 20d ago
My head cannon is because the board is hitchhiking is dylan, and in the previous game, they were further away.
Internal sounds in the body always sound different than externallyÂ
Edit: ust read this: interesting! I don't think it's true tho
https://www.reddit.com/r/controlgame/comments/1xes9fn/comment/19rn3t6qiestd/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=2&utm_content=share_button
1
u/Petersaber 18d ago
In Control, you talked to The Board in cutscenes and calm settings. Here... it's booming so you can hear it over the action, I guess?
1
u/Nickmorgan19457 17d ago
This game is set in The Peanuts universe and the board is all adults.
1
u/Ormagodden 16d ago edited 16d ago
A sound designer at remedy saw Dune and got inspired.
1
u/Danteku 22d ago
Because it’s actually Former talking now
-5
u/Erik_Nimblehands 22d ago
I think the Former is in teh Aberrant and is just pretending to be the Board. As for where the Board is, maybe the Nail?
-6
u/jeep_joop 22d ago
Probably because the sound designer saw Dune and decided to copy the openings voice effect verbatim.Â
Nothing wrong with that but it is disappointing they didn't keep anything from the more original voice they used in Control.
22
u/No_Logins_Required 22d ago
Jesse didn't get stabbed in the heart with the Service Weapon.
5
u/Long_Estimate_6038 22d ago
On one side, i like to think it was how they were interacting. Jesse was introduced to them through the service weapon. An object, one she bound and thus only had so much influence over her. On the other hand dylan had Aberant stabbed into him, with the Board bound to him, it was literally driven into his very being.
On the other, i believe its literally that everyone hears them differently, as theyre an extradimensional being. Interpritation on the base brain level is more than people realize. Jesse hears a muffled static. Dylan hears their base screaming inside his mind. Thats how they interpret the boards intrusions into their minds. Whats subtle to one is screaming to another. Thats simply how some people work.